FHIR Breaking changes between DSTU 2 ballot and final

Content on this page has been migrated to Confluence here: https://confluence.hl7.org/display/FHIR/DSTU2+Ballot+to+Final+breaking+changes

A list of all the changes made to DSTU 2 after DSTU 2 ballot that were labelled 'non-compatible':

2865 Clarify the functionality of GET [base]/[compartment]/[id]/?
3011 CarePlan.activity.note needs further explanation
3249 Profile.date should have a more meaningful name
3361 Message endpoints should be associated with the event protocol
3627 Value set - define/concept[0..*] needs additional wording
3633 Change .expansion.timestamp datatype to dateTime
3855 search param naming is inconsistent
4003 Resource Encounter Content
5165 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #32
5444 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #337
5457 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #396
5561 Composition.type and Composition.class defintions should be improved according to the improvements made to DocumentReference.
5678 List.flag vocabulary
5680 order of common resource elements not consistent
5695 Medication should be required in MedicationStatement
5698 Appointment.order can't work at present
5701 MedicationStattement.wasNotGiven should notTaken
5760 $translate does not suport dependsOn
5895 is Order.authority part of 80%?
5940 allow MedicationStatement.quantity to be either a quantity or range
5947 Relationship between child concepts and subsumption needs clarification
5951 Timing doesn't allow an overall duration
5961 Change DiagnosticReport.name to .code
5997 Rename Provenance.agent.reference[x]
5998 ImagingStudy should use CodeableConcept, not Coding
6029 More precise definitions of some concept map equivalence codes
6040 StructureDefinition/ElementDefinition overlaps
6067 Split Supply into SupplyRequest and SupplyDispense
6079 StructureDefinition needs a target type property
6089 Telecom doesn't allow for alternate systems
6094 change 'subject' search parameter
6104 Tooling should enforce coding capitalization consistency
6118 409 status code
6122 Support non-atomic transactions/batches in RESTful API
6129 Change the Procedure attribute type to code
6130 Change attribute name for Quantiy.code, Quantity.units, Quantity.system
6171 Flag.patient should be [0..1]
6215 roll up CarePlan.activity.detail.note into CarePlan.activity.notes
6216 Goal.concern reference list
6242 ImagingStudy.clinicalInformation shoiuld choice of string or Condition resource and possbile code?
6253 body site should be a datatype - but used consisitantly throughout the standrard.
6269 AuditEvent needs a Participant userId type code to explain how to understand the value in userId (e.g. Patient ID in CX form)
6304 Abstract for Action Who/What/When/Where/Why across Resources
6309 Allow reference to medication to be either a code or a Medication Resource Reference
6310 Add MedicationStatementStatus for planned future medications
6311 Need better explanation of DataElement Slicing
6331 Clarify whether conditional operations in a transaction include [base]
6336 "Executing an Operation Asynchronously" should be removed
6343 The /Mailbox endpoint is no longer needed, given FHIR's "operations" framework
6637 Add modifier to string parameters to indicate what kind of partial match is required
6793 2015May sdc #10 - Use stringency, not specificity
6868 2015May sdc #85 - Why unassessible?
6913 2015May sdc #136 - How are "append" relationships handled?
6922 2015May sdc #145 - Request that max count be unbounded
6944 2015May core #9 - Make reason 0..*
7018 2015May core #83 - Response: Specifying paging support would be a welcome addition and would further increase interoperability.
7123 2015May core #182 - What's difference between Procedure.category and type?
7127 2015May core #186 - Procedure.relatedItem is too complicated - make it extension
7154 2015May core #213 - Explain reliability
7347 2015May core #537 - Schedule.actor has resource type of "Any"
7366 2015May core #556 - Why not avoid this problem by requiring contained resources to explicitly state their subject? Why allow this degree of optionality?
7404 2015May core #594 - Is narrative the same for documents vs. other mechanisms?
7428 2015May core #716 - Using of Snomed CT
7431 2015May core #719 - AuditEvent source identifier
7454 2015May core #742 - Can only one be declared as primary? Can none?
