FHIR Infrastructure Minutes CC 20181008

FHIR Infrastructure Conference Call 3:00PM Eastern Time (Date above)

Return to FHIR Infrastructure Minutes

Agenda

• Approve Minutes Prior Meeting on mm/dd
• Block vote
• Tracker items

Attendees

• Lloyd McKenzie (Chair)
• Rick Geimer (Scribe)
• Bryn Rhodes
• Grahame Grieve
• Richard Ettema
• Sean McIlvenna
• Yunwei Wang
• John Moehrke
• Eric Haas
• Pegeen Ladeau

Minutes approval

• Motion to approve Minutes Prior Meeting on mm/dd

Block Vote

• Block vote (notice went out Tuesday Oct 2)
  • Approval motion: Rick Geimer/Bryn Rhodes: 7-0-0
  • Some further discussion about 18233, make it clear that the resolution applies to R5, not R4

Tracker Items

• Tracker 17777: ImplementationGuide.fhirVersion should be mandatory
  • Discussed whether there are any use cases for IGs that don't specify a version. Perhaps IGs don't contain profiles, etc. (i.e. just prose that could apply to any version of FHIR), or IGs that refer to other IGs.
  • Lloyd created a new tracker to note that the IG resource is used for more than just FHIR (19338)
  • Agreed to make fhirVersion 1..*.
  • Persuasive
  • Motion: Rick Geimer/Richard Ettema: 7-0-0
• Tracker 19338: ImplementationGuide is used for more than just FHIR
  • Agreed to change the definition of the IG resource
  • Persuasive
  • Motion: Grahame Grieve/Bryn Rhodes: 7-0-0
• Tracker 18356: Can't guarantee narrative will include modifiers unless they're on the root. - N-Infra #44
  • Agreed that the narrative of a resource needs to contain modifier extension content if present.
  • Persuasive with Mod
  • Motion: Rick Geimer/Grahame Grieve: 7-0-1
• Tracker 18363: Drop requirement to declare in CapabilityStatement - N-Infra #51
  • The text in question should have been removed when task 14647 was applied, since there is no longer a formal way of meeting the requirement. Will remove as a technical correction.
  • Persuasive
  • Motion: Rick Geimer/Sean McIlvenna: 8-0-0
• Tracker 18814: Why are some FHIRPatch parameters uppercase and others lowercase
  • Agreed to make all parameter names lower-case
  • Persuasive
  • Motion: Grahame Grieve/Yunwei Wang: 9-0-0
• Tracker 18815: FHIRPatch is missing rules around what's allowed/not
  • Agreed to table this for now, work on the test cases, and come back with proposals later.
• Tracker 19247: profile-types.xml: wrong 'base' elements
  • ElementDefinition.base clearly states the rules, the behavior noted by the balloter is by design.
  • Not Persuasive
  • Motion: Grahame Grieve/Yunwei Wang: 8-0-1
• Tracker 16528: safety page should reference the security page and not duplicate security/privacy checklist items
  • Needs more input, tabled for now will come back to it
• Tracker 17278: add element to indicate the source file
  • Currently this is done in ig.json, but that file is going away
  • Agreed to defer this discussion to FHIR R5
  • Consider for Future Use
  • Motion: Rick Geimer/Sean McIlvenna: 9-0-0
• Tracker 17358: Compartment definition of Practitioner should explicitely include Resources linked indirectly via PractitionerRole
  • Agreed to defer to R5
  • Consider for Future Use
  • Motion: Grahame Grieve, Rick Geimer: 7-0-0
• Tracker 17768: Explain how to use List.mode = changes
  • Agreed to move the discussion to Zulip for now and revisit later
• Tracker 17802: Narrative in contained resource
  • We agreed to loosen the restriction against contained resources having narrative in 13870.
  • Will fix as a technical correction, since text in question was missed when 13870 was applied.
  • Persuasive
  • Motion: Rick Geimer/Richard Ettema: 7-0-0
• Tracker 17824: ordinal value extensions
  • Agreed to delete the iso and questionnaire specific ones and define a general ordinalValue extension
  • Persuasive
  • Motion: Grahame Grieve/Rick Geimer: 6-1-0
• Tracker 18195: Consider a generic "annotation" extension on Element
  • Agreed to replace the current context specific extensions with a generic one.
  • Persuasive
  • Motion: Rick Geimer/Richard Ettema: 7-0-0
• Tracker 18989: Subscription should not rely on tag
  • Agreed to remove the tag. Add narrative explaining the use of Communication and/or AuditEvent to track subscription notifications.
  • Persuasive with Mod
  • Motion: Grahame Grieve/Rick Geimer: 7-0-0
• Tracker 18991: Subscription.channel.payload and SMS or Email
  • Agreed to change the datatype of payload to code with a binding to MIME type
  • Clarified the note to make it clear that payload should be omitted, not set to "false"
  • Persuasive with Mod
  • Motion: Rick Geimer/Yunwei Wang: 7-0-0
• Tracker 18992: Subscription to SMS or Email and default text
  • Agreed to add as an extension and test at Connectathon, and to describe the use of text/plain mime type for SMS and message.
  • Persuasive with Mod
  • Motion: Rick Geimer/Yunwei Wan: 7-0-0