Tools for RIM based software development

Tools for RIM based software development are software toolkits that can be used by software developers to support/implement HL7's RIM-based standards.

Notes:

1. Most tools within HL7 cater to 'standards creators', i.e. tools that support the standards development process. See e.g. HL7 Tooling FAQs and HL7.org toolkit page.
2. The term "implementation" is commonly/historically used in HL7 to identify "the process of creating implementation guides" (the definition of a contextualized profile for a universal HL7 standard), whereas software developers would understand "implementation" to mean "software implementation / software development". For that reason this page avoids the term altogether.

The list below contains HL7-sponsored or HL7-developed tools, as well as open source, public domain, or commercial tools. By default all listed tools are open source and public domain. Commercial tools are (and: SHALL be) explicitely identified as such.

Tool evaluation process

Aims of the process:

• Make it easier to implement HL7's RIM-based standards by
  • evaluating candidate tools or toolkits, and publish the results. The evaluation process will be open and based on objective criteria (see below for a list). Note: no endorsement, no certification, but evalution.
  • making these evaluations known to software developers (see Tooling Communication Plan), thereby allowing them to select any tools that may fit their particular context and programming platform. In conjunction with these evaluation results (a) information should be made available that is minimalistically sufficient to enable an implementer to understand the main charcteristics and goals of the tool, and (b) identifies where additional information can be found and where the tool can be downloaded.

The evaluation process itself consists of the following:

• all tools can be nominated by any party to be evaluated
• as part of the evaluation it is determined what tool category (as identified below) the tool belongs to - each tool category may have category specific evaluation criteria (e.g. code generators may have certain desirable characteristics, whereas testing tools have different characteristics)
  • a tool may not fit in any existing tool category because it's either 'out of scope' for this evaluation process, or because a new tool category needs to be added to the list.
• new evaluation criteria (whether general or tool category specific), and new tool categories, may be proposed by any party
• the evaluation proces itself will be the responsibility of N? RIMBAA?/Tooling? members elected by the WG. Those responsible may sollicit help from those more knowledgable about certain tools during the evaluation process.
• all tools are re-evaluated after 1? year, or after a major release of the tool.

Tool Categories

Implementation tools that RIMBAA has identified include the ones below, sorted by the type of audience/task they support:

Tools that directly suport the software development process:

Lvl	Tool Category	Description	Examples (todo: links!)	v3 msg	v3 CDA	RIMBAA	FHIR
1	MIF Parser	MIF consumption, API to use MIF (all MIF packages)		x	x	x
1	HL7 processable artefact definition based code generator	Includes serialization (which is independent of ITS)
2	MIF based class/code generators	Includes serialization (which is independent of ITS)	MDHT, Everest, JavaSIG	x	x	x
2	XSD based class/code generators	Includes serialization (which is independent of ITS)	JaxB	x	x	x	x
1	MIF based UI generators	Constrained information model to UI element				x	x
1	Datatypes library	Classes, operations, may include serialization
2	ISO Datatypes library	Classes, operations, may include serialization	Everest	x	x	x
2	FHIR Datatypes library	Classes, operations, may include serialization				x	x
1	CTS products		Apelon, LexGRID, Healthlanguagecommercial	x	x	x	x
1	Mapping tools		Open Mapping Software	x	x	x	x
1	RIM Based Persistence Layer	inclusive of OO-API, as a base platform for application development. Subtype: ORM layer to abstract the data types (e.g. an enhanced Hibernate)	JavaSIG, MGRIDcommercial, Oracle HTBcommercial			x	x
1	MIF to model transformation	to any other model, includes a MIF Parser		x	x	x	x
2	MIF to UML transformation			x	x	x	?
2	MIF based schema and schematron generator		SchemaGenerator	x	x
2	MIF based database schema generator	for RIM, datatypes (and versions thereof), or R-MIMs	MGRIDcommercial?			x	x

Tools that support software developers:

Tool Category	Description	Examples
Set of testcases/examples	to test ones code. Or test framework such as IHE Gazelle.
Model Based Testing tools		Instance Editor, MDHT
An example of a software implementation	testing, playing around
MIF visualization tool	show condensed view

Tools that are used by analysts/providers:

Tool Category	Description	Examples
Model Driven application generation tools	(static/dynamic/UIs/..)	PHI Technology
Model Driven documentation generators		PHI Technology
MIF based UI designers	binding UI wireframe to model elements

Tool Evaluation Criteria

The following list of general criteria (independent of to which tool category the tool belongs to) should aid HL7/RIMBAA in evaluating tools:

Criterium	Description
Offers support	Up to date documentation, Availability of skilled resources and services
Continued development	Follow developments within HL7 (with a reasonable time lag)
Proven usage	Used at least 1, or x, sites
Reusable	open architecture, developed for re-use as a component in a different "stack", not be tied into one particular solution stack
Unambiguous license	No prohibitive licensing small-print, For open products: use should not effectively require the purchase of non-open parts. No hidden "Widget-frosting", should be known ahead of time.
No cost barrier	Low cost preferred over high cost