7457 2015May core #745 - should allow for multiple Coding returned, with at most one marked as primary
7460 2015May core #748 - Allow non-resources to be focus of Provenance
7483 2015May core #778 - consistency of FamilyMemberHistory's condition with the Condition resource
7511 2015May core #802 - Make names consistent between Procedure and Encounter
7515 2015May core #806 - rename MedicationStatement.dosage.schedule to MedicationStatement.dosage.timing
7517 2015May core #808 - Bring back Observation.component
7518 2015May core #809 - Immunization.protocol cardinality
7521 2015May core #812 - ICD-9 system URLs
7525 2015May core #816 - MedicationStatement.status definitions
7530 2015May core #821 - remove ElementDefinition.binding.name
7541 2015May core #832 - Simply conditional create header
7543 2015May core #834 - include transitiveness
7545 2015May core #836 - transaction and base interaction
7550 2015May core #841 - AllergyIntolerance negation
7581 2015May core #872 - How do we specify an "active" or "resolved" problem?
7583 2015May core #874 - We need a status to specify whether the med is "active" vs. "discontinued" meds?
7585 2015May core #876 - GMDN FDA guidance: http://www.fda.gov/downloads/MedicalDevices/DeviceRegulationandGuidance/GuidanceDocuments/UCM369248.pdf
7587 2015May core #878 - body site is overly complicated (Observation)
7613 2015May core #904 - How is encounter diagnosis handled?
7617 2015May core #908 - Is Working vs. Confirmed in the 80%?
7621 2015May core #912 - Aren't these all similar items? Shouldn't they all be called target or detail?
7622 2015May core #913 - Allow structures in notes, make 0..*
7629 2015May core #920 - Suggest renaming to 'bodySite' or 'affectedSite'
7631 2015May core #922 - Procedure.device -> targetDevice
7633 2015May core #924 - Procedure has evolved since ProcedureRequest was drafted. Suggest re-aligning the two resources to account for changes in one, relevant to the other.
7636 2015May core #927 - Should 'applies' be renamed to 'physiologicallyRelevant[x]'. While short names are good, they must also be more descriptive.
7639 2015May core #930 - What's difference between has component and has member?
7651 2015May core #942 - Need to categroize re-admissions
7655 2015May core #946 - Recommend renaming this to referralRequestFulfilled
7693 2015May core #984 - Who or what should sign a bundle and how is this used? RBAC? What happens if a transaction is not signed?
7702 2015May core #993 - Can signature be captured by blob?
7751 2015May core #1072 - Replace Provenance extension
7753 2015May core #1074 - The use of the DocumentReference.confidentiality element is not conformant with the HCS requirements on Security Labels. This needs to be fixed.
7760 2015May core #1081 - Add dependsOn element as an input Parameter with parts, and product as an output Parameter with parts.
7761 2015May core #1082 - Allow ConceptMap/$translate to have multiple outcomes
7859 2015May core #1179 - Condition.dateAsserted definition clarification
7864 2015May core #1184 - Condition.clinicalStatus should not convey both record status (in error) and confirmation Status (working, confirmed, refuted)
7867 2015May core #1187 - Add a record status to communicate active, in error, cancelled
7894 2015May core #1214 - Rename AllergyIntolerance.event
7897 2015May core #1217 - Should immunization be searchable by subject since there is no subject parameter (if yes, should AllergyIntollerance be searchable by subject?)
7906 2015May core #1226 - Encounter condition relationship
7913 2015May core #1233 - MedicationStatement.status clarification
7924 2015May core #1244 - Clarify content-location for Reads without Versioning support
7954 2015May core #1274 - Remove _language query parameter support
7957 2015May core #1277 - Alternative suggestion for Date Ranges
7961 2015May core #1281 - Modify Name of Substance.Type Property
8002 2015May core #1326 - Add mode parameters as a value set.
