Category:MnM Hot Topics

MnM Hot Topics are methodology-related discussions which require guidance or resolution from the Modeling and Methodology technical committee. Resolution of methodology issues is one of the primary deliverables of MnM.

Process

A hot topic may be raised by anyone.

To raise a hot topic:

1. Create a wiki page (or using an existing wiki page on which the issue is already being discussed)
2. Ensure the wiki page reflects the core of the issue, rationale as to why the issue needs to be resolved, and if possible, a suggested resolution
3. Flag it as a hot topic by inserting \{\{MnM Open Hot Topic\}\} at the end of the text of the wiki discussion
4. Send an e-mail to the MnM list with the subject line "Hot Topic: <some descriptive label>" and include a summary of the issue along with a link to the Wiki page

Resolution process:

• Hot topics will be reviewed on a regular basis at both MnM conference calls (MnM Schedule) and working group meetings.
• The hot topics for discussion at a given conference call or meeting will be governed by several considerations
  • Whether the wiki discussion seems to be close to reconcilliation
  • Whether there has been progress on the list servers and/or wiki since the issue was last discussed
  • Whether the principle participants in the discussion are available to discuss the topic
• Hot topics will generally be scheduled for discussion either at the end of the MnM conference call the week preceding a hot topics discussion, or for WGMs, the Sunday afternoon prior to the start of the WGM.
• Results of MnM discussions will be posted to the WGM
• Hot topics are resolved by motion and context-sensitive (key interested stake-holders must be respresentived) quorum vote of the MnM meeting where the issue is discussed
  • Depending on the level of impact and controversy around a topic, the resolution may be brought forward to Thursday Night round-table for confirmation by the full set of MnM facilitators
• A hot topic may be re-opened by quorum vote at an MnM hot topics call in circumstances where new information not previously considered in the prior resolution of the issue is brought forward.
• Upon resolution, a hot topic will be either categorized as
  • resolved - if there are further outstanding actions to be taken by MnM or other committees, or
  • closed - if all action items have been completed
• MnM will monitor the action items for hot topics categorized as resolved with a view to seeing them move to closed as soon as feasible.

Hot Topics Sub-Lists

• Open
• Resolved
• Closed

• Intentionality of Act and the Future of Observations - A discussion on how Acts should be seen in the standard.
• A discussion of identifier types, how they should be used and RIM proposals to enable same.
• Interaction Versioning
• Semantic Backward Compatibility
• Context Conduction - Discussion of issues with current approach
• Implementation of updateMode
• Add interactionId to ControlAct
• Use of UUIDs in II.extension
• Definition of act.text
• RIM Cardinality issues
• Constraints on infrastructureRoot attributes
• Definition of Realm
• Query recursion
• When to unroll a class