This wiki has undergone a migration to Confluence found Here
Difference between revisions of "OO CRLRI-009 - LRI-60 and LRI-61"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Created page with "Category:OO Open LRI IG Change Requests Return to OO Change Requests page. {|width=100% cellspacing=0 cellpadding=2 border=1 || '''Submitte...") |
|||
| (2 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
'''Technical issues with how the conformance statements are written.''' | '''Technical issues with how the conformance statements are written.''' | ||
| − | LRI-60 is a compound conformance statement and would be clearer if separated. | + | 1)LRI-60 is a compound conformance statement and would be clearer if separated. |
| − | |||
| − | + | 2)There can be multiple OBRs and unclear to which the Statements are referring. | |
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | *LRI-61: "If one or more SPM segments are present for the same OBR and if OBR-8 (Observation End Date/Time) is present, OBR-8 | + | *LRI-60: "If one or more SPM segments are present for the same OBR, then the earliest SPM-17.1 (Range Start Date/Time) SHALL be equal to or before OBR-7 (Observation Date/Time) and OBR-7 (Observation Date/Time) SHALL be equal to or before the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time)." |
| − | (Observation End Date/Time) SHALL be equal to or before the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time)" | + | |
| + | *LRI-61: "If one or more SPM segments are present for the same OBR and if OBR-8 (Observation End Date/Time) is present, OBR-8 (Observation End Date/Time) SHALL be equal to or before the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time)" | ||
'''in the PH component rewrote them to correct these issues:''' | '''in the PH component rewrote them to correct these issues:''' | ||
| − | *ELR-75: The earliest SPM-17.1 (Range Start Date/Time) value SHALL be equal to or before OBR-7 (Observation Date/Time) value within the same | + | *ELR-75: The earliest SPM-17.1 (Range Start Date/Time) value SHALL be equal to or before OBR-7 (Observation Date/Time) value within the same ORDER_OBSERVATION Group. |
| − | ORDER_OBSERVATION Group. | + | *ELR-76: If present, the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time) value SHALL be equal to or after OBR-7 (Observation Date/Time) value within the same Order_Observation Group. |
| − | *ELR-76: If present, the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time) value SHALL be equal to or after OBR-7 (Observation Date/Time) value within the | + | *ELR-30: If present, the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time) value SHALL be equal to or after OBR-8 (Observation End Date/Time) value within the same ORDER_OBSERVATION Group |
| − | same Order_Observation Group. | ||
| − | *ELR-30: If present, the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time) value SHALL be equal to or after OBR-8 (Observation End Date/Time) value within the | ||
| − | same ORDER_OBSERVATION Group | ||
But this created conflicting Conformance statement between the base profile and the PH profile. | But this created conflicting Conformance statement between the base profile and the PH profile. | ||
| − | + | ||
== Recommendation == | == Recommendation == | ||
Latest revision as of 19:59, 29 July 2014
Return to OO Change Requests page.
| Submitted by: Eric Haas | Revision date: Jan 21 2014 |
| Submitted date: Jan 21 2014 | Change request ID: OO CRLRI-009 |
| Standard/IG: Implementation Guide | Artifact ID, Name: LRI-60 and LRI-61 |
Issue
Technical issues with how the conformance statements are written.
1)LRI-60 is a compound conformance statement and would be clearer if separated.
2)There can be multiple OBRs and unclear to which the Statements are referring.
- LRI-60: "If one or more SPM segments are present for the same OBR, then the earliest SPM-17.1 (Range Start Date/Time) SHALL be equal to or before OBR-7 (Observation Date/Time) and OBR-7 (Observation Date/Time) SHALL be equal to or before the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time)."
- LRI-61: "If one or more SPM segments are present for the same OBR and if OBR-8 (Observation End Date/Time) is present, OBR-8 (Observation End Date/Time) SHALL be equal to or before the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time)"
in the PH component rewrote them to correct these issues:
- ELR-75: The earliest SPM-17.1 (Range Start Date/Time) value SHALL be equal to or before OBR-7 (Observation Date/Time) value within the same ORDER_OBSERVATION Group.
- ELR-76: If present, the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time) value SHALL be equal to or after OBR-7 (Observation Date/Time) value within the same Order_Observation Group.
- ELR-30: If present, the latest SPM-17.2 (Range End Date/Time) value SHALL be equal to or after OBR-8 (Observation End Date/Time) value within the same ORDER_OBSERVATION Group
But this created conflicting Conformance statement between the base profile and the PH profile.
Recommendation
Reommend replacing LRI-60 and LRI-61 with ELR-75, ELR-76 and ELR-30. (renaming them appropriately)
Discuss whether these CS are necessary in light of their absence in LOI.
Rationale
Simplify and Clarify Conformance statements