8043 2015May core #1368 - Change Resource Contraindication to DetectedIssue
8045 2015May core #1370 - Medication Prescription Status Values
8105 DocumentReference.format needs to be type Codeing
8107 Update the definition of "status" for the MedicationStatement
8112 Recommend adding 'On-Hold' to MedicationStatement.status
8120 Consider Location.status "present"
8123 AuditEvent constraints are too tight
8142 2015May daf #96 - Modify Content Search Parameters
8163 Transaction processing sequence should reflect bundle entry sequence
8172 transaction-operation coding system doesn't correspond to transaction-operation value set
8184 Add reference to Condition
8188 ConceptMap structure doesn't make sense
8198 MAY2015 QICore#70 - Change CommunciationRequest.orderedOn to requestedOn
8204 URI for Medical Device Codes defined in ISO 11073-10101 is wrong
8210 2015MAY QICore#85 Goal.patient cardinality
8226 ValueSet.url should be ValueSet.uri
8230 Display for filter-operator "=" code is " "
8236 terminology system URL syntax
8246 Signature.who can have every dataType in fhir-single.xsd
8265 ValueSet.compose.include should have codes or filters, but not both
8281 Rename ProcedureRequest.timing[x] to scheduled[x]
8313 Change terminology for AllergyIntolerance.type
8343 j.equivalence definition and valueset detfinition contradict each other
8354 ValueSet.define should be renamed to ValueSet.codeSystem
8355 valueOrdinal should be decimal, not integer
8363 No place for a displayname in SearchParameter
8370 We're ambiguous about allowing relative urls for reference-type search parameters
8372 Support multiple discharge diagnoses
8379 Observation indirect target is confusing
8386 LOINC copyright query should not allow "All" as a value
8416 Remove batch operations now that we have a batch interaction
8418 Add Period to Group Characteristic
8437 Remove Social Security Number from the Identifier type value set and improve definition
8440 Change references from Supply to SupplyRequest
8441 Provide support for a CodeableConcept for answer to question
8449 OperationOutcome.issue.code is either extendable CodeableConcept or not Code - Prefer extendable
8450 OperationOutcome.issue.location is unfriendly to JSON based applications only using HTTP Get parameters
8498 DocumentReference.format belongs inside content
8504 change DR.requestdetail to DR.request to harmonize with PC resources
8509 Conformance should have a "kind"
8510 Rename NamingSystem.type to NamingSystem.kind
8511 NamingSystem.country and .category should become useContext
8512 NamingSystem.category should have same binding as Identifier.type
8514 change name of element serviveCategory to category
8521 Questionnaire Extension defaultasfixed - clarification
8551 create and extension for O.refrange to allow for ...or equal to

All tasks (inclduing the list above)

2840 Address can't differentiate physical and postal
2865 Clarify the functionality of GET [base]/[compartment]/[id]/?
3006 4.15.6 Resource Observation - Examples need to show related propert in use for panel and calculated measurement
