This wiki has undergone a migration to Confluence found Here
Difference between revisions of "Data Types R2 issues"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 33: | Line 33: | ||
|- style="background:Lightcyan" | |- style="background:Lightcyan" | ||
| 3 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 3|Add ED.translation]] || ED || Abstract || Applied|| Significant || LM || LM | | 3 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 3|Add ED.translation]] || ED || Abstract || Applied|| Significant || LM || LM | ||
− | |- | + | |- style="background:Lightcyan" |
− | | 4 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 4|Add GTS.code]] || GTS || Abstract || | + | | 4 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 4|Add GTS.code]] || GTS || Abstract || Applied || Very Significant || LM || LM || |
|- style="background:Lightcyan" | |- style="background:Lightcyan" | ||
| 5 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 5|Add HIST.controlActIdRef]] || HIST || Abstract || Applied || Trivial || LM || LM | | 5 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 5|Add HIST.controlActIdRef]] || HIST || Abstract || Applied || Trivial || LM || LM | ||
Line 45: | Line 45: | ||
|- style="background:Lightcyan" | |- style="background:Lightcyan" | ||
| 9 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 9|Clarify BAG-SET-LIST relationship]] || COLL || Abstract || Proposed || Closed|| LM || LM || | | 9 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 9|Clarify BAG-SET-LIST relationship]] || COLL || Abstract || Proposed || Closed|| LM || LM || | ||
− | |- | + | |- style="background:Lightcyan" |
− | | 10 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 10|Create URG constraint on UVP]] || UVP || Abstract || | + | | 10 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 10|Create URG constraint on UVP]] || UVP || Abstract || Gone to Ballot || Very Significant || LM || LM || Voting |
|- style="background:lightcyan" | |- style="background:lightcyan" | ||
| 11 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 11|Derive ADXP and ENXP from SC]] || AD / EN || Abstract || Applied || Trivial || LM || LM | | 11 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 11|Derive ADXP and ENXP from SC]] || AD / EN || Abstract || Applied || Trivial || LM || LM | ||
Line 57: | Line 57: | ||
|- style="background:lightcyan" | |- style="background:lightcyan" | ||
| 17 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 17|Add title or filename to ED]] || ED || Abstract || Applied || Trivial | | 17 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 17|Add title or filename to ED]] || ED || Abstract || Applied || Trivial | ||
− | |- | + | |- style="background:grey" |
− | | 18 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 18|GTS.translation]] || GTS || Abstract || Proposed || | + | | 18 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 18|GTS.translation]] || GTS || Abstract || Proposed || Rejected || || || |
|- style="background:Lightcyan" | |- style="background:Lightcyan" | ||
| 19 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 19|FLAVOR: Add Bounded PIVL (GTS.BOUNDEDPIVL)]] || PIVL || Abstract || Applied || ? | | 19 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 19|FLAVOR: Add Bounded PIVL (GTS.BOUNDEDPIVL)]] || PIVL || Abstract || Applied || ? | ||
Line 77: | Line 77: | ||
|- style="background:lightcyan" | |- style="background:lightcyan" | ||
| 27 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 27|EIVL<TS> Issues]] || EIVL || Abstract || Applied || Significant | | 27 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 27|EIVL<TS> Issues]] || EIVL || Abstract || Applied || Significant | ||
− | |- | + | |- style="background:Lightcyan" |
− | | 28 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 28|GTS literal]] || GTS || XML || | + | | 28 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 28|GTS literal]] || GTS || XML || Applied || Significant || || || |
|- | |- | ||
| 29 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 29|PPD<T> issues]] || PPD || Abstract || Proposed || Significant || || || Waiting for input from Gunther | | 29 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 29|PPD<T> issues]] || PPD || Abstract || Proposed || Significant || || || Waiting for input from Gunther | ||
Line 127: | Line 127: | ||
|- style="background:Lightcyan" | |- style="background:Lightcyan" | ||
