This wiki has undergone a migration to Confluence found Here
<meta name="googlebot" content="noindex">

Difference between revisions of "Tooling WGM 2013 Sep"

From HL7Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(5 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 61: Line 61:
 
  <tr>
 
  <tr>
 
   <td>Q4</td>
 
   <td>Q4</td>
−
  <td>Room TBD</td>
 
 
   <td> </td>
 
   <td> </td>
−
   <td> Tooling</td>
+
   <td> </td>
−
   <td> (Vocab?)</td>
+
   <td> </td>
 +
  <td>  )</td>
 
   <td></td>
 
   <td></td>
 
   <td>&nbsp;</td>
 
   <td>&nbsp;</td>
Line 89: Line 89:
 
   <td rowspan=2>AM </td>
 
   <td rowspan=2>AM </td>
 
   <td>Q1</td>
 
   <td>Q1</td>
−
   <td>Room TBD</td>
+
   <td>Empress East</td>
 
   <td>Introduction to Tooling Work Group - Processes, Projects & Collaborations<br/>''See our [http://gforge.hl7.org/gf/download/docmanfileversion/7307/10395/2013MayTooling-morning-slides.pptx morning slides]''
 
   <td>Introduction to Tooling Work Group - Processes, Projects & Collaborations<br/>''See our [http://gforge.hl7.org/gf/download/docmanfileversion/7307/10395/2013MayTooling-morning-slides.pptx morning slides]''
 
  </td>
 
  </td>
Line 101: Line 101:
 
  <tr>
 
  <tr>
 
   <td>Q2</td>
 
   <td>Q2</td>
−
   <td>Room TBD</td>
+
   <td>Empress East</td>
−
   <td> Project updates: MAX, EHRS-FM Profile Designer, </td>
+
   <td> Project updates: MAX, EHRS-FM Profile Designer, Trifolia TD </td>
 
   <td> Tooling </td>
 
   <td> Tooling </td>
 
   <td>&nbsp;</td>
 
   <td>&nbsp;</td>
Line 113: Line 113:
 
   <td rowspan=3>PM</td>
 
   <td rowspan=3>PM</td>
 
   <td>Q3</td>
 
   <td>Q3</td>
−
   <td>Room TBD</td>
+
   <td>Molly Pitcher</td>
 
   <td>Hosted by Structured Docs (need to confirm)</td>
 
   <td>Hosted by Structured Docs (need to confirm)</td>
 
   <td> </td>
 
   <td> </td>
Line 135: Line 135:
 
  <tr>
 
  <tr>
 
   <td bgcolor=#dddddd>7-9PM</td>
 
   <td bgcolor=#dddddd>7-9PM</td>
−
   <td bgcolor=#dddddd>Room TBD</td>
+
   <td bgcolor=#dddddd> Riverside Pavilion</td>
 
   <td bgcolor=#dddddd>Tuesday Tooling Night ([[Tuesday_Tooling_-_Sep_2013| details]])</td>
 
   <td bgcolor=#dddddd>Tuesday Tooling Night ([[Tuesday_Tooling_-_Sep_2013| details]])</td>
 
   <td bgcolor=#dddddd>Tooling</td>
 
   <td bgcolor=#dddddd>Tooling</td>
Line 225: Line 225:
 
   <td rowspan=2>AM </td>
 
   <td rowspan=2>AM </td>
 
   <td>Q1</td>
 
   <td>Q1</td>
−
   <td>Room TBD</td>
+
   <td>Empress West</td>
−
   <td> Project Topics: V3 Generator, Migration Planning, <!--HingX Participation,--> Tooling Challenge
+
   <td> Project Topics: V3 Generator, Migration Planning, <!--HingX Participation,--> Tooling Challenge <br/> AMS conformance tooling intro (15 mins)
 
   <td>Tooling</td>
 
   <td>Tooling</td>
 
   <td></td>
 
   <td></td>
Line 236: Line 236:
 
  <tr>
 
  <tr>
 
   <td>Q2</td>
 
   <td>Q2</td>
−
   <td>Room TBD</td>
+
   <td>Empress West</td>
 
   <td>Tooling Strategy Discussion, Update from liaisons to other WG, Tactical Plan</td>
 
   <td>Tooling Strategy Discussion, Update from liaisons to other WG, Tactical Plan</td>
 
   <td>Tooling</td>
 
   <td>Tooling</td>
Line 248: Line 248:
 
   <td rowspan=2>PM</td>
 
   <td rowspan=2>PM</td>
 
   <td>Q3</td>
 
   <td>Q3</td>
−
   <td>Room TBD</td>
+
   <td>Guest Room 209</td>
 
   <td>Tools for development</td>
 
   <td>Tools for development</td>
 
   <td>RIMBAA</td>
 
   <td>RIMBAA</td>
Line 287: Line 287:
 
   <td rowspan=2>AM</td>
 
   <td rowspan=2>AM</td>
 
   <td>Q1</td>
 
   <td>Q1</td>
−
   <td>Room TBD</td>
+
   <td> Aquarium</td>
 
   <td>Joining Templates </td>
 
   <td>Joining Templates </td>
 
   <td>Templates</td>
 
   <td>Templates</td>
Line 331: Line 331:
  