3011 CarePlan.activity.note needs further explanation
3063 Simplification of Schemas #4 - use the
3090 Conformance SearchParams should be more powerful
3123 CarePlan.participant.role needs a value set
3129 Profile.structure.element.definition.type.profile should repeat
3151 Parent concept in medication-form-codes and medication-package-form-codes is wrong
3228 Need rules for tags invalidated by an update
3249 Profile.date should have a more meaningful name
3297 Add a warning about the safety implications of not conforming to the specification
3317 Patient/RelatedPerson/Organization search key 'phonetic' lacks path definition
3342 contained resources overrepresented in examples
3358 Need to clarify what's in-scope for resources vs. profiles
3361 Message endpoints should be associated with the event protocol
3478 Add DateTime to the Attachment data type
3501 Practitioner address data model not rich enough to capture needed information in all countries
3511 Add detail to Value Set Expansion Definition
3534 Need a formal support mechanism for i18n and l10n of schemas and schematrons
3598 Add support for multiple designations on concepts
3624 Add a property for comments to the JSON format
3625 Create "best practice" guide for creating a "system URI" for Coding
3627 Value set - define/concept[0..*] needs additional wording
3633 Change .expansion.timestamp datatype to dateTime
3655 Need to allow for Patient's where there's no indication of human vs. animal
6206 display text is wrong fro example
3760 Clarify when OperationOutcome rather than another resource is appropriate
3792 FHIR ebook not valid
3800 $validate and $translate should allow multiple repetitions
3802 Specify what it means for a search parameter to matches a complex datatype
3807 Should add rationale to Invariant
3810 Resource package/profile list should link directly to profile if only one is defined for unique id
3819 Need to allow Observation.related.target to be QuestionnaireAnswers in addition to Observation
3820 Need to add support for message polling and message querying
3836 Add constraining base node searches through ConformanceProfile
3855 search param naming is inconsistent
3873 Explicitly specify resource/element types throughout?
3874 Referenced system vakue "http://hl7.org/fhir/message-type" seems incorrect
3918 usability issues with "address" as a search parameter for patient
4003 Resource Encounter Content
4038 Expand the definition of CarePlan.concern
4872 Communication support for phone calls
5164 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #30
5165 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #32
5182 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #56
5194 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #69
5308 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #187
5313 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #192
5319 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #199
5368 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #254
5369 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #255
5371 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #257
5374 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #261
5378 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #265
5381 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #268
5383 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #270
5384 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #271
5386 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #273
5387 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #274
5388 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #275
5395 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #284
5444 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #337
5457 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #396
5458 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #397
5459 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #398
5460 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #399
5461 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #400
5471 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #407
5473 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #409
5474 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #410
5479 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #416
5480 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #417
5483 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #420
5495 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #432
5509 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #446
5518 Update example f201 to use dose, timing, and medication (remove the todos)
5520 Clarify the relationship of Medication.package and Medication.product
5535 Include common resource elements in resource profile definitions
5541 Add best practice narrative on suppressing data for client access of a resource
5549 Expansion and compose should allow for caseSensitive or define should loose the attribute
5553 Resource Ownership
5561 Composition.type and Composition.class defintions should be improved according to the improvements made to DocumentReference.
5624 create UDI examples for device
5633 Consider choice of code|Reference(Medication) or code|Reference(Medication|Substance)
5644 Follow up on #3600 Change MedAdmin.dosage.site to .bodySite choice of codeableConcept|reference(BodySite)
5652 Be specific that JSON format must be UTF-8 just like XML
5661 Add 'active' On Practitioner Resource
5665 To add new datatype for multichannel recording data
5666 .identifier - bring consistency to the cardinality and type across resources
5672 maintaining order within FHIR resources for list items
5678 List.flag vocabulary
5680 order of common resource elements not consistent
5690 Patient Entered/Reported Data
5694 Request for new security label for when content is removed from a resource for operational reasons
5695 Medication should be required in MedicationStatement
5701 MedicationStattement.wasNotGiven should notTaken
5713 Add "proposed" status to the Appointment resource
5720 MedicationAdministration.status should be marked as a modifier
5721 MedicationStatement.status should be marked as a modifier
5732 Add Organization reference to Order.source
5749 Need extensions for capturing formal mapping paths for data elements
5759 Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #455
5760 $translate does not suport dependsOn
5761 Consider Adding Precondition to MedicationStatement
5762 Dosage Instructions on Medication Dispense
5786 Are there other ways of doing UI hinting than a heirarchy in the expansion
5787 Do we need support for active/inactive in expansions?
5789 can we be more specific about date and filter parameters on expansion
5790 Improve documentation around value set expansion currency
5794 Define "all known value sets" magic URI as part of the spec
5800 Server Validation of CodeSystem.define.system
5801 Should code system name be a service provider specific identifer?
5802 How should display text case be handled on validate - case sensitive or not?
5803 Add concept map link extension
5806 Administration of medication to a patient
5820 AllergyIntolerance.event.description vs AllergyIntolerance.event.comment
5826 FamilyHistory negation
5829 Specimen needs status code
5844 Identification of Value Sets Used in a Profile
5846 typo in MedicationAdministration.dosage.rate
5847 MedicationAdministration.dosage.rate where no duration is needed
5861 MedicationPrescription.dosageInstruction.scheduled[x] naming inconsistency
5870 Alert should have encounter
5872 Add extension to link OperationOutcome and Contraindication
5880 Recognition in FHIR specificaiton of profiles from other organizations
5882 Value set should explain how master files are handled
5892 Medication Package Form Codes wrong?
5893 Note Immunization Resource Can Record Historical Immunizations
5895 is Order.authority part of 80%?