| 57 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 57|II.useCode]] || II || Abstract || Applied || Significant || LM || LM | | 57 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 57|II.useCode]] || II || Abstract || Applied || Significant || LM || LM | ||
− | |- | + | |- style="background:Lightcyan" |
− | | 58 || #[[Datatypes R2 Issue 58|GTS Frequency Code]] || GTS || Abstract || | + | | 58 || #[[Datatypes R2 Issue 58|GTS Frequency Code]] || GTS || Abstract || Applied || Signficant || LM || LM || |
|-style="background:Lightcyan" | |-style="background:Lightcyan" | ||
| 59 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 59|Unknown home phone number]] || TEL || Abstract || Applied || Significant || LM || LM | | 59 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 59|Unknown home phone number]] || TEL || Abstract || Applied || Significant || LM || LM | ||
Line 143: | Line 143: | ||
|- style="background:lightcyan" | |- style="background:lightcyan" | ||
| 65 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 65|IVL center/width and low/high issue]] || IVL || Abstract || Applied || Editorial | | 65 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 65|IVL center/width and low/high issue]] || IVL || Abstract || Applied || Editorial | ||
− | |- | + | |- style="background:lightcyan" |
− | | 66 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 66|conformance to preferred OID root]] || II,C* || Abstract || | + | | 66 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 66|conformance to preferred OID root]] || II,C* || Abstract || Gone to Ballot || Significant || || || Waiting for vocab decision |
|- style="background:grey" | |- style="background:grey" | ||
| 67 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 67|Clarification of Promotion and Demotion]] || All || Abstract || ? || Normal || LM || LM | | 67 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 67|Clarification of Promotion and Demotion]] || All || Abstract || ? || Normal || LM || LM | ||
Line 213: | Line 213: | ||
|- style="background:lightcyan" | |- style="background:lightcyan" | ||
| 109 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 109|Invariants on PQR and MO]] || PQ,MO || Abstract || Applied || ? || | | 109 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 109|Invariants on PQR and MO]] || PQ,MO || Abstract || Applied || ? || | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | 110 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 110|BIN/ED/ST Problems]] || ED || Abstract || Proposed || ? || | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | 111 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 111|II type proposal]] || II || Abstract || Proposed || ? || | ||
|- | |- | ||
|} | |} |
Latest revision as of 08:10, 11 April 2008
This is the register of known data types issues for release 2. (R2 XML ITS datatypes has been merged into this list for XML ITS data type issues.)
Status list:
- ? : to be clarified
- clarification: still gathering information
- discussion: clarification is complete. discussion is progressing
- proposal: has been resolved out of committee, waiting for formal resolution in committee
- approved: INM has approved the proposed resolution, waiting for the editor to apply to the document
- complete: editing is complete
- abandoned: proposal has been abandoned
Volunteer column:
- initials indicate willing to participate int resolving the issue
Priority column:
- initials indicate person desires issue to be included in the next release of the Abstract Data Types
- Legend for initials (please add yours): LM - Lloyd McKenzie;
Colours:
- Yellow = approved, ready for editing specification
- grey = closed and abandoned
- pink = ready for INM endorsement
- lightcyan = editing is complete
- line - deferred for R3 or some other discussion
ID | Topic | Type | Category | Status | Ranking | Volunteer | Priority | Status |
1 | Add CD.group | CD | Abstract | Applied | Significant | |||
2 | Add DRVQ mixin for Quantity | QTY | Abstract | Proposed | Very Significant | LM | LM | |
3 | Add ED.translation | ED | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM | |
4 | Add GTS.code | GTS | Abstract | Applied | Very Significant | LM | LM | |
5 | Add HIST.controlActIdRef | HIST | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | LM | LM | |
6 | Add PIVL.frequency | PIVL | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM | |
7 | Add PLIST as LIST ancestor | LIST | Abstract | Rejected | Signficant | LM | LM | |
8 | Add STT datatype | ST | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM | |
9 | Clarify BAG-SET-LIST relationship | COLL | Abstract | Proposed | Closed | LM | LM | |
10 | Create URG constraint on UVP | UVP | Abstract | Gone to Ballot | Very Significant | LM | LM | Voting |
11 | Derive ADXP and ENXP from SC | AD / EN | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | LM | LM | |
12 | Drop identity-equality distinction | ANY | Abstract | Applied | Very Significant | LM | LM | |
13 | Generalize originalText | ANY | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM | |
14 | Relax Unit Constraint on PQ | PQ | Abstract | Applied | Normal | |||
17 | Add title or filename to ED | ED | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | |||
18 | GTS.translation | GTS | Abstract | Proposed | Rejected | |||
19 | FLAVOR: Add Bounded PIVL (GTS.BOUNDEDPIVL) | PIVL | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
20 | Cardinality of IVL<T> | IVL | Abstract | Abandoned | Trivial | LM | LM | |
21 | New mime types for CDA | ED | Abstract | Closed | Trivial | |||
22 | New CD definitions | CD | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | LM | LM | |
23 | Rename Snomed RT | Vocab | Abstract | Applied | Editorial | |||
24 | vocab domain issues | Vocab | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | |||
25 | II.reference | II | Abstract | Closed | Normal | |||
26 | Special CDA Type | ED | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | |||
27 | EIVL<TS> Issues | EIVL | Abstract | Applied | Significant | |||
28 | GTS literal | GTS | XML | Applied | Significant | |||
29 | PPD<T> issues | PPD | Abstract | Proposed | Significant | Waiting for input from Gunther | ||
30 | Add Bag.literal | BAG | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | |||
31 | Null constraints | all | Abstract | Approved | Significant | LM | LM | OH NO!! Big R2 argument here |
32 | cd.code rules | CD | Abstract | Applied | Normal | |||
35 | UID Case sensitivity | II | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | LM | LM | |
36 | URI issue | URL | Abstract | Closed | Trivial | |||
37 | Fax issue | URL | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | LM | LM | |
38 | Type Substitution | all | Abstract | Closed | Normal | LM | LM | |
39 | DEL null content issue | ADXP | Abstract | Applied | Editorial | LM | LM | |
40 | ProbabilityDistributionType | vocab | Abstract | Abandoned | Nothing | |||
41 | decimal significance | REAL | Abstract | Abandoned | Nothing | |||
43 | order of HIST and HXIT | narrative | Abstract | Applied | Editorial | |||
44 | PIVL issues | PIVL | Abstract | ? | Signficant | |||
45 | comp name | SET | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | |||
46 | PPD QTY.diff issues | PPD | Abstract | Applied | Significant | |||
49 | PQR originalText | PQR | Abstract | Applied | Normal | |||
50 | CD.original text demotion | CD | Abstract | Applied | Editorial | |||
51 | Support for Likert scales | CO | Abstract | Applied | Normal | |||
52 | Missing demotions | all | Abstract | ? | Trivial | |||
53 | IVL attribute names | IVL | Abstract | Applied | Significant | |||
54 | CE definition error | CE | Abstract | Applied | Editorial | LM | LM | |
55 | Update mode & Audit Trail | all | Abstract | Applied | Normal | LM | LM | |
56 | SRCH semantics | EN | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM | |
57 | II.useCode | II | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM | |
58 | #GTS Frequency Code | GTS | Abstract | Applied | Signficant | LM | LM | |
59 | Unknown home phone number | TEL | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM | |
60 | Data Type Flavors | all | Abstract | ? | Applied | LM | LM | |
61 | PHON semantics | EN | Abstract | Applied | Significant | |||
62 | Add AD.use PHON+SRCH | AD | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM | |
63 | IVL narrative issue | IVL | Abstract | Applied | Editorial | |||
64 | IVL center issue | IVL | Abstract | Applied | Significant | |||
65 | IVL center/width and low/high issue | IVL | Abstract | Applied | Editorial | |||
66 | conformance to preferred OID root | II,C* | Abstract | Gone to Ballot | Significant | Waiting for vocab decision | ||
67 | Clarification of Promotion and Demotion | All | Abstract | ? | Normal | LM | LM | |
