Technology
Binding and function definition issues
Current CTS approach
The current CTS specification defines the information model using UML and defines the API using the OMG Interface Definition Language (IDL). A sample IDL declaration follows:
typedef string OID; typedef OID CodeSystemId; typedef string ConceptCode; exception UnexpectedError { string possible_cause; }; exception UnknownCodeSystem { CodeSystemId codeSystem_id; }; struct ConceptId { CodeSystemId codeSystem_id; ConceptCode concept_code; }; boolean isConceptIdValid( in ConceptId concept_id, in boolean activeConceptsOnly ) raises (UnknownCodeSystem, UnexpectedError);
IDL was chosen because there is a definitive, standard mapping defined between IDL and most programming languages. There are two problems, however. The first is that, while IDL is supposedly technology neutral, the language mappings carry some CORBA related artifacts. The ConceptID declaration above compiles to:
public final class ConceptId implements org.omg.CORBA.portable.IDLEntity { public String codeSystem_id = null; public String concept_code = null; public ConceptId () { } // ctor public ConceptId (String _codeSystem_id, String _concept_code) { codeSystem_id = _codeSystem_id; concept_code = _concept_code; } // ctor } // class ConceptId
While the IDLEntity abstract You will note that this standardized mapping is not an interface specification, but rather a concrete class. This It also creates the files:
- ConceptIdHelper.java
- ConceptIdHolder.Java
Both of which contain a lot of CORBA specific information.
The UnexpectedError exception declaration causes a lot of problems. It generates the Java:
public final class UnexpectedError extends org.omg.CORBA.UserException { public String possible_cause = null; public UnexpectedError () { super(UnexpectedErrorHelper.id()); } // ctor public UnexpectedError (String _possible_cause) { super(UnexpectedErrorHelper.id()); possible_cause = _possible_cause; } // ctor public UnexpectedError (String $reason, String _possible_cause) { super(UnexpectedErrorHelper.id() + " " + $reason); possible_cause = _possible_cause; } // ctor } // class UnexpectedError
Which contains references to a CORBA specific UserException as well as UnexpectedErrorHelper references. Both of these are CORBA specific.