5896 Name of MedicationPrescription
5911 Consider 'dateEnded' for MedicationPrescription
5912 Consider 'reasonEnded' codeable concept for MedicationPrescription
5916 Clarify MedicationStatement usage
5926 Invariants should be on MedicationStatement
5928 FHIR specification and build system must be refactored
5935 "Break the Glass" Method Description in Security Labels Section is Very Limiting
5940 allow MedicationStatement.quantity to be either a quantity or range
5941 Clarify boundary between MedicationAdministration and MedicationStatement
5944 Clarify what elements of valueSet constitute the Content Logical Definition
5946 hostname instead of URL for LOINC
5947 Relationship between child concepts and subsumption needs clarification
5949 relationship between dosage.text and dosage.Scheduled[x]
5951 Timing doesn't allow an overall duration
5956 Additional Questionnaire layout hints - horizontal, autocomplete and select
5961 Change DiagnosticReport.name to .code
5965 Status values for MedicationStatement can conflict with effective[x]
5966 Composition section content should come before a nested section
5972 Weird-looking flags
5973 Superseded is misspelled
6336 "Executing an Operation Asynchronously" should be removed
5981 Need to be able to specify a value set identity by reference to a binding (e.g. element definition) in value set operations
5982 mixing of dates and versioning
5983 Unexpected behaviour specifyiing binding strength
5987 remove isSummary from Resource Definintion
5992 Wrong VS expansion: http://hl7.org/fhir/vs/medication-form-codes
5993 Wrong VS expansion: http://hl7.org/fhir/vs/medication-package-form-codes
5994 MedicationAdministration.medication description misleading
5996 Proposal to add _narrative parameter to REST api
5997 Rename Provenance.agent.reference[x]
5998 ImagingStudy should use CodeableConcept, not Coding
6019 Need a common extension to allow goals to be referenced from other resources
6022 Change short description of .perfomer
6023 Minimum cardinality of ProcedureRequest.subject should be 0
6025 Need rules for stringency
6032 Too many things 1..x in DocumentReference
6034 NDF-RT link on Named Systems List page 404s
6040 StructureDefinition/ElementDefinition overlaps
6041 durationMax not present in Repeat element of Timing resource
6042 Terminology services page: validate-code replaces validate
6043 Questionnaire.$populate - subject parameter type should be Reference(Any) not Any
6044 Questionnaire - needs a subject type element
6045 Sort - specification is unclear about whether sort is case sensitive or not
6046 Questionnaire.$populate - content parameter type should be Any, not string
6048 Signature should allow device resources
6060 Documentation of extensions for simple types
6061 Typos
6066 Expand [x] type element in profile unspecified types in the snapshot
6067 Split Supply into SupplyRequest and SupplyDispense
3791 create examples tab for extensions
6077 Complex extensions aren't rendering properly
6078 LOINC mappings for data element should be to database columns
6079 StructureDefinition needs a target type property
6080 CAP example isn't showing up in ballot
6084 MedicationPrescription misspelled as MedicationPescription in several places
6085 Add discussion of profile consistency to profile page
6087 No way to specify multiple bindings (with different strengths)?
6088 We still need Physical vs. Postal address
6089 Telecom doesn't allow for alternate systems
6091 Add Device.note
6092 Individual Resource pages do not align with Resource names
6093 Differential element[x] is expanded to element
6094 change 'subject' search parameter
6096 Bundle resource has no elements that are marked as "in summary"
6097 Conceptmaps are not part of validation.zip
6098 Extension Initial presumed answer for question - request for more detail surrounding
6099 Should have style and markup on Question.text and Group.text
6100 change enternalFormula.rate to type quantity
6101 Miove .enteralformula.schduled next to .quantity
6102 move enrteraformula.administrationinstruction to end
6103 provide guidance in notes section on how to use the resource for a continuous vs a bolus enteral feeding
6104 Tooling should enforce coding capitalization consistency
6105 Appointment notes section could use a diagram or two
6106 add a entry for a single file containing all the structure definition datatype and resource
6107 broken link in patient example
6108 Clarify FHIR server behavior (http codes, body, outcome etc) while CREATE with id, UPDATE without id
6109 HTTP codes ValueSet
6111 change type for rate change trom quatnity to rate
6113 Summary needs to be updated
6115 add elements to Address data type
6116 Parameters resource is missing in listings
6118 409 status code
6121 Content-Type,_format,accept,Accept-Charset
6122 Support non-atomic transactions/batches in RESTful API
6125 Profiling should document rules for documentation & mappings
6126 Make clear that RelatedPerson and Practitioner can be animals
6127 ValueSet profile should support additional instruction on codes
6128 Change vaccineType to vaccineCode
6129 Change the Procedure attribute type to code
6130 Change attribute name for Quantiy.code, Quantity.units, Quantity.system
6131 CarePlan could benefit from a reference to EpisodeOfCare
6132 Add Problem to ConditionCategory
6133 change "list" to "see List of Resources"
6134 Change 'This resource is extends resource" to 'This resource is extends the base Resource'
6135 move hyperlink to resources adn Capitalize
6136 change "concept" to "concept code" or "code"
6138 Validator not handling references to contained resources
6139 Resource.Id and Resource.meta not in summary
6140 Schema error for Age, Count, etc.
6144 remove table showing conformance/extensibility combinations
6145 typo in example
6147 Typo in text for DomainResource Resource
6148 Typo in text for searhc parameter
6149 missing text? in bundle transaction discussion
6151 structureDefintion notes section does not apply - typo?
6152 typo in 6.17.5.2
6153 Conformance.rest.security.service should be extensible
6154 Does Conformence need a RevIinclude list?
6155 Refers to StructureDefinition wheras much of the discussion is about ElementDefinition
6156 should this section refer to the section on revinclude?
6157 replace this section or refer to Bundle text from 6.8.3.5
6158 fix link
6159 correct typo
6160 fix typo
6162 fix typo
6163 no example of JSON comments found -need explicit example references or shown
6164 fix uml for timing datatype
6166 when and how to use AppointmentResponse.participantType
6167 need more clear clarification
6169 vsd 1 expansion.value for is wrong
6170 Clarify use of flag.category
6171 Flag.patient should be [0..1]
6172 no example for named query
6173 Parameters resource not listed on resource page
6174 add link
6175 change text to avoid using term 'list'
6176 clarfiy what is meant by 'subject resource '
6177 fix typo
6178 provide claricifaction to profile tags
6179 Narrow down composition.section.code value set
6180 Bining types need to be updated in this section
6181 Code restriction regex is wrong
6184 BCP-13 and BCP-47 should be in the coding system list
6187 need to also refer to both SturctureDefinition and ElementDefintion
6188 differnec between profile types is unclear
6189 differential view should only show what is different
6190 There are two Clinical Document profiles in Spec?
6191 broken links
6193 change name of section
6194 remove the parenthetical resources
6195 Include reference to fulfillment of referral request
6196 propose boundaries for DO
6199 add boundaries section to DR
6200 remove background and context section from DR
6201 Add referral creation date
6202 redo Background and Context section
6205 refer to .neme which is missing
6207 Improve the description for .event.detail
6208 Allow Organization in flag.author
6209 Unclear how to represent non-medical devices
6212 create at least example binding
6214 detail.product what about diet/ nutrional suppliements
6215 roll up CarePlan.activity.detail.note into CarePlan.activity.notes
6216 Goal.concern reference list
6218 change name to sodium and 'fluid' restircted
6219 medication form bound to dosage route VS
6223 why not have a reference to the MedicationDispense Resource for reference to dosing details
6226 Search summary table misses entry for _query
6229 extension definition still very hard to read
6233 AuditEvent confusion on 'idenfier' elements that are actually strings. Affects understanding as well as search (which should not be token)
6234 suggestion to add a feature like _fields
6235 Invalid namespace prefix xs:xs:gYear in primitive profile XML
6238 Is WADO-RS equivalent to " DICOM contexts " and "DICOM constructs"
6239 many descritiption contain paranthetical ids - a legend would be nice to explain what they mean
6240 with identifier.type does is make sense to roll up multiple identifier or keep as separate idenetifiers
6241 Retrieve URI (0008,1190) is confusing name
6242 ImagingStudy.clinicalInformation shoiuld choice of string or Condition resource and possbile code?
6243 .procedure needs at least an example binding and should there be a choice with procedure resource
6244 ImagingStudy.series.instance.content comment is wrong
6245 Suggest hyperlinks to referenced standards WADO and DICOM
6246 add choice ImagingObjectSelection to DiagnosticReport.imagingStudy
6248 add unkown to Value Set http://hl7.org/fhir/vs/animal-genderstatus and make required
6251 Communication.payload.content[x] definition is too narrow
6252 Timing.repeat.count must support ranges and decimal type.
6253 body site should be a datatype - but used consisitantly throughout the standrard.
6256 define entity and how is different from agent
6257 Need additional prefixes for date search parameters
6258 Extension Reference to the DeviceMetric resource - