This wiki has undergone a migration to Confluence found Here

Difference between revisions of "Data Types R2 issues"

From HL7Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 16: Line 16:
 
| '''ID''' || '''Topic''' || '''Type''' || '''Category''' || '''Status''' || '''Ranking'''
 
| '''ID''' || '''Topic''' || '''Type''' || '''Category''' || '''Status''' || '''Ranking'''
 
|-
 
|-
|  1 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 1|Add CD.group]] || CD || Abstract || approved
+
|  1 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 1|Add CD.group]] || CD || Abstract || approved || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
|  2 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 2|Add DRVQ mixin for Quantity]] || QTY || Abstract || ?
+
|  2 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 2|Add DRVQ mixin for Quantity]] || QTY || Abstract || ? || Very Significant
 
|-
 
|-
|  3 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 3|Add ED.translation]] || ED || Abstract || ?
+
|  3 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 3|Add ED.translation]] || ED || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
|  4 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 4|Add GTS.code]] || GTS || Abstract || ?
+
|  4 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 4|Add GTS.code]] || GTS || Abstract || ? || Very Significant
 
|-
 
|-
|  5 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 5|Add HIST.controlActIdRef]] || HIST || Abstract || ?
+
|  5 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 5|Add HIST.controlActIdRef]] || HIST || Abstract || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
|  6 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 6|Add PIVL.frequency]] || PIVL || Abstract || ?
+
|  6 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 6|Add PIVL.frequency]] || PIVL || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
|  7 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 7|Add PLIST as LIST ancestor]] || LIST || Abstract || ?
+
|  7 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 7|Add PLIST as LIST ancestor]] || LIST || Abstract || ? || Signficant
 
|-
 
|-
|  8 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 8|Add STT datatype]] || ST || Abstract || ?
+
|  8 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 8|Add STT datatype]] || ST || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
|  9 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 9|Clarify BAG-SET-LIST relationship]] || COLL || Abstract || ?
+
|  9 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 9|Clarify BAG-SET-LIST relationship]] || COLL || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 10 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 10|Create URG constraint on UVP]] || UVP || Abstract || ?
+
| 10 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 10|Create URG constraint on UVP]] || UVP || Abstract || ? || Very Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 11 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 11|Derive ADXP and ENXP from SC]] || AD / EN || Abstract || ?
+
| 11 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 11|Derive ADXP and ENXP from SC]] || AD / EN || Abstract || ? || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 12 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 12|Drop identity-equality distinction]] || ANY || Abstract || ?
+
| 12 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 12|Drop identity-equality distinction]] || ANY || Abstract || ? || Very Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 13 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 13|Generalize originalText]] || ANY || Abstract || ?
+
| 13 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 13|Generalize originalText]] || ANY || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 14 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 14|Relax Unit Constraint on PQ]] || PQ || Abstract || ?
+
| 14 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 14|Relax Unit Constraint on PQ]] || PQ || Abstract || ? || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
 
| 15 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 15|XML Representation of Collection Type and NullFlavor]] || COLL || XML || ?
 
| 15 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 15|XML Representation of Collection Type and NullFlavor]] || COLL || XML || ?
 
|-
 
|-
| 16 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 16|XML Representation of SLIST]] || SLIST || XML || ?
+
| 16 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 16|XML Representation of SLIST]] || SLIST || XML || ? || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 17 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 17|Add title or filename to ED]] || ED || Abstract || ?
+
| 17 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 17|Add title or filename to ED]] || ED || Abstract || ? || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 18 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 18|GTS.translation]] || GTS || Abstract || ?
+
| 18 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 18|GTS.translation]] || GTS || Abstract || ? || ?
 
|-
 
|-
| 19 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 19|Add Bounded PIVL (BPVL)]] || PIVL || Abstract || ?
+
| 19 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 19|Add Bounded PIVL (BPVL)]] || PIVL || Abstract || ? || ?
 
|-
 
|-
| 20 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 20|Cardinality of IVL<T>]] || IVL || Abstract || ?
+
| 20 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 20|Cardinality of IVL<T>]] || IVL || Abstract || ? || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 21 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 21|New mime types for CDA]] || ED || Abstract || Approved
+
| 21 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 21|New mime types for CDA]] || ED || Abstract || Approved || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 22 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 22|New CD definitions]] || CD || Abstract || ?
+
| 22 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 22|New CD definitions]] || CD || Abstract || ? || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 23 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 23|Rename Snomed RT]] || Vocab || Abstract || Proposal
+
| 23 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 23|Rename Snomed RT]] || Vocab || Abstract || Proposal || Editorial
 
|-
 
|-
| 24 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 24|vocab domain issues]] || Vocab || Abstract || Discussion
+
| 24 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 24|vocab domain issues]] || Vocab || Abstract || Discussion || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 25 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 25|II.reference]] || II || Abstract || ?
+
| 25 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 25|II.reference]] || II || Abstract || ? || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 26 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 26|Special CDA Type]] || ED || Abstract || ?
+
| 26 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 26|Special CDA Type]] || ED || Abstract || ? || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 27 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 27|EIVL<TS> Issues]] || EIVL || Abstract || ?
+
| 27 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 27|EIVL<TS> Issues]] || EIVL || Abstract || ? Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 28 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 28|GTS literal]] || GTS || XML|| ?
+
| 28 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 28|GTS literal]] || GTS || XML || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 29 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 29|PPD<T> issues]] || PPD || Abstract || ?
+
| 29 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 29|PPD<T> issues]] || PPD || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 30 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 30|Add Bag.literal]] || BAG || Abstract || Proposal
+
| 30 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 30|Add Bag.literal]] || BAG || Abstract || Proposal || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 31 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 31|Null constraints]] || all || Abstract || Approved
+
| 31 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 31|Null constraints]] || all || Abstract || Approved || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 32 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 32|cd.code rules]] || CD || Abstract || Approved
+
| 32 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 32|cd.code rules]] || CD || Abstract || Approved || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 33 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 33|language binding in XML]] || ED || XML|| ?
+
| 33 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 33|language binding in XML]] || ED || XML|| ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 34 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 34|Removed Properties]] || all || Abstract || ?
+
| 34 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 34|Removed Properties]] || all || XML || ? || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 35 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 35|UID Case sensitivity]] || II || Abstract || ?
+
| 35 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 35|UID Case sensitivity]] || II || Abstract || ? || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 36 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 36|URI issue]] || URL || Abstract || ?
+
| 36 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 36|URI issue]] || URL || Abstract || ? || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 37 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 37|Fax issue]] || URL || Abstract || Approved
+
| 37 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 37|Fax issue]] || URL || Abstract || Approved || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 38 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 38|Type Substitution]] || all || Abstract || ?
+
| 38 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 38|Type Substitution]] || all || Abstract ||   ? || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 39 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 39|DEL null content issue]] || ADXP || Abstract || ?
+
| 39 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 39|DEL null content issue]] || ADXP || Abstract || ? || Editorial
 
|-
 
|-
| 40 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 40|ProbabilityDistributionType]] || vocab || Abstract || Abandoned
+
| 40 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 40|ProbabilityDistributionType]] || vocab || Abstract || Abandoned || Nothing
 
|-
 
|-
| 41 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 41|decimal significance]] || REAL || Abstract || Abandoned
+
| 41 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 41|decimal significance]] || REAL || Abstract || Abandoned || Nothing
 
|-
 
|-
| 42 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 42|RTO xsi:type]] || RTO || XML || ?
+
| 42 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 42|RTO xsi:type]] || RTO || XML || ? || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 43 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 43|order of HIST and HXIT]] || narrative || Abstract || ?
+
| 43 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 43|order of HIST and HXIT]] || narrative || Abstract || ? || Editorial
 
|-
 
|-
| 44 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 44|PIVL issues]] || PIVL || Abstract || ?
+
| 44 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 44|PIVL issues]] || PIVL || Abstract || ? || Signficant
 
|-
 
|-
| 45 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 45|comp name]] || SET || Abstract || ?
+
| 45 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 45|comp name]] || SET || Abstract || ? || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 46 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 46|PPD QTY.diff issues]] || PPD || Abstract || ?
+
| 46 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 46|PPD QTY.diff issues]] || PPD || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 47 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 47|xml attributes]] || all || XML || Proposal
+
| 47 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 47|xml attributes]] || all || XML || Proposal || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 48 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 48|CS element form]] || CS || XML|| Approved
+
| 48 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 48|CS element form]] || CS || XML|| Approved || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 49 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 49|PQR originalText]] || PQR || Abstract || ?
+
| 49 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 49|PQR originalText]] || PQR || Abstract || ? || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 50 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 50|CD.original text demotion]] || CD || Abstract || ?
+
| 50 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 50|CD.original text demotion]] || CD || Abstract || ? || Editorial
 
|-
 
|-
| 51 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 51|Support for Likert scales]] || CO || Abstract || Discussion
+
| 51 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 51|Support for Likert scales]] || CO || Abstract || Discussion || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 52 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 52|Missing demotions]] || all || Abstract || ?
+
| 52 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 52|Missing demotions]] || all || Abstract || ? || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 53 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 53|IVL attribute names]] || IVL || Abstract || ?
+
| 53 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 53|IVL attribute names]] || IVL || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 54 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 54|CE definition error]] || CE || Abstract || Proposal
+
| 54 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 54|CE definition error]] || CE || Abstract || Proposal || Editorial
 
|-
 
|-
| 55 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 55|Update mode & Audit Trail]] || all || Abstract || Clarification
+
| 55 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 55|Update mode & Audit Trail]] || all || Abstract || Clarification || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 56 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 56|SRCH semantics]] || EN || Abstract || ?
+
| 56 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 56|SRCH semantics]] || EN || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 57 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 57|II.useCode]] || II || Abstract || Discussion
+
| 57 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 57|II.useCode]] || II || Abstract || Discussion || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 58 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 58|GTS Frequency Code]] || GTS || Abstract || ?
+
| 58 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 58|GTS Frequency Code]] || GTS || Abstract || ? || Signficant
 
|-
 
|-
| 59 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 59|Unknown home phone number]] || TEL || Abstract || Discussion
+
| 59 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 59|Unknown home phone number]] || TEL || Abstract || Discussion || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 60 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 60|Data Type Flavors]] || all || Abstract || ?
+
| 60 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 60|Data Type Flavors]] || all || Abstract || ? || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 61 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 61|PHON semantics]] || EN || Abstract || ?
+
| 61 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 61|PHON semantics]] || EN || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 62 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 62|Add AD.use PHON+SRCH]] || AD || Abstract || ?
+
| 62 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 62|Add AD.use PHON+SRCH]] || AD || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 63 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 63|IVL narrative issue]] || IVL || Abstract || Proposal
+
| 63 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 63|IVL narrative issue]] || IVL || Abstract || Proposal || Editorial
 
|-
 
|-
| 64 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 64|IVL center issue]] || IVL || Abstract || ?
+
| 64 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 64|IVL center issue]] || IVL || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 65 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 65|IVL center/width and low/high issue]] || IVL || Abstract || ?
+
| 65 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 65|IVL center/width and low/high issue]] || IVL || Abstract || ? || Editorial
 
|-
 
|-
| 66 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 66|conformance to preferred OID root]] || II,C* || Abstract || ?
+
| 66 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 66|conformance to preferred OID root]] || II,C* || Abstract || ? || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 67 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 67|Clarification of Promotion and Demotion]] || All || Abstract || ?
+
| 67 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 67|Clarification of Promotion and Demotion]] || All || Abstract || ? || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 68 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 68|Text Telephone Number]] || TEL || Proposal || ?
+
| 68 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 68|Text Telephone Number]] || TEL || Proposal || ? || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 69 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 69|CD.translation changes]] || CD || Abstract || Approved
+
| 69 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 69|CD.translation changes]] || CD || Abstract || Approved || Catastrophe
 
|-
 
|-
| 70 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 70|PQR Visibility]] || PQR || Abstract || Proposed
+
| 70 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 70|PQR Visibility]] || PQR || Abstract || Proposed || Trivial
 
|-
 
|-
| 71 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 71|LanguageCommunication DataType]] || -- || Abstract || Proposed
+
| 71 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 71|LanguageCommunication DataType]] || -- || Abstract || Rejected || Nothing
 
|-
 
|-
| 72 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 72|DATAVALUE.specialisationType]] || -- || Abstract || Proposed
+
| 72 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 72|DATAVALUE.specialisationType]] || -- || Abstract || Proposed || Significant
 
|-
 
|-
| 73 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 73|CD.valueSet]] || -- || Abstract || Proposed
+
| 73 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 73|CD.valueSet]] || -- || Abstract || Proposed || Normal
 
|-
 
|-
| 74 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 74|Lazy developer framework]] || -- || Abstract || Proposed
+
| 74 || [[Datatypes R2 Issue 74|Unencoded NullFlavor]] || -- || Abstract || Proposed || Trivial
 
|-}
 
|-}

Revision as of 22:00, 11 January 2007

This is the register of known abstract data types issues for release 2. R2 XML ITS datatypes has been merged into this list for XML ITS data type issues.

R2 Datatypes Taskforce

Status list:

  •  ? : to be clarified
  • clarification: still gathering information
  • discussion: clarification is complete. discussion is progressing
  • proposal: has been resolved out of committee, waiting for formal resolution in committee
  • approved: INM has approved the proposed resolution, waiting for the editor to apply to the document
  • complete: editing is complete
  • abandoned: proposal has been abandoned
ID Topic Type Category Status Ranking
1 Add CD.group CD Abstract approved Significant
2 Add DRVQ mixin for Quantity QTY Abstract ? Very Significant
3 Add ED.translation ED Abstract ? Significant
4 Add GTS.code GTS Abstract ? Very Significant
5 Add HIST.controlActIdRef HIST Abstract Trivial
6 Add PIVL.frequency PIVL Abstract ? Significant
7 Add PLIST as LIST ancestor LIST Abstract ? Signficant
8 Add STT datatype ST Abstract ? Significant
9 Clarify BAG-SET-LIST relationship COLL Abstract ? Significant
10 Create URG constraint on UVP UVP Abstract ? Very Significant
11 Derive ADXP and ENXP from SC AD / EN Abstract ? Trivial
12 Drop identity-equality distinction ANY Abstract ? Very Significant
13 Generalize originalText ANY Abstract ? Significant
14 Relax Unit Constraint on PQ PQ Abstract ? Normal
15 XML Representation of Collection Type and NullFlavor COLL XML ?
16 XML Representation of SLIST SLIST XML ? Normal
17 Add title or filename to ED ED Abstract ? Trivial
18 GTS.translation GTS Abstract ? ?
19 Add Bounded PIVL (BPVL) PIVL Abstract ? ?
20 Cardinality of IVL<T> IVL Abstract ? Trivial
21 New mime types for CDA ED Abstract Approved Trivial
22 New CD definitions CD Abstract ? Trivial
23 Rename Snomed RT Vocab Abstract Proposal Editorial
24 vocab domain issues Vocab Abstract Discussion Trivial
25 II.reference II Abstract ? Normal
26 Special CDA Type ED Abstract ? Trivial
27 EIVL<TS> Issues EIVL Abstract ? Significant
28 GTS literal GTS XML ? Significant
29 PPD<T> issues PPD Abstract ? Significant
30 Add Bag.literal BAG Abstract Proposal Trivial
31 Null constraints all Abstract Approved Significant
32 cd.code rules CD Abstract Approved Normal
33 language binding in XML ED XML ? Significant
34 Removed Properties all XML ? Normal
35 UID Case sensitivity II Abstract ? Trivial
36 URI issue URL Abstract ? Trivial
37 Fax issue URL Abstract Approved Trivial
38 Type Substitution all Abstract ? Normal
39 DEL null content issue ADXP Abstract ? Editorial
40 ProbabilityDistributionType vocab Abstract Abandoned Nothing
41 decimal significance REAL Abstract Abandoned Nothing
42 RTO xsi:type RTO XML ? Normal
43 order of HIST and HXIT narrative Abstract ? Editorial
44 PIVL issues PIVL Abstract ? Signficant
45 comp name SET Abstract ? Trivial
46 PPD QTY.diff issues PPD Abstract ? Significant
47 xml attributes all XML Proposal Normal
48 CS element form CS XML Approved Trivial
49 PQR originalText PQR Abstract ? Normal
50 CD.original text demotion CD Abstract ? Editorial
51 Support for Likert scales CO Abstract Discussion Normal
52 Missing demotions all Abstract ? Trivial
53 IVL attribute names IVL Abstract ? Significant
54 CE definition error CE Abstract Proposal Editorial
55 Update mode & Audit Trail all Abstract Clarification Normal
56 SRCH semantics EN Abstract ? Significant
57 II.useCode II Abstract Discussion Significant
58 GTS Frequency Code GTS Abstract ? Signficant
59 Unknown home phone number TEL Abstract Discussion Significant
60 Data Type Flavors all Abstract ? Normal
61 PHON semantics EN Abstract ? Significant
62 Add AD.use PHON+SRCH AD Abstract ? Significant
63 IVL narrative issue IVL Abstract Proposal Editorial
64 IVL center issue IVL Abstract ? Significant
65 IVL center/width and low/high issue IVL Abstract ? Editorial
66 conformance to preferred OID root II,C* Abstract ? Significant
67 Clarification of Promotion and Demotion All Abstract ? Normal
68 Text Telephone Number TEL Proposal ? Normal
69 CD.translation changes CD Abstract Approved Catastrophe
70 PQR Visibility PQR Abstract Proposed Trivial
71 LanguageCommunication DataType -- Abstract Rejected Nothing
72 DATAVALUE.specialisationType -- Abstract Proposed Significant
73 CD.valueSet -- Abstract Proposed Normal
74 Unencoded NullFlavor -- Abstract Proposed Trivial