68 | Text Telephone Number | TEL | Abstract | Applied | Normal | LM | LM | |
69 | CD.translation changes | CD | Abstract | Applied | Catastrophe | |||
70 | PQR Visibility | PQR | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | |||
71 | LanguageCommunication DataType | -- | Abstract | Rejected | Nothing | |||
72 | DATAVALUE.specialisationType | -- | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM | |
73 | CD.valueSet | CD | Abstract | Applied | Normal | |||
74 | Unencoded NullFlavor | ANY | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM | |
75 | II Root Usage warning | II | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | |||
76 | II.reference URI not just URL | II | ITS | Applied | Trivial | |||
77 | II.assigningAuthorityName use not clear | II | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | LM | LM | |
78 | PQR coding rationale | PQR | Abstract | Applied | Significant | GS | GS | |
79 | CD coding rationale | CD | Abstract | Applied | Significant | GG | GG | |
80 | CE Translations & Conformance | CD & CE | Abstract | Applied | Significant | GG | GG | |
81 | Reference to GSLIST | GLIST | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | |||
82 | Narrative for Substitution | All | Abstract | Rejected | Trivial | |||
83 | Discrete and Continuous SET (DSET, QSET) | All | Abstract | Applied | Unclassified | GS | GS | |
85 | QSET (GTS) Enhance Detail | All | Abstract | Applied | Significant | GS | GS | |
94 | URI reference to an II | II / URL | Abstract | Applied | Trivial | |||
95 | Qualifiers of qualifiers | CD | Abstract | Applied | Significant | |||
96 | CO generalisation | CO | Abstract | Abandoned | Significant | |||
97 | Type.implies nullNess question | Type | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
98 | Prohibit qualifiers in CE translations | CE | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
99 | Clarification of semantics on QTY | QTY | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
100 | Editorial Corrections for IVL.hull | IVL | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
101 | Clarification of Name Semantics | EN | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
102 | Constraints on TEL usage in ED.reference and CD.originalText | TEL | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
103 | NullFlavor considerations | All | Abstract | Proposed | ? | Primarily a conformance issue; not for R2 | ||
104 | Address Part Type AL | AD | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
105 | SC clarifications | AD | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
106 | IVL.any proposal | IVL | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
107 | UML changes | All | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
108 | OCL Support | All | Abstract | Proposed | ? | Placeholder for future issue | ||
109 | Invariants on PQR and MO | PQ,MO | Abstract | Applied | ? | |||
110 | BIN/ED/ST Problems | ED | Abstract | Proposed | ? | |||
111 | II type proposal | II | Abstract | Proposed | ? |
Data Type Flavors
ID | Topic | Type | Category | Status | Ranking | Volunteer | Priority |
84 | Datatype Flavors Section | All | Both | Applied | Significant | ||
86 | FLAVOR: TS Datatype Flavors | TS | Abstract | Applied | Significant | GG | GG |
87 | FLAVOR: ED Datatype Flavors | ED | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM |
88 | FLAVOR: IVL Datatype Flavors | IVL | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM |
89 | FLAVOR: PQ Datatype Flavors | PQ | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM |
90 | FLAVOR: TEL Datatype Flavors | TEL | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM |
91 | FLAVOR: INT Datatype Flavors | INT | Abstract | Applied | Significant | LM | LM |
93 | FLAVOR: Move CE, CV and CS to flavor section | CD | Abstract | Abandoned | Significant |
XML issues
ID | Topic | Type | Category | Status | Ranking | Volunteer | Priority |
15 | XML Representation of Collection Type and NullFlavor | COLL | XML | Proposed | Normal | LM | LM |
16 | XML Representation of SLIST | SLIST | XML | Proposed | Normal | ||
33 | language binding in XML | ED | XML | Proposed | Significant | ||
34 | Removed Properties | all | XML | ? | Normal | ||
42 | RTO xsi:type | RTO | XML | ? | Normal | ||
47 | xml attributes | all | XML | Proposal | Normal | ||
48 | CS element form | CS | XML | Abandoned | Trivial | ||
92 | TS Format in text change | TS | Abstract | Proposed | Editorial |