 
</table>
 
</table>
 +
 +
 +
===Meeting Information===
 +
 +
{|border="1" cellpadding="2" cellspacing="0"
 +
<!---=======================================================================
 +
|                                                                          |
 +
|  MM    MM  TTTTTT  GGGGG        IIIIII  NN    NN  FFFFFF  OOOOO      |
 +
|  MMM  MMM    TT    GG              II    NNN  NN  FF      OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM MMM MM    TT    GG  GGG        II    NN NN NN  FFFF    OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM  M  MM    TT    GG  GG        II    NN  NNN  FF      OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM    MM    TT    GGGGG        IIIIII  NN    NN  FF      OOOOO      |
 +
|                                                                          |
 +
========================================================================--->
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE WG Name or Project ON NEXT LINE *******************-->
 +
| width="50%" colspan="1" align="left" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|'''HL7 Tooling Meeting Agenda/Minutes''' <br/>
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE conf call details or meeting room ON NEXT LINE*****-->
 +
'''Location: Empress East
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE Date and Time  ON NEXT LINE  **********************-->
 +
| width="50%" colspan="1" align="left" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|'''Date: 2013-09-24'''<br/> '''Time: 9AM Eastern'''
 +
|-
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE chair and scribe ON NEXT LINES  *******************-->
 +
|colspan="1" align="right"|'''Facilitator''': Andy
 +
|colspan="1" align="right"|'''Note taker(s)''': Andy
 +
|-
 +
| border="4" cellpadding="1" colspan="2" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|
 +
|-
 +
| border="1" cellpadding="2" colspan="1" align="left"|'''Attendee''' || '''Name, Affiliation'''
 +
 +
<!---==============================================================================
 +
|                                                                                |
 +
|    AAAA  TTTTTT  TTTTTT  EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    EEEEEE  EEEEEE  SSSSS    |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EE      NNN  NN  DD  DD  EE      EE      SS        |
 +
|  AAAAAA    TT      TT    EEEE    NN NN NN  DD  DD  EEEE    EEEE    SSSS      |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EE      NN  NNN  DD  DD  EE      EE          SS    |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    EEEEEE  EEEEEE  SSSSS      |
 +
|                                                                                |
 +
===============================================================================--->
 +
|-
 +
| x||Attila Farkas, CHI (AF)
 +
|-
 +
| x  ||Alexander Henket, NICTIZ (AH)
 +
|-
 +
|regrets||Lynn Laakso, HL7 HQ Tooling Support
 +
|-
 +
| x||Andy Stechishin, Co-chair (AS)
 +
|-
 +
|regrets  ||Michael van der Zel, co-chair
 +
|-
 +
| x||Tessa van Stijn, NICTIZ (TvS)
 +
|-
 +
|colspan="2" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|
 +
|-
 +
<!-- *****  Delete instructions  and change quorum requirements ON NEXT LINE *****-->
 +
|colspan="2" |'''Quorum Requirements Met (co-chair plus 3 counting staff): '''(yes)
 +
|-
 +
|}
 +
 +
Q1 notes
 +
Tues Q1
 +
*Attendees were experienced Tooling participants and decided to forego the usual introduction to Tooling and cover tooling concerns.
 +
*At suggestion of chair, session was an open discussion on concerns/issues/needs from participants
 +
*AH and TvS opened discussion with queries on the direction for Template exchange and use of DECOR
 +
*AS gave an overview of the progress on the use of DECOR in the Templates ITS
 +
*AF had questions on the use of CDA Templates in the European jurisdictions and AS, AH, TvS gave overviews of the various functionality and capabilities of ART/DECOR
 +
*AF spoke about the Canadian activities and the overlap that was occurring between the realms and wondered if there was possibilities for sharing work/resources/experiences. AS said that Tooling would be happy to serve as a forum for these joint discussions. AH also suggested that HL7 Tooling would assist in the development of tools by defining the mechanisms for sharing of the core design artifacts.
 +
 +
 +
{|border="1" cellpadding="2" cellspacing="0"
 +
<!---=======================================================================
 +
|                                                                          |
 +
|  MM    MM  TTTTTT  GGGGG        IIIIII  NN    NN  FFFFFF  OOOOO      |
 +
|  MMM  MMM    TT    GG              II    NNN  NN  FF      OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM MMM MM    TT    GG  GGG        II    NN NN NN  FFFF    OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM  M  MM    TT    GG  GG        II    NN  NNN  FF      OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM    MM    TT    GGGGG        IIIIII  NN    NN  FF      OOOOO      |
 +
|                                                                          |
 +
========================================================================--->
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE WG Name or Project ON NEXT LINE *******************-->
 +
| width="50%" colspan="1" align="left" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|'''HL7 Tooling Meeting Agenda/Minutes''' <br/>
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE conf call details or meeting room ON NEXT LINE*****-->
 +
'''Location: Empress East
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE Date and Time  ON NEXT LINE  **********************-->
 +
| width="50%" colspan="1" align="left" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|'''Date: 2013-09-24'''<br/> '''Time: 11AM Eastern'''
 +
|-
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE chair and scribe ON NEXT LINES  *******************-->
 +
|colspan="1" align="right"|'''Facilitator''': Andy
 +
|colspan="1" align="right"|'''Note taker(s)''': Lynn Laakso
 +
|-
 +
| border="4" cellpadding="1" colspan="2" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|
 +
|-
 +
| border="1" cellpadding="2" colspan="1" align="left"|'''Attendee''' || '''Name, Affiliation'''
 +
 +
<!---==============================================================================
 +
|                                                                                |
 +
|    AAAA  TTTTTT  TTTTTT  EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    EEEEEE  EEEEEE  SSSSS    |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EE      NNN  NN  DD  DD  EE      EE      SS        |
 +
|  AAAAAA    TT      TT    EEEE    NN NN NN  DD  DD  EEEE    EEEE    SSSS      |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EE      NN  NNN  DD  DD  EE      EE          SS    |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    EEEEEE  EEEEEE  SSSSS      |
 +
|                                                                                |
 +
===============================================================================--->
 +
|-
 +
|x.||Liora Alschuler, Lantana .
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Bo Dagnall, HP
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Sarah Gaunt, Lantana
 +
|-
 +
|x  ||Alexander Henket
 +
|-
 +
| x||Lynn Laakso, HL7 HQ Tooling Support
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Craig Purdon, Standards Australia
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Stephen Royce, NEHTA (AUS)
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Kanwarpreet Sethi, Lantana
 +
|-
 +
| x||Andy Stechishin, Co-chair
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Michael van der Zel, co-chair
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Tessa van Stijn, NICTIZ
 +
|-
 +
|colspan="2" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|
 +
|-
 +
<!-- *****  Delete instructions  and change quorum requirements ON NEXT LINE *****-->
 +
|colspan="2" |'''Quorum Requirements Met (co-chair plus 3 counting staff): '''(yes)
 +
|-
 +
 +
 +
|}
 +
<!---=======================================================
 +
|                                                          |
 +
|    AAAA    GGGGG  EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    AAAA      |
 +
|  AA  AA  GG      EE      NNN  NN  DD  DD  AA  AA    |
 +
|  AAAAAA  GG  GGG  EEEE    NN NN NN  DD  DD  AAAAAA    |
 +
|  AA  AA  GG  GG  EE      NN  NNN  DD  DD  AA  AA    |
 +
|  AA  AA  GGGGG  EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    AA  AA    |
 +
|                                                          |
 +
========================================================--->
 +
===Agenda===
 +
'''Agenda Topics''' <br/>
 +
*Project Updates
 +
**MAX
 +
**Trifolia
 +
 +
 +
===Minutes===
 +
<!---================================================================
 +
|                                                                  |
 +
|  MM    MM  IIIIII  NN    NN  UU  UU  TTTTTT  EEEEEE  SSSSS    |
 +
|  MMM  MMM    II    NNN  NN  UU  UU    TT    EE      SS        |
 +
|  MM MMM MM    II    NN NN NN  UU  UU    TT    EEEE    SSSS      |
 +
|  MM  M  MM    II    NN  NNN  UU  UU    TT    EE          SS    |
 +
|  MM    MM  IIIIII  NN    NN  UUUU    TT    EEEEEE  SSSSS      |
 +
|                                                                  |
 +
=================================================================--->
 +
 +
'''Minutes/Conclusions Reached:'''<br/>
 +
 +
Andy convenes at 11:07 AM
 +
*Michael describes the MAX tooling
 +
**EA extension, and next will address making it available to others beyond CIC
 +
**Export capability to flat format for non-technical user review also for schematron discussed
 +
**Bo discusses such an approach to use for the Business Architecture Model (BAM) for ArB - how to handle cascading many-to-many relationships for multiple objects. Michael noted the use case.
 +
**Kanwareet (KP) asks if they considered schematron directly against the UML, but it does not include everything for the functional models and they wanted an universal common format.
 +
*Sarah reviews the latest Trifolia release
 +
**Publishing tool, template versioning, and other features added.
 +
**Andy comments that the template status field should consider using the Templates Business Process requirements for those field values.
 +
 +
===Thursday Sep 26 Q1===
 +
{|border="1" cellpadding="2" cellspacing="0"
 +
<!---=======================================================================
 +
|                                                                          |
 +
|  MM    MM  TTTTTT  GGGGG        IIIIII  NN    NN  FFFFFF  OOOOO      |
 +
|  MMM  MMM    TT    GG              II    NNN  NN  FF      OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM MMM MM    TT    GG  GGG        II    NN NN NN  FFFF    OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM  M  MM    TT    GG  GG        II    NN  NNN  FF      OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM    MM    TT    GGGGG        IIIIII  NN    NN  FF      OOOOO      |
 +
|                                                                          |
 +
========================================================================--->
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE WG Name or Project ON NEXT LINE *******************-->
 +
| width="50%" colspan="1" align="left" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|'''HL7 Tooling Meeting Agenda/Minutes''' <br/>
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE conf call details or meeting room ON NEXT LINE*****-->
 +
'''Location: Riverside Pavilion
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE Date and Time  ON NEXT LINE  **********************-->
 +
| width="50%" colspan="1" align="left" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|'''Date: 2013-09-26'''<br/> '''Time: 9 AM Eastern'''
 +
|-
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE chair and scribe ON NEXT LINES  *******************-->
 +
|colspan="1" align="right"|'''Facilitator''': Andy
 +
|colspan="1" align="right"|'''Note taker(s)''': Lynn
 +
|-
 +
| border="4" cellpadding="1" colspan="2" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|
 +
|-
 +
| border="1" cellpadding="2" colspan="1" align="left"|'''Attendee''' || '''Name, Affiliation'''
 +
 +
<!---==============================================================================
 +
|                                                                                |
 +
|    AAAA  TTTTTT  TTTTTT  EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    EEEEEE  EEEEEE  SSSSS    |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EE      NNN  NN  DD  DD  EE      EE      SS        |
 +
|  AAAAAA    TT      TT    EEEE    NN NN NN  DD  DD  EEEE    EEEE    SSSS      |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EE      NN  NNN  DD  DD  EE      EE          SS    |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    EEEEEE  EEEEEE  SSSSS      |
 +
|                                                                                |
 +
===============================================================================--->
 +
|-
 +
| x||Woody Beeler
 +
|-
 +
|x  ||Alexander Henket, NICTIZ
 +
|-
 +
|  ||Abdul-Malik Shakir
 +
|-
 +
| x||Andy Stechishin, Co-chair
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Michael van der Zel, co-chair
 +
|-
 +
|x||Lynn Laakso, scribe
 +
|-
 +
|colspan="2" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|
 +
|-
 +
|colspan="2" |'''Quorum Requirements Met (co-chair plus 3 counting staff): '''(yes)
 +
|-
 +
|}
 +
<!---=======================================================
 +
|                                                          |
 +
|    AAAA    GGGGG  EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    AAAA      |
 +
|  AA  AA  GG      EE      NNN  NN  DD  DD  AA  AA    |
 +
|  AAAAAA  GG  GGG  EEEE    NN NN NN  DD  DD  AAAAAA    |
 +
|  AA  AA  GG  GG  EE      NN  NNN  DD  DD  AA  AA    |
 +
|  AA  AA  GGGGG  EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    AA  AA    |
 +
|                                                          |
 +
========================================================--->
 +
 +
===Agenda===
 +
Project Topics:
 +
*V3 Generator,
 +
*Migration Planning,
 +
*Tooling Challenge
 +
*AMS conformance tooling intro (15 mins)
 +
 +
===Meeting Outcomes===
 +
Convene at 9:14 AM
 +
*Vocabulary maintenance language (VML) for vocabulary update
 +
**Value triplet properties, history of process evolution discussed and the remaining manual intervention required.
 +
