FHIR Infrastructure Minutes CC 20150729

FHIR Infrastructure Conference Call 3:00PM Eastern Time (Date above)

Return to FHIR Infrastructure Minutes

Agenda

• Block votes, see below
• 6194 remove the parenthetical resources (Eric Haas) None
• 7542 2015May core #833 - registry URLS (Grahame Grieve) None
• 8047 2015May core #1372 - Add UIR for NPI (National Provider ID) (Tim McNeil) None
• 8171 Profile HTML pages should have default values from base resources grayed out if missing in differential (Jason Mathews) None
• 8452 Add StructureDefinition.invariants (Lloyd McKenzie) None

Attendees

• James Agnew
• JOsh Mandel
• Grahame Grieve
• Brian Pech
• Eric Haas

Actions

• block votes: passed as a block: James Agnew / Grahame Grieve: 4-0-0
• 6194 - approved
• 7542 - approved
• 8047 - approved
• 8171 - approved
• 8452 - modified

Adjournment

Call adjourned 3:50pm Eastern

Block Vote #1

• 7449 2015May core #737 - Typo (George Cole) Considered - No action required
• 7987 2015May core #1307 - Ignore (Brett Marquard) Considered - No action required
• 6800 2015May sdc #17 - Contained resources inline? (Lloyd McKenzie) Considered for Future Use
• 7433 2015May core #721 - Harmonisztion Contsys ISO 13940 (Helen Broberg) Considered for Future Use
• 7437 2015May core #725 - Harmonization with ISO EN 13606 Harmonisztion Contsys ISO 13940 (Helen Broberg) Considered for Future Use
• 7936 2015May core #1256 - Guidelines for Resource Integrity Management within Conformance (Sean Moore) Considered for Future Use
• 7948 2015May core #1268 - Suggestions for Event definition via ValueSet Resource (Sean Moore) Considered for Future Use
• 7970 2015May core #1290 - Sugest to add comparison with relatd non-HL7 specs as well, notably DICOM (Rene Spronk) Considered for Future Use
• 6804 2015May sdc #21 - IG-specific schemas (Lloyd McKenzie) Not Persuasive
• 6851 2015May sdc #68 - When will extensions move to core? (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive
• 6854 2015May sdc #71 - Add authorization qualifier to 'vread' (James Kretz) Not Persuasive
• 6855 2015May sdc #72 - Add authorization qualifier to 'update' (James Kretz) Not Persuasive
• 6856 2015May sdc #73 - Add authorization qualifier to 'history' (James Kretz) Not Persuasive
• 6857 2015May sdc #74 - Add authorization qualifier to 'delete' (James Kretz) Not Persuasive
• 6858 2015May sdc #75 - Add authorization qualifier to 'history' (James Kretz) Not Persuasive
• 6924 2015May sdc #147 - The need to page through large lists in application context, requires that we support paging capabilities. (Calvin Beebe) Not Persuasive
• 7010 2015May core #75 - Section on Signatures are "todo" (Andy Bond) Not Persuasive
• 7240 2015May core #300 - no input (Clem McDonald) Not Persuasive
• 7241 2015May core #301 - This will be a problem (Clem McDonald) Not Persuasive
• 7245 2015May core #305 - ??? (Clem McDonald) Not Persuasive
• 7246 2015May core #306 - ??? (Clem McDonald) Not Persuasive
• 7451 2015May core #739 - Move extensions to core (George Cole) Not Persuasive
• 7699 2015May core #990 - How do we prevent improperly defined/inappropriate extensions? (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive
• 8084 2015May core #1466 - It must be possible to download a version which can be read offline (Frank Oemig) Not Persuasive
• 8152 2015May daf #187 - What does it take for an extension to be added to a resource. We are in DSTU2 and already have a lot of Patient and Observation extensions already. Should they be added to FHIR Normative 1? Are they forever extensions. Please explain i (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive
• 8153 2015May daf #188 - Some clarification in "2.14.0.1.2 System Profiles" would be useful to indicate to server implementers that they need to be aware of "unrecognized" modifier extensions? (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive
• 6850 2015May sdc #67 - What's behavior for modifier extensions? (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 6853 2015May sdc #70 - Add authorization qualifier to 'read' (James Kretz) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 7041 2015May core #106 - It would be helpful if this value set had a code to indicate a List is accurate within the context it is used in (Andy Bond) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 7243 2015May core #303 - Don’t know what is included (Clem McDonald) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 7371 2015May core #561 - Narrative only shouldn't be a List (David Tao) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 7372 2015May core #562 - See my comment on 6.1.5 -- it does not make sense to call these types of narrative a "List." (David Tao) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 7452 2015May core #740 - How do we avoid duplicate extensions? (George Cole) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 7991 2015May core #1315 - Does including this in a ballot upgrade the status to proposed? Where can folks track the discusision on this resource? (Brett Marquard) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 8150 2015May daf #181 (Claude Nanjo) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 8165 2015May core #975b - Add authorization qualifier to 'read' (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 7028 2015May core #93 - Is this an actual value? :) (Andy Bond) Not Related
• 7287 2015May core #477 - Is it permissable to use http://blame-Grahame.com/operations instead? (Corey Spears) Not Related
• 6862 2015May sdc #79 - Small XSD facets issue. (James Kretz) Persuasive
• 7027 2015May core #92 - Missing content / TODO (Andy Bond) Persuasive
• 7285 2015May core #475 - No content is provieded in this section (Corey Spears) Persuasive
• 7368 2015May core #558 - Narrative should contain all human-relevant discrete data (David Tao) Persuasive
• 7387 2015May core #577 - Add link to documents from Resources page under "Documents (David Tao) Persuasive
• 7994 2015May core #1318 - How did the authors decide to include 'to 2 significant figures'? In the next row it states 'to 4 significant figures'. (Brett Marquard) Persuasive
• 7996 2015May core #1320 - Did you consider listing the supported comparators or the minimum you expect systems to support? (Brett Marquard) Persuasive
• 8051 2015May core #1376 - Link broken (Tim McNeil) Persuasive
• 8053 2015May core #1378 - Link broken (Tim McNeil) Persuasive
• 5870 Alert should have encounter (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive with Mod
• 6311 Need better explanation of DataElement Slicing (Rob McClure) Persuasive with Mod
• 6799 2015May sdc #16 - Warn about schema-centric implementation. (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive with Mod
• 7284 2015May core #474 - No content is provieded in this section (Corey Spears) Persuasive with Mod
• 7370 2015May core #560 - How is list narrative made non-redundant if generated? (David Tao) Persuasive with Mod
• 7388 2015May core #578 - Soften language on presentation of the document changing. (David Tao) Persuasive with Mod
• 7450 2015May core #738 - How is unknown extensions support declareD? (George Cole) Persuasive with Mod
• 7460 2015May core #748 - Allow non-resources to be focus of Provenance (George Cole) Persuasive with Mod
• 7551 2015May core #842 - Current Problem List (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive with Mod
• 7572 2015May core #863 - Explain business-specific details of update (Ioana Singureanu) Persuasive with Mod
• 7787 2015May core #1108 - Need to create and document processes for achieving interoperability using FHIR (Mark Kramer) Persuasive with Mod
• 7931 2015May core #1251 - Further clarification for variant searches within compartments (Sean Moore) Persuasive with Mod
• 7935 2015May core #1255 - Transaction Integrity Guidelines in Read and Search (Sean Moore) Persuasive with Mod
• 7976 2015May core #1296 - Add option for a receiver to send responses to mailbox endpoint of the source (Rene Spronk) Persuasive with Mod
• 8079 2015May core #1461 - More structured approach to conformance resource (Zoran Milosevic) Persuasive with Mod
• 8080 2015May core #1462 - FHIR section 6.16.3 does not describe all UML classes (Zoran Milosevic) Persuasive with Mod
• 8081 2015May core #1463 - The concept of profile needs further consolidation (Zoran Milosevic) Persuasive with Mod

Block Vote #2

• 5183 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #57 (Claude Nanjo) Considered - No action required
• 5340 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #221 (Gary Dickinson) Considered - No action required
• 5869 add comment about ADT processing to valueset (David Hay) Considered - No action required
• 8362 Search query under single query parameter (Krzysztof Suchomski) Considered - Question Answered
• 5178 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #52 (Mark Kramer) Considered for Future Use
• 5822 Querying for data elements across Resources, Profiles and extensions (Mark Roche) Considered for Future Use
• 5933 Add a search criteria for Bundle.entry (Lloyd McKenzie) Considered for Future Use
• 6120 add http statucode and resource content in operationoutcome (Wanghaisheng) Considered for Future Use
• 6389 A FHIR Registry should be indetifiable (Rob Mulders) Considered for Future Use
• 8364 New List operations $add and $delete (Brian Postlethwate) Considered for Future Use
• 3898 missing language, text, contained in composition conent (Jingdong Li) Not Persuasive
• 3937 Add option to get TagList based on search (Alexander Henket) Not Persuasive
• 5176 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #50 (Mark Kramer) Not Persuasive
• 5929 Restricting references to profiled resources is a gigantic, error-prone productivity sink (Mark Kramer) Not Persuasive
• 5930 No way to restrict "Any" resource references to profiled resources (Mark Kramer) Not Persuasive
• 6110 Possible inconsistencies in Conformance Resource elements (Ewout Kramer) Not Persuasive
• 6278 StructureDefinition URI SHOULD be dereferenceable to an authoritative definition (David Booth) Not Persuasive
• 8087 StructureDefinition.experimental (Wanghaisheng) Not Persuasive
• 8170 Conformance needs a way to express a server does not accept unknown extensions (Ewout Kramer) Not Persuasive
• 8260 Composition.subject should be 0..1 (David Hay) Not Persuasive
• 8294 Comments section not visible (Christiaan Knaap) Not Persuasive
• 8334 No description for Bundle.type attribute (Finnie Flores) Not Persuasive
• 8335 No description/definition for Bundle.entry.search.mode attribute (Finnie Flores) Not Persuasive
• 3957 Make support of Get for search optional (Lee Coller) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 5161 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #27 (Claude Nanjo) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 5319 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #199 (David Tao) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 5403 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #292 (Matthew Graham) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 6123 change _id search param type from token to string (Wanghaisheng) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 8086 Create best practice wording on how to deal with large scale OID URI strategy (Alexander Henket) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 3280 Profiles for behaviour of document post to mailbox (Richard Schneider) Not Related
• 6146 confliction between explanation to Bundle.link.url in search response (Wanghaisheng) Not Related
• 6096 Bundle resource has no elements that are marked as "in summary" (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive
• 6139 Resource.Id and Resource.meta not in summary (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive
• 6167 need more clear clarification (Wanghaisheng) Persuasive
• 6183 Broken link in Attachment description (Scott Deerwester) Persuasive
• 6226 Search summary table misses entry for _query (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive
• 6307 Specify dot-notation for element name (Chris Grenz) Persuasive
• 8111 Clarify description of OperationDefinition.idempotent (Dunmail Hodkinson) Persuasive
• 8121 Allow additional search results when an advanced search algorithm is available (Michael Donnelly) Persuasive
• 8124 Clinical Resource categories (Richard Kavanagh) Persuasive
• 8162 "Complete Conformance Statement" is incomplete (Simone Heckmann) Persuasive
• 8167 What to do when I encounter unknown elements in a FHIR payload? (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive
• 8174 Typo on REST/API page (Christiaan Knaap) Persuasive
• 8187 Correct Language about outcome of translation operation (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive
• 8230 Display for filter-operator "=" code is " " (Scott Deerwester) Persuasive
• 8233 Add searchRevInclude to Conformance (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive
• 8284 Profile vs StructureDefinition on Conformance rules (Christiaan Knaap) Persuasive
• 8285 Profiling examples are still DSTU1 (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive
• 8287 Profile to StructureDefinition (Christiaan Knaap) Persuasive
• 8288 Profile still used as example (Christiaan Knaap) Persuasive
• 8296 New explanation for discriminator (Christiaan Knaap) Persuasive
• 8309 Constraints can be used to constrain extensions too (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive
• 8342 include the option for a client to specify whether the updated resource is to be included in a transaction response (David Hay) Persuasive
• 8365 Relative URLs in reference search parameter (Michele Mottini) Persuasive
• 8370 We're ambiguous about allowing relative urls for reference-type search parameters (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive
• 3361 Message endpoints should be associated with the event protocol (Richard Schneider) Persuasive with Mod
• 3978 Unclear how do search using messaging (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive with Mod
• 5174 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #48 (Mark Kramer) Persuasive with Mod
• 5313 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #192 (David Tao) Persuasive with Mod
• 5374 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #261 (Ioana Singureanu) Persuasive with Mod
• 5387 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #274 (Jay Lyle) Persuasive with Mod
• 5584 There are two overlapping mailbox constructs - remove one (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive with Mod
• 5856 typo error (Wanghaisheng) Persuasive with Mod
• 5987 remove isSummary from Resource Definintion (Eric Haas) Persuasive with Mod
• 6060 Documentation of extensions for simple types (Elliott Lavy) Persuasive with Mod
• 6085 Add discussion of profile consistency to profile page (Mark Kramer) Persuasive with Mod
• 6087 No way to specify multiple bindings (with different strengths)? (Michael Lawley) Persuasive with Mod
• 6106 add a entry for a single file containing all the structure definition datatype and resource (Wanghaisheng) Persuasive with Mod
• 6108 Clarify FHIR server behavior (http codes, body, outcome etc) while CREATE with id, UPDATE without id (Nikolay Ryzhikov) Persuasive with Mod
• 6140 Schema error for Age, Count, etc. (Elliott Lavy) Persuasive with Mod
• 6184 BCP-13 and BCP-47 should be in the coding system list (Scott Deerwester) Persuasive with Mod
• 6187 need to also refer to both SturctureDefinition and ElementDefintion (Eric Haas) Persuasive with Mod
• 6234 suggestion to add a feature like _fields (John Moehrke) Persuasive with Mod
• 6257 Need additional prefixes for date search parameters (Chris Toomey) Persuasive with Mod
• 6796 2015May sdc #13 - Various comments (Clem McDonald) Persuasive with Mod
• 6934 How does escaping work in composite URI searches? (Alexander Henket) Persuasive with Mod
• 8113 Need additional documentation on List resource about List semantics (Claude Nanjo) Persuasive with Mod
• 8159 word clarify (Wanghaisheng) Persuasive with Mod
• 8172 transaction-operation coding system doesn't correspond to transaction-operation value set (Scott Deerwester) Persuasive with Mod
• 8234 What are "the standard search parameters" (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive with Mod
• 8321 Extensibility documentation should explain representation for primitive data types in JSON (Scott Deerwester) Persuasive with Mod
• 8333 Missing Examples for other usage identified (Finnie Flores) Persuasive with Mod
• 8339 Allow a server to specify that eTags are required for updates (David Hay) Persuasive with Mod
• 8341 conformance versioning detail not consistent (David Hay) Persuasive with Mod
• 8353 Non-resource-specific pages should include responsible WG (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive with Mod
• 8363 No place for a displayname in SearchParameter (Marten Smits) Persuasive with Mod
• 8371 content-type=application/x-www-form-urlencoded (Wanghaisheng) Persuasive with Mod

Block Vote #3

• 7800 2015May core #1122 - Tools aren't checking cardinality alignment (Jason Mathews) None
• 7683 2015May core #974 - Add security guidance for 'read' (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive
• 7685 2015May core #976 - Add authorization qualifier to 'vread' (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive
• 7686 2015May core #977 - Add authorization qualifier to 'update' (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive
• 7688 2015May core #979 - Add authorization qualifier to 'delete' (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive
• 7758 2015May core #1079 - FHIR Profiles should always identify what they have changed with respect to cardinality, bindings, or data type restriction (Keith Boone) Not Persuasive
• 7783 2015May core #1104 - Profile snapshot views are not complete. (Jason Walonoski) Not Persuasive
• 8126 2015May daf #23 - Differential vs Snapshot view best practices. (Ollie Gray) Not Persuasive
• 7687 2015May core #978 - Add authorization qualifier to 'history' (Ioana Singureanu) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 8032 2015May core #1357 - Code inconsistent (Larry Babb) Not Persuasive with Mod
• 6822 2015May sdc #39 - Incomplete cardinalities in Differential Table view. (Nancy Orvis, Wei Guo, Ollie Gray) Not Related
• 8132 2015May daf #32 - Profile title suggestion (Ollie Gray) Not Related
• 8134 2015May daf #34 - Profile title suggestion (Ollie Gray) Not Related
• 6229 extension definition still very hard to read (Eric Haas) Persuasive
• 6797 2015May sdc #14 - Show the actual data type for References (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive
• 6824 2015May sdc #41 - Provide XML (Nancy Orvis, Wei Guo, Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 6827 2015May sdc #44 - Fix page numberings (Nancy Orvis, Wei Guo, Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 6829 2015May sdc #46 - Declare references as Reference(x) (Nancy Orvis, Wei Guo, Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 6832 2015May sdc #49 - JSON template not in All view (Nancy Orvis, Wei Guo, Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 6833 2015May sdc #50 - Links to structure definitions don't resolve (Nancy Orvis, Wei Guo, Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 6834 2015May sdc #51 - XML representation for last "value*" element should have the entire element crossed out not just its description. (Nancy Orvis, Wei Guo, Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 6840 2015May sdc #57 - Labels on different tabs should be different (Nancy Orvis, Wei Guo, Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 6849 2015May sdc #66 - Add Search capabilities to FHIR DSTU and FHIR Continuous build sites. (Ioana Singureanu) Persuasive
• 6907 2015May sdc #130 - Valueset could not be expanded (Riki Merrick) Persuasive
• 6910 2015May sdc #133 - why does the sentences states value set has 0 concepts? (Riki Merrick) Persuasive
• 7470 2015May core #765 - Finding the Table of Contents and Section numbers (Tom Oniki) Persuasive
• 8125 2015May daf #5 - Missing Concept Display Name (George Cole) Persuasive
• 8128 2015May daf #26 - Expand value set (Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 8129 2015May daf #27 - Profile title suggestion (Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 8130 2015May daf #28 - Profile title suggestion (Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 8136 2015May daf #36 - Profile title suggestion (Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 8137 2015May daf #45 - Profile title suggestion (Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 8138 2015May daf #48 - Duplicate Section Titles (Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 8151 2015May daf #186 - Add Search capabilities to FHIR DSTU and FHIR Continuous build sites. (Ioana Singureanu) Persuasive
• 8155 2015May daf #210 (David Tao) Persuasive
• 8156 2015May daf #211 - Broken link: http://www.hl7.org/FHIR/2015May/QICoreMedicationCodes.html#1.23.2.1.2088 (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive
• 8194 May2015 QICore #34 - Unreadable documentation page (Claude Nanjo) Persuasive
• 8196 MAY2015-QICore#61- Broken "link-to-here" (Tom Oniki) Persuasive
• 8197 MAY2015-QICore #62-63 - Show value set and strength instead of binding name (Tom Oniki) Persuasive
• 8262 2015May daf #50 - FHIR Version Number (Ollie Gray) Persuasive
• 8263 2015May daf #54 -Title: Extension: Data Absent Reason (David Parker) Persuasive
• 6189 differential view should only show what is different (Eric Haas) Persuasive with Mod
• 6838 2015May sdc #55 - TOC did not list all sections. (Nancy Orvis, Wei Guo, Ollie Gray) Persuasive with Mod
• 6908 2015May sdc #131 - fix link: generates 404 page error (Riki Merrick) Persuasive with Mod
• 6909 2015May sdc #132 - fiX link: generates 404 page error (Riki Merrick) Persuasive with Mod
• 7488 2015May core #783 - Clarification needed on the use of Data Element with other resources (Tom Oniki) Persuasive with Mod
• 7779 2015May core #1100 - Epub is corrupted (Jason Walonoski) Persuasive with Mod
• 7785 2015May core #1106 - Make sections of the full table of contents expandable/contractible (Mark Kramer) Persuasive with Mod
• 7790 2015May core #1111 - Documentation should be based on the profile XML. (Mark Kramer) Persuasive with Mod
• 8141 2015May daf #64 - remove entries from constraints and Term Bindings tables for referenceRange (David Parker) Persuasive with Mod

Block Vote #4

• 8182 A snapshot generator should resolve three dots to include the base narrative (Martijn Harthoorn) Not Persuasive
• 8398 Continuous build should reference svn revision number (Bryn Rhodes) Not Persuasive
• 6092 Individual Resource pages do not align with Resource names (Keith Boone) Persuasive
• 6578 NamingSystem bundle for FHIR distibution (Nikolay Ryzhikov) Persuasive
• 6783 Add a bundle of NamingSystems for known code systems/identifiers (Alexander Henket) Persuasive
• 8110 When "To many codes to display (>10000)" , show *some* of them (Josh Mandel) Persuasive
• 8235 Return behaviour of named queries: Bundle or Parameters (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive
• 8357 Extension display doesn't show cardinality for extension (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive
• 8416 Remove batch operations now that we have a batch interaction (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive
• 8417 Concept Designation Use binding - clarify SCT licensing issues (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive
• 8418 Add Period to Group Characteristic (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive
• 8427 Custodian of a Resource should be accessible through Provenance (Keith Boone) Persuasive
• 8430 Clarify how non-transaction/batch Bundle posts work when sent to the base URL (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive
• 8433 Add "logical" to StructureDefinition.kind (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive
• 8439 Add a value set for yes/no/don't know (common questionnaire combination) (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive
• 8444 Test Script should note relationship to other resources (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive
• 3327 FHIR Publish Tools - html rendering issue (Yongjian Bao) Persuasive with Mod
• 3836 Add constraining base node searches through ConformanceProfile (Alexander Henket) Persuasive with Mod
• 6365 Improve documentation about element (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive with Mod
• 8422 FHIR Spec Bread Crumbs need updating (Brett Marquard) Persuasive with Mod
• 8426 What is the effect of operations on _history? (Ewout Kramer) Persuasive with Mod
• 8429 $everything operation support _include directive? (Angelica Garcia) Persuasive with Mod