201704 Financial Track
Return to April 2017 Value-Based Care FHIR Mini-Connectathon
Financial Management
Submitting WG/Project/Implementer Group
Financial Management Work Group
Justification
The FM resources for Claims and Reimbursement Resources are of interest internationally for implementing modern claim processing and connectathon exposure allows implementers to test and contribute to the resources as they are being readied to transition from Draft to DSTU. Since September 2013 FM resources have gained maturity and been tested in many of the connectathons with increased complexity of the test scenarios with each successive connectathon.
Proposed Track Lead
Coordinator: Paul Knapp Skype: paulknapp
Expected participants
- Knapp Consulting - Client and Server supporting most scenarios including the Veteran Institutional Claim to VA Payor Scenario
- US Payers supporting a cross section with many taking either a client or a server role
- CMS supporting Explanation of Benefit (BlueButton)
- Almerys supporting most scenarios from the client and server perspectives
Mappings to FM FHIR Resources
The (draft) mapping below between CMS 1500 paper form and the FHIR Claim and supporting resources may aid those familiar with CMS 1500 but not with the FHIR financial resources to navigate the FHIR resources.
- CMS 1500 to FHIR Claim mapping File:CMS1500-FHIR.xlsx
The (draft) mapping below between UB04 paper form and the FHIR Claim and supporting resources may aid those familiar with UB04 but not with the FHIR financial resources to navigate the FHIR resources.
- UB04 to FHIR Claim mapping File:UB04.xlsx
FHIR Version for the Track
FHIR Version 1.8.0 http://hl7.org/fhir/2017Jan/index.html
Servers
Knapp Consulting Inc.: Server is currently Live
- Request-Response: XML only: http://www.pknapp.com:8081/con14/
- Sending a Claim with priority=deferred will result in the adjudication being deferred - pick up the ClaimResponse with a ProcessRequest.
- Sending a Claim with priority=stat will result in additional information being required - submit a Communication with the additional information then a ProcessRequest to pick up the ClaimResponse.
- FHIR REST: XML only and CapabilityStatement, Claim, ClaimResponse supported: http://www.pknapp.com:8081/con14/FHIR/
Note: Servers should provide a CapabilityStatement resource on their FHIR endpoint in response to a GET for [baseurl]/metadata.
Roles
FHIR Client - Eligibility Submitter
Enable the creation and submission of the Eligibility resource and the receiving or obtaining of an EligibilityResponse.
FHIR Server - Eligibility Processor
Support the receiving and processing of the Eligibility resource and creation of the EligibilityResponse resource.
FHIR Client - Claims Submitter
Enable the creation and submission of the Claim resource and the receiving or obtaining of a ClaimResponse. This may be as a Pre-Authorization, Pre-Determination or a completed Claim for actual adjudication.
FHIR Server - Claims Processor
Support the receiving and processing of the Claim resource as a: Pre-Authorization; Predetermination; or, actual Claim; and creation of the ClaimResponse resource.
FHIR Client - Claims Attachment Submitter
Enable the creation and submission of the Communication resource and the receiving or obtaining of a ProcessResponse. This may be as supporting information for a Pre-Authorization, Pre-Determination or a completed Claim for actual adjudication.
FHIR Server - Claims Attachment Processor
Support the receiving and processing of the Communication resource as supporting information for a Pre-Authorization, Predetermination or actual Claim; and creation of the ProcessResponse resource.
FHIR Server - Claims Attachment Requestor
Support the receiving and processing of the ProcessRequest resource and return a CommunicationRequest resource for a previously received and pended Pre-Authorization, Predetermination or actual Claim.
FHIR Client - ProcessRequest Submitter
Enable the creation and submission of the ProcessRequest resource and the receiving or obtaining of a ProcessResponse. This may be to: request a Claim Reversal, request a deferred response, or a PaymentReconciliation or to obtain the processing status.
FHIR Server - ProcessRequest Processor
Support the receiving and processing of the ProcessRequest resource and creation of the ProcessResponse resource.
FHIR Server - PaymentReconciliation Processor
Support the receiving and processing of the ProcessRequest resource and creation of the PaymentReconciliation resource.
FHIR Server - Explanation of Benefit Processor
Support the receiving and processing of the ProcessRequest resource and creation of the ExplanationOfBenefit resource.