**Russ did a java program posting from VML to Access db. Woody extended VML for xhtml markup for definitions recently. RIM-repos has the vocab tables db. Right now it's a tool for three people, e.g. Woody, Ted, Russ; would like to expand. Woody does not want to modify the Vocab db. ACTION: Need to revisit this in San Antonio.
 +
**Alexander asks about coreMIFs for each release having the same date. There is no versioning in the database, Woody reports. This is a weakness of the Database and a known issue but have been ignoring it for so long they forget. He recommends vocabulary MIF-diff files to see what has changed.
 +
*Rosetree has simplified user interface. Issues with Visio controls discussed
 +
**Andy asks if we need a browser overlay. It would be nice, but Visio environment is the concern. The Tooling Challenge is meant to address this but is not necessarily of a scope reasonable to the prize.
 +
<!--emf conversion of MIF to classes, but not all the html, stopping before the flow and used their sample interfaces to load a mif file-->
 +
**SMD included dependency on RIM file and needed new tool for each release of RIM. Michael notes that AML (Architecture Modeling Language) has been discussed to adapt UML for CIMI, OpenEHR and HL7 modeling use. There are parts of that in his profile for MIF. Sparx and RSA may implement it if they get an OMG profile approved. Woody notes the ability to move around classes, add new classes and subclass attributes are desirable. Michael notes the AML is applicable beyond health care. Andy notes that while there's not a lot of work going on in this space we don't want to leave it orphaned, and still requires investment each year to keep it up to date.
 +
**RMIM designer in visio works better than the UML templates in Visio and our audience is spoiled.
 +
**Woody asks about the state of the RFP from OMG - Michael clarifies it was more of an RFI and they are working on an RFP.
 +
*Woody notes that improvements in the Canadian Generator exist and need to migrate rather than replicate their upgrades. He hasn't had time this summer to work on it and needs a three-week stretch to focus.
 +
*Wish to build an internal web platform for members-only, that looks like a ballot site, for future normative edition publication material and meeting ANSI publication guidelines. Then it will be frozen and zipped into a normative edition.  A web version of the NE was created for the Help Desk and that type of platform can be reused. Non-V3 type material like IGs are linked from the NE pages. What about CDA IGs? Woody notes they have not normally been in our publishing space. They are not typically included in the ZIP files.
 +
**He isolated an error in the RMIM designer in Visio this summer and it was very time consuming.
 +
**Woody would like to seek retraction of support for Visio 2002. '''Motion:''' He moves we notify the cochairs, editors and internationaladmin lists in addition to Tooling the intent of Tooling's consideration to drop support for Visio 2002 effective with review at 2014JanuaryWGM in San Antonio. Michael seconds. Michael asks about establishing the principle to remove support with the vendor end-of-life. The Rosetree stuff is well beyond end of life, however, without a replacement. Alexander suggests we survey the affiliates as well. ''Vote:''' unanimously approved
 +
*Tooling challenge
 +
**What do we do with the Tooling Challenge entries, and their IP. If similar to Eclipse Public License, then derivative works must refer to the original IP but can develop further. Could make them backwards transformable to MIF.
 +
**RIM maintenance moved to RSA two years ago, but process is to export RSA, and then manage in MIF with a reverse transform for GUIDs assigned.  Woody is now interested in migrating it to EA with graphics and annotations. Michael and Harold have used an extension to sanitize the EA XML. Woody will draft some documentation on the migration before suggesting a formal motion.
 +
**EMF stuff from last year is linked from January 2012s minutes.
 +
**How to package the Tooling Challenge winning entry with documentation and user guide and put it out there for people to use (Package release)? Is it members-only? What about Sparx, if they're not members should they have access? Needs further discussion on a call
 +
*AMS not present, adjourned 10:38 AM.
 +
 +
 +
===Thursday Sep 26 Q2===
 +
 +
{|border="1" cellpadding="2" cellspacing="0"
 +
<!---=======================================================================
 +
|                                                                          |
 +
|  MM    MM  TTTTTT  GGGGG        IIIIII  NN    NN  FFFFFF  OOOOO      |
 +
|  MMM  MMM    TT    GG              II    NNN  NN  FF      OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM MMM MM    TT    GG  GGG        II    NN NN NN  FFFF    OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM  M  MM    TT    GG  GG        II    NN  NNN  FF      OO  OO    |
 +
|  MM    MM    TT    GGGGG        IIIIII  NN    NN  FF      OOOOO      |
 +
|                                                                          |
 +
========================================================================--->
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE WG Name or Project ON NEXT LINE *******************-->
 +
| width="50%" colspan="1" align="left" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|'''HL7 Tooling Meeting Agenda/Minutes''' <br/>
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE conf call details or meeting room ON NEXT LINE*****-->
 +
'''Location: Empress East
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE Date and Time  ON NEXT LINE  **********************-->
 +
| width="50%" colspan="1" align="left" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|'''Date: 2013-09-26'''<br/> '''Time: 11:00AM Eastern'''
 +
|-
 +
<!-- ********  CHANGE chair and scribe ON NEXT LINES  *******************-->
 +
|colspan="1" align="right"|'''Facilitator''': Andy
 +
|colspan="1" align="right"|'''Note taker(s)''': Lynn Laakso
 +
|-
 +
| border="4" cellpadding="1" colspan="2" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|
 +
|-
 +
| border="1" cellpadding="2" colspan="1" align="left"|'''Attendee''' || '''Name, Affiliation'''
 +
 +
<!---==============================================================================
 +
|                                                                                |
 +
|    AAAA  TTTTTT  TTTTTT  EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    EEEEEE  EEEEEE  SSSSS    |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EE      NNN  NN  DD  DD  EE      EE      SS        |
 +
|  AAAAAA    TT      TT    EEEE    NN NN NN  DD  DD  EEEE    EEEE    SSSS      |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EE      NN  NNN  DD  DD  EE      EE          SS    |
 +
|  AA  AA    TT      TT    EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    EEEEEE  EEEEEE  SSSSS      |
 +
|                                                                                |
 +
===============================================================================--->
 +
|-
 +
| x||Jeff Brown, HL7 ES liaison
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Matthew Graham, Mayo, Mobile Health
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Alexander Henket, NICTIZ
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Tony Julian, Mayo
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Lynn Laakso, HL7 HQ Tooling Support
 +
|-
 +
| x||Frank McKinney, consulting
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Tim McNeil, Surescripts
 +
|-
 +
| x||Frank Oemig
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Andy Stechishin, Co-chair
 +
|-
 +
|regrets ||Michael van der Zel, co-chair
 +
|-
 +
|x ||Sara Stewart, NIST
 +
|-
 +
|colspan="2" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|
 +
|-
 +
<!-- *****  Delete instructions  and change quorum requirements ON NEXT LINE *****-->
 +
|colspan="2" |'''Quorum Requirements Met (co-chair plus 3 counting staff): '''(yes)
 +
|-
 +
 +
 +
|}
 +
<!---=======================================================
 +
|                                                          |
 +
|    AAAA    GGGGG  EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    AAAA      |
 +
|  AA  AA  GG      EE      NNN  NN  DD  DD  AA  AA    |
 +
|  AAAAAA  GG  GGG  EEEE    NN NN NN  DD  DD  AAAAAA    |
 +
|  AA  AA  GG  GG  EE      NN  NNN  DD  DD  AA  AA    |
 +
|  AA  AA  GGGGG  EEEEEE  NN    NN  DDDDD    AA  AA    |
 +
|                                                          |
 +
========================================================--->
 +
===Agenda===
 +
'''Agenda Topics''' <br/>
 +
Tooling Strategy Discussion, Update from liaisons to other WG, Tactical Plan
 +
 +
===Minutes===
 +
* Roll Call & Agenda Review
 +
*Update from Tooling Liaisons:
 +
** Electronic Services - Jeff Brown
 +
*** shift in process on dependency on HQ staff with Josh Carmody's departure- new person starts October 1st, setback with ES and ES Tooling; they are reprioritizing.
 +
**CGIT - Rob Snelick represented by Sara Stewart shows a short slide presentation
 +
***Messaging Work Bench - Pete gave MWB to NIST. NIST did analysis and recommendations to compile and placed it into open source. Matt Graham/Tony assert Mayo has gotten it to compile. Matt took code from sourceforge and migrated to Delphi 7 and identified missing libraries. There are few Delphi developers left but some at Mayo. Long term maintenance is unclear. Need updated version of V2.x Access db from Frank Oemig and Tony/Matt will import.
 +
***NIST is developing in Java an IG authoring and management tool extending profiling capabilities of MWG, currently in demo/pilot phase. Matt suggests a MWB listserv for existing users. Andy suggests using the Tooling listserv for now.
 +
***Tony asks if HL7 wants to fund Regex expression license for current regex. Matt notes it's 80 Euro with source code. Without source it's $50, per developer. Andy will talk to John about it. Excel spreadsheet-like dialog and component set license would be separate but belongs to a dead code thread so is probably unnecessary.
 +
** CIC - AMS is not available
 +
**CS - Rik Smithies is not available
 +
** Education - Diego Kaminker is not available
 +
** EHR - John Ritter is not available
 +
** Marketing - Rene Spronk  is not available
 +
** Patient Care, RIMBAA - Michael Van der Zel is not available.
 +
***Andy reports from RIMBAA that there was not anything particular to Tooling, but interesting presentations on Tooling Tuesday but no issues.
 +
**Alexander Henket notes that if PA does not have a liaison he can fill that role. If we have requirements solicitation we will ping him.
 +
** Structured Documents, (Vocabulary), Publishing - Andy Stechishin 
 +
***SDWG Tuesday Q3 focused on publishing quality IG subgroup. They will continue to meet monthly and they look at how publishing issues can be resolved in the tooling. Trifolia is not officially endorsed but may seek endorsement. No other updates from publishing.
 +
** Templates, Open Health Tools - Jane Curry is not available; Andy will find out more tomorrow. Templates ITS for CDA IG exchange has focused on DÉCOR format in EU, which currently maps to Trifolia but not sure on MDHT - awaiting status from Keith Boone.
 +
***Continuing investigations into the API/interface with the HingX tool.
 +
*:Tooling-sponsored Projects
 +
**[http://www.hl7.org/Special/committees/v3toolstaskforce/projects.cfm?action=edit&ProjectNumber=801 PI# 801] [[Tooling_Strategy_and_Process_Revision|Tooling Strategy and Process Revision]] - tentative plan has been endorsed by TSC; still pending review by Board, but needs refresh and review already. Vitality assessment discussions in ArB noted by Andy and MvdZel and spurring review Tooling architecture documents to bring up to date and refine them based on strategy. Seek to present an updated Tooling Strategy in San Antonio and perhaps even an updated architecture.
 +
**Mobile health looking at a project with GS1 that may involve Tooling (Harry Rhodes/Christian Hay)- Andy invites him to bring the project to Tooling as co-sponsor. May need an iOS developers' license. May be setting up tracking attendees through mobile app. Google playstore licensing and Android platform development unknown. ACTION ITEM: Andy will talk to John and Mark about an iOS developers' license for HL7. They hope for a prototype for January. Matt Graham will act as liaison.
 +
*Sara then shows a slide show and pilot of the IGAMT.  She is running a local Tomcat server but can run a web server. What is the process for saving local copies of values when running the web server - Andy points out that corporate browsers won't allow saving to local storage. They use DITA processing chain for such documentation. Andy cautions DITA conversions for ePub, HTML.  She will send out a link to those that are piloting next week when they move to a different external server.
 +
 +
Adjourned 12:25PM
 +
 +
 +
 +
===Meeting Outcomes===
 +
{|border="1" cellpadding="2" cellspacing="0"
 +
|-
 +
<!---==============================================================
 +
|                                                                |
 +
|    AAAA    CCCCC  TTTTTT  IIIIII  OOOOO  NN    NN  SSSSS    |
 +
|  AA  AA  CC        TT      II    OO  OO  NNN  NN  SS        |
 +
|  AAAAAA  CC        TT      II    OO  OO  NN NN NN  SSSS      |
 +
|  AA  AA  CC        TT      II    OO  OO  NN  NNN      SS    |
 +
|  AA  AA  CCCCC    TT    IIIIII  OOOOO  NN    NN  SSSSS      |
 +
|                                                                |
 +
===============================================================--->
 +
 +
| width="100%" align="left" style="background:#f0f0f0;"|'''Actions''' ''
 +
 +
 +
|-
 +
<!---=======================================================================
 +
|                                                                          |
 +
|  NN    NN  EEEEEE  XX  XX  TTTTTT      MM    MM  TTTTTT  GGGGG      |
 +
|  NNN  NN  EE      XX XX    TT        MMM  MMM    TT    GG          |
 +
|  NN NN NN  EEEE      XXX      TT        MM MMM MM    TT    GG  GGG    |
 +
|  NN  NNN  EE      XX XX    TT        MM  M  MM    TT    GG  GG    |
 +
|  NN    NN  EEEEEE  XX  XX    TT        MM    MM    TT    GGGGG      |
 +
|                                                                          |
 +
========================================================================--->
 +
 +
|width="100%" |'''Next Meeting/Preliminary Agenda Items'''<br/>
 +
 +
|}
 +
  
  
 
* [[Tuesday Tooling Nights]] lists historical agendas from Tuesday Tooling nights which are led by Andy at each WGM
 
* [[Tuesday Tooling Nights]] lists historical agendas from Tuesday Tooling nights which are led by Andy at each WGM
 
* Approved '''[http://www.hl7.org/Special/committees/v3toolstaskforce/minutes.cfm Tooling Work Group Minutes]''' are on HL7.org; draft telecon minutes are on [[Telecon Agendas]]
 
* Approved '''[http://www.hl7.org/Special/committees/v3toolstaskforce/minutes.cfm Tooling Work Group Minutes]''' are on HL7.org; draft telecon minutes are on [[Telecon Agendas]]
 +
 +
 +
[[Tooling Work Group | Return to Tooling]]
 +
 +
 +
© 2013 Health Level Seven® International.  All rights reserved.

Latest revision as of 17:05, 26 September 2013

Tooling WG Agenda for the Sep 2013 WGM in Cambridge MA USA

Return to Tooling Work Group page.

Day Date Time   Room Event Host joining Chair Scribe Notes
Monday Sep 23 AM Q1        
Q2          
PM Q3    
Q4 )  
Day Date Time   Room Event Host joining Chair Scribe Notes
Tuesday 9/24 AM Q1 Empress East Introduction to Tooling Work Group - Processes, Projects & Collaborations
See our morning slides 		Tooling   Andy Stechishin
Q2 Empress East Project updates: MAX, EHRS-FM Profile Designer, Trifolia TD Tooling   Michael Lynn  
PM Q3 Molly Pitcher Hosted by Structured Docs (need to confirm) ITS, MnM, Tooling (Andy), V3 Publishing    
Q4              
7-9PM Riverside Pavilion Tuesday Tooling Night ( details) Tooling RIMBAA Andy    
Day Date Time   Room Event Host joining Chair Scribe Notes
Wednesday Sep 25 AM Q1              
Q2    
PM Q3  
Q4
Day Date Time   Room Event Host joining Chair Scribe Notes
Thursday Sep 26 AM Q1 Empress West Project Topics: V3 Generator, Migration Planning, Tooling Challenge
AMS conformance tooling intro (15 mins) 		Tooling Andy Lynn
Q2 Empress West Tooling Strategy Discussion, Update from liaisons to other WG, Tactical Plan Tooling Tooling liaisons Michael Lynn  
PM Q3 Guest Room 209 Tools for development RIMBAA Tooling RIMBAA    
Q4              
Day Date Time   Room Event Host joining Chair Scribe Notes
Friday 9/27 AM Q1 Aquarium Joining Templates Templates Tooling, Patient Care, Structured Docs     TBD
Q2              
PM Q3              
Q4              


Meeting Information

HL7 Tooling Meeting Agenda/Minutes

Location: Empress East

Date: 2013-09-24
Time: 9AM Eastern
Facilitator: Andy Note taker(s): Andy
Attendee Name, Affiliation
x Attila Farkas, CHI (AF)
x Alexander Henket, NICTIZ (AH)
regrets Lynn Laakso, HL7 HQ Tooling Support
x Andy Stechishin, Co-chair (AS)
regrets Michael van der Zel, co-chair
x Tessa van Stijn, NICTIZ (TvS)
Quorum Requirements Met (co-chair plus 3 counting staff): (yes)

Q1 notes Tues Q1

  • Attendees were experienced Tooling participants and decided to forego the usual introduction to Tooling and cover tooling concerns.
  • At suggestion of chair, session was an open discussion on concerns/issues/needs from participants
  • AH and TvS opened discussion with queries on the direction for Template exchange and use of DECOR
  • AS gave an overview of the progress on the use of DECOR in the Templates ITS
  • AF had questions on the use of CDA Templates in the European jurisdictions and AS, AH, TvS gave overviews of the various functionality and capabilities of ART/DECOR
  • AF spoke about the Canadian activities and the overlap that was occurring between the realms and wondered if there was possibilities for sharing work/resources/experiences. AS said that Tooling would be happy to serve as a forum for these joint discussions. AH also suggested that HL7 Tooling would assist in the development of tools by defining the mechanisms for sharing of the core design artifacts.


HL7 Tooling Meeting Agenda/Minutes

Location: Empress East

Date: 2013-09-24
Time: 11AM Eastern
Facilitator: Andy Note taker(s): Lynn Laakso
Attendee Name, Affiliation
x. Liora Alschuler, Lantana .
x Bo Dagnall, HP
x Sarah Gaunt, Lantana
x Alexander Henket
x Lynn Laakso, HL7 HQ Tooling Support
x Craig Purdon, Standards Australia
x Stephen Royce, NEHTA (AUS)
x Kanwarpreet Sethi, Lantana
x Andy Stechishin, Co-chair
x Michael van der Zel, co-chair
x Tessa van Stijn, NICTIZ
Quorum Requirements Met (co-chair plus 3 counting staff): (yes)

Agenda

Agenda Topics

  • Project Updates
    • MAX
    • Trifolia


Minutes

Minutes/Conclusions Reached:

Andy convenes at 11:07 AM

  • Michael describes the MAX tooling
    • EA extension, and next will address making it available to others beyond CIC
    • Export capability to flat format for non-technical user review also for schematron discussed
    • Bo discusses such an approach to use for the Business Architecture Model (BAM) for ArB - how to handle cascading many-to-many relationships for multiple objects. Michael noted the use case.
    • Kanwareet (KP) asks if they considered schematron directly against the UML, but it does not include everything for the functional models and they wanted an universal common format.
  • Sarah reviews the latest Trifolia release
    • Publishing tool, template versioning, and other features added.
    • Andy comments that the template status field should consider using the Templates Business Process requirements for those field values.

Thursday Sep 26 Q1

HL7 Tooling Meeting Agenda/Minutes

Location: Riverside Pavilion

Date: 2013-09-26
Time: 9 AM Eastern
Facilitator: Andy Note taker(s): Lynn
Attendee Name, Affiliation
x Woody Beeler
x Alexander Henket, NICTIZ
Abdul-Malik Shakir
x Andy Stechishin, Co-chair
x Michael van der Zel, co-chair
x Lynn Laakso, scribe
Quorum Requirements Met (co-chair plus 3 counting staff): (yes)

Agenda

Project Topics:

  • V3 Generator,
  • Migration Planning,
  • Tooling Challenge
  • AMS conformance tooling intro (15 mins)

Meeting Outcomes

Convene at 9:14 AM

  • Vocabulary maintenance language (VML) for vocabulary update
    • Value triplet properties, history of process evolution discussed and the remaining manual intervention required.
    • Russ did a java program posting from VML to Access db. Woody extended VML for xhtml markup for definitions recently. RIM-repos has the vocab tables db. Right now it's a tool for three people, e.g. Woody, Ted, Russ; would like to expand. Woody does not want to modify the Vocab db. ACTION: Need to revisit this in San Antonio.
    • Alexander asks about coreMIFs for each release having the same date. There is no versioning in the database, Woody reports. This is a weakness of the Database and a known issue but have been ignoring it for so long they forget. He recommends vocabulary MIF-diff files to see what has changed.
  • Rosetree has simplified user interface. Issues with Visio controls discussed
    • Andy asks if we need a browser overlay. It would be nice, but Visio environment is the concern. The Tooling Challenge is meant to address this but is not necessarily of a scope reasonable to the prize.
    • SMD included dependency on RIM file and needed new tool for each release of RIM. Michael notes that AML (Architecture Modeling Language) has been discussed to adapt UML for CIMI, OpenEHR and HL7 modeling use. There are parts of that in his profile for MIF. Sparx and RSA may implement it if they get an OMG profile approved. Woody notes the ability to move around classes, add new classes and subclass attributes are desirable. Michael notes the AML is applicable beyond health care. Andy notes that while there's not a lot of work going on in this space we don't want to leave it orphaned, and still requires investment each year to keep it up to date.
    • RMIM designer in visio works better than the UML templates in Visio and our audience is spoiled.
    • Woody asks about the state of the RFP from OMG - Michael clarifies it was more of an RFI and they are working on an RFP.
  • Woody notes that improvements in the Canadian Generator exist and need to migrate rather than replicate their upgrades. He hasn't had time this summer to work on it and needs a three-week stretch to focus.
  • Wish to build an internal web platform for members-only, that looks like a ballot site, for future normative edition publication material and meeting ANSI publication guidelines. Then it will be frozen and zipped into a normative edition. A web version of the NE was created for the Help Desk and that type of platform can be reused. Non-V3 type material like IGs are linked from the NE pages. What about CDA IGs? Woody notes they have not normally been in our publishing space. They are not typically included in the ZIP files.
    • He isolated an error in the RMIM designer in Visio this summer and it was very time consuming.
    • Woody would like to seek retraction of support for Visio 2002. Motion:' He moves we notify the cochairs, editors and internationaladmin lists in addition to Tooling the intent of Tooling's consideration to drop support for Visio 2002 effective with review at 2014JanuaryWGM in San Antonio. Michael seconds. Michael asks about establishing the principle to remove support with the vendor end-of-life. The Rosetree stuff is well beyond end of life, however, without a replacement. Alexander suggests we survey the affiliates as well. Vote: unanimously approved
  • Tooling challenge
    • What do we do with the Tooling Challenge entries, and their IP. If similar to Eclipse Public License, then derivative works must refer to the original IP but can develop further. Could make them backwards transformable to MIF.
    • RIM maintenance moved to RSA two years ago, but process is to export RSA, and then manage in MIF with a reverse transform for GUIDs assigned. Woody is now interested in migrating it to EA with graphics and annotations. Michael and Harold have used an extension to sanitize the EA XML. Woody will draft some documentation on the migration before suggesting a formal motion.
    • EMF stuff from last year is linked from January 2012s minutes.
    • How to package the Tooling Challenge winning entry with documentation and user guide and put it out there for people to use (Package release)? Is it members-only? What about Sparx, if they're not members should they have access? Needs further discussion on a call
  • AMS not present, adjourned 10:38 AM.


Thursday Sep 26 Q2

HL7 Tooling Meeting Agenda/Minutes

Location: Empress East

Date: 2013-09-26
Time: 11:00AM Eastern
Facilitator: Andy Note taker(s): Lynn Laakso
Attendee Name, Affiliation
x Jeff Brown, HL7 ES liaison
x Matthew Graham, Mayo, Mobile Health
x Alexander Henket, NICTIZ
x Tony Julian, Mayo
x Lynn Laakso, HL7 HQ Tooling Support
x Frank McKinney, consulting
x Tim McNeil, Surescripts
x Frank Oemig
x Andy Stechishin, Co-chair
regrets Michael van der Zel, co-chair
x Sara Stewart, NIST
Quorum Requirements Met (co-chair plus 3 counting staff): (yes)

Agenda

Agenda Topics
Tooling Strategy Discussion, Update from liaisons to other WG, Tactical Plan

Minutes

  • Roll Call & Agenda Review
  • Update from Tooling Liaisons:
    • Electronic Services - Jeff Brown
      • shift in process on dependency on HQ staff with Josh Carmody's departure- new person starts October 1st, setback with ES and ES Tooling; they are reprioritizing.
    • CGIT - Rob Snelick represented by Sara Stewart shows a short slide presentation
      • Messaging Work Bench - Pete gave MWB to NIST. NIST did analysis and recommendations to compile and placed it into open source. Matt Graham/Tony assert Mayo has gotten it to compile. Matt took code from sourceforge and migrated to Delphi 7 and identified missing libraries. There are few Delphi developers left but some at Mayo. Long term maintenance is unclear. Need updated version of V2.x Access db from Frank Oemig and Tony/Matt will import.
      • NIST is developing in Java an IG authoring and management tool extending profiling capabilities of MWG, currently in demo/pilot phase. Matt suggests a MWB listserv for existing users. Andy suggests using the Tooling listserv for now.
      • Tony asks if HL7 wants to fund Regex expression license for current regex. Matt notes it's 80 Euro with source code. Without source it's $50, per developer. Andy will talk to John about it. Excel spreadsheet-like dialog and component set license would be separate but belongs to a dead code thread so is probably unnecessary.
    • CIC - AMS is not available
    • CS - Rik Smithies is not available
    • Education - Diego Kaminker is not available
    • EHR - John Ritter is not available
    • Marketing - Rene Spronk is not available
    • Patient Care, RIMBAA - Michael Van der Zel is not available.
      • Andy reports from RIMBAA that there was not anything particular to Tooling, but interesting presentations on Tooling Tuesday but no issues.
    • Alexander Henket notes that if PA does not have a liaison he can fill that role. If we have requirements solicitation we will ping him.
    • Structured Documents, (Vocabulary), Publishing - Andy Stechishin
      • SDWG Tuesday Q3 focused on publishing quality IG subgroup. They will continue to meet monthly and they look at how publishing issues can be resolved in the tooling. Trifolia is not officially endorsed but may seek endorsement. No other updates from publishing.
    • Templates, Open Health Tools - Jane Curry is not available; Andy will find out more tomorrow. Templates ITS for CDA IG exchange has focused on DÉCOR format in EU, which currently maps to Trifolia but not sure on MDHT - awaiting status from Keith Boone.
      • Continuing investigations into the API/interface with the HingX tool.
    Tooling-sponsored Projects
    • PI# 801 Tooling Strategy and Process Revision - tentative plan has been endorsed by TSC; still pending review by Board, but needs refresh and review already. Vitality assessment discussions in ArB noted by Andy and MvdZel and spurring review Tooling architecture documents to bring up to date and refine them based on strategy. Seek to present an updated Tooling Strategy in San Antonio and perhaps even an updated architecture.
    • Mobile health looking at a project with GS1 that may involve Tooling (Harry Rhodes/Christian Hay)- Andy invites him to bring the project to Tooling as co-sponsor. May need an iOS developers' license. May be setting up tracking attendees through mobile app. Google playstore licensing and Android platform development unknown. ACTION ITEM: Andy will talk to John and Mark about an iOS developers' license for HL7. They hope for a prototype for January. Matt Graham will act as liaison.
  • Sara then shows a slide show and pilot of the IGAMT. She is running a local Tomcat server but can run a web server. What is the process for saving local copies of values when running the web server - Andy points out that corporate browsers won't allow saving to local storage. They use DITA processing chain for such documentation. Andy cautions DITA conversions for ePub, HTML. She will send out a link to those that are piloting next week when they move to a different external server.

Adjourned 12:25PM


Meeting Outcomes

Actions


Next Meeting/Preliminary Agenda Items



Return to Tooling


© 2013 Health Level Seven® International. All rights reserved.

Retrieved from "https://wiki.hl7.org/w/index.php?title=Tooling_WGM_2013_Sep&oldid=78550"