Scenarios
Each of the scenarios shown below may be implemented via FHIR REST or simple HTTP Request-Response exchange of Resources. The expected Track testing will be via HTTP POST Request-Response with the resource, or exchangeable content in the body of the HTTP content. While XML and JSON are both valid for rendering the FHIR resources, XML is preferred for the official testing to ensure as many participants as possible are able to find one or more Clients or Servers to test against. The testing scenarios shown below form the core of the "Financial" test track. There are eight test scenarios:
- Submit an Eligibility, Retrieve/Receive an EligibilityResponse
- Submit a Pre-Authorization (Claim Resource) then an Attachment, Retrieve/Receive a ClaimResponse
- Submit a Claim, Retrieve/Receive a ClaimResponse :via REST (Create), Retrieve a ClaimResponse (Get) :via HTTP and Receive a ClaimResponse
- Submit Veteran Institutional Claim to VA Payor, Receive/Retrieve ClaimResponse
- Retrieve deferred ClaimResponse via ProcessRequest
- Retrieve the processing status (ProcessResponse) via ProcessRequest
- Retrieve a PaymentReconciliation via ProcessRequest
- Retrieve an ExplanationOfBenefit via ProcessRequest
You may select one or more of these testing scenarios - whatever appeals to you most given your particular context. We encourage you to execute these scenarios with varying test data, but the only test executions which can be assured are those using resources based on the data provided here.
Submit an Eligibility, Retrieve/Receive an EligibilityResponse
- Action: The FHIR Client will construct a Eligibility resource. To obtain the EligibilityResponse for the submitted resource via FHIR REST the client with perform a GET on EligibilityResponse with search parameters which may be expected to select the intended response.
- Precondition: None
- Success Criteria: Eligibility processed correctly by the Server (inspect via browser or available UI)
- Bonus point: return plan details in addition to the indication of whether the coverage is in force.
Submit a Pre-Authorization (Claim Resource) then an Attachment, Retrieve/Receive a ClaimResponse
- Action: The FHIR Client will construct a Claim resource indicating Pre-Authorization. The service will respond with a ClaimResponse indicating only receipt not adjudication of the Claim (Pre-Authorization). To obtain the adjudicated ClaimResponse the client must then submit an Attachment (Communication resource) containing any supporting material to which the Server will respond with a ProcessResponse indicating success or failure with errors. Then the client may obtain the adjudicated ClaimResponse via the appropriate protocol. The ClaimResponse will contain an identifier which may be used during claim submission to indicate that the Pre-Authorization has been performed.
- Precondition: None
- Success Criteria: Pre-Authorization and Attachment processed correctly by the Server (inspect via browser or available UI)
- Bonus point: For sending a business-appropriate form of attachment.
Submit a Claim via REST, Retrieve a ClaimResponse
- Action: The FHIR Client will construct a Claim having either already submitted the supporting resources or with the supporting resources provided within the Claim as contained resources. To obtain the ClaimResponse for the submitted Claim the client with perform a GET on ClaimResponse with search parameters which may be expected to select the intended response.
- Precondition: None
- Success Criteria: Claim processed correctly by the Server (inspect via browser or available UI)
- Bonus point: N/A
Submit a Claim via HTTP and Receive a ClaimResponse
- Action: The FHIR Client will construct a Claim with the supporting information provided within the Claim as contained resources. The response to the Claim will be an OperationOutcome if the Claim cannot be understood or a ClaimResponse if it can.
- If the priority=deferred then a ClaimResponse containing only errors or acknowledgement detail will be returned. The ClaimResponse containing adjudication details can be obtained later as the response to a ProcessRequest (action=poll) resource, for example: [base]/ClaimResponse?request.identifier=http://happyvalley.com/claim%7C1500
- Precondition: None
- Success Criteria: Claim processed correctly by the Server (inspect via browser or available UI)
- Bonus point: N/A
Submit Veteran Institutional Claim to VA Payor, Receive/Retrieve ClaimResponse
- Action: The FHIR Client will construct a Claim with the supporting information provided within the Claim as contained resources where the Claim is from an Institutional Provider to a VA Hospital for Emergency Services. The response to the Claim will be an OperationOutcome if the Claim cannot be understood or a ClaimResponse if it can.
- Precondition: None
- Success Criteria: Claim processed correctly by the Server (inspect via browser or available UI)
- Bonus point: for performing a Pre-Authorization prior to the claim
Retrieve deferred ClaimResponse via ProcessRequest
- Action: Submission of a ProcessRequest (action=poll) resource which contains a reference to the previously submitted claim will result in the creation, and perhaps return, of the ClaimResponse containing the adjudicated results of the previously submitted Claim.
- Precondition: None
- Success Criteria: ClaimResponse returned correctly by the Server and parsed and displayed in context by the Client
- Bonus point: N/A
Retrieve the processing status (ProcessResponse) via ProcessRequest
- Action: Submission of a ProcessRequest (action=status) resource which contains a reference to the previously submitted claim will result in the creation and perhaps return of the ProcessResponse containing the processing status of the previously submitted Claim.
- Precondition: None
- Success Criteria: ProcessResponse returned correctly by the Server (inspect via browser or available UI)
- Bonus point: N/A
Retrieve a PaymentReconciliation via ProcessRequest
- Action: Submission of a ProcessRequest (action=poll) resource which contains a reference to the ProcessRequest class of Resources will result in the creation and possible return of the PaymentReconciliation containing the payments for the previously submitted Claims.
- Precondition: None
- Success Criteria: PaymentReconciliation returned correctly by the Server (inspect via browser or available UI)
- Bonus point: N/A
Retrieve an ExplanationOfBenefit via ProcessRequest
- Action: Submission of a ProcessRequest (action=poll) resource which contains a reference to the ExplanationOfBenefit class of Resources and a period and Coverage will result in the creation and possible return of the ExplanationOfBenefit.
- Precondition: None
- Success Criteria: ExplanationOfBenefit returned correctly by the Server (inspect via browser or available UI)
- Bonus point: N/A
Sample Data
Claims
| Field | Patient #1 Claim | Patient #2 Claim |
| Claim Number | 1500 | 1501 |
| Processing Priority | Normal | Normal |
| Claim Type | Oral Health | Oral Health |
| Name | John M. Smith (Usual) | Judy F. Robinson (Usual) |
| Gender | M | F |
| Birthdate | 1973-04-14 | 1993-06-24 |
| Exceptions | Full-time student (Code 1) at Rozdale University | |
| Address | 1234 Any Street
Menlo Park, California 90123 |
1 Landingpad Lane
Loma Linda, California 90310 |
| Dentist | Dr. Darryl Dentist (# 904563)
Happy Valley Clinic (# 1535) |
Dr. Phil Amolar (# 678543)
Happy Valley Clinic (# 1535) |
| Referral | Practitioner (# 720415)
Reason: Rampant decay (Code 7) |
|
| Insurance | The Benefit Company (BINN# 654123)
Certificate: A7G345, Plan (Policy): 123YHT56 SubPlan: 35 Dependent: 01 Relationship: Self Policy: Dental annual Individual Maximum of $2500, Basic Services at 80%, Major at 50%, no Orthodontic coverage |
Health Management Corp (BINN# 564378)
Certificate: RF98765 Plan (Policy): GALACTIC Dependent: 04 Relationship: Child Frank Robinson born 1953-05-14 Policy: Dental annual Individual Maximum of $2500, Basic Services at 100%, Major at 80%, lifetime individual Orthodontic coverage $6000 Vision: $200 per year, Pharmacy: 20% co-pay, $3500 individual annual maximum. |
| Service Code, Fee, Tooth Surface, Lab#1 Code, Lab#1 Fee, Lab#2 Code, Lab#2 Fee | ||
| Service #1 | 1102, $65.00 | 1101, $55.00 |
| Service #2 | 21211, $105.00, 21, L | 2102, $730.00 |
| Service #3 | 27211, $900.00, 22, , 99111, $250.00 | 21211, $105, 21, L |
| Service #4 | 21212, $200.00, 42, DI | |
| Service #5 | 11101, $135.00 | |
Services
| Code | Description | Fee |
| 1101 | Exam, comp, primary | 55.00 |
| 1102 | Exam, comp, mixed | 60.00 |
| 1103 | Exam, comp, permanent | 65.00 |
| 1201 | Exam, comp, primary | 45.00 |
| 1205 | Exam, emergency | 75.00 |
| 2101 | Radiograph, series (12) | 530.00 |
| 2102 | Radiograph, series (16) | 730.00 |
| 2141 | Radiograph, bytewing | 530.00 |
| 2601 | Radiograph, panoramic | 420.00 |
| 11101 | Polishing, 1 unit | 35.00 |
| 11102 | Polishing, 2 unit | 70.00 |
| 11103 | Polishing, 3 unit | 105.00 |
| 11104 | Polishing, 4 unit | 135.00 |
| 21211 | Amalgam, 1 surface | 105.00 |
| 21212 | Amalgam, 2 surface | 200.00 |
| 27211 | Crown, PFM | 900.00 |
| 99111 | Lab, commercial | 250.00 |
| 99333 | Lab, in office | 200.00 |
| 99555 | Lab, Expense | 0.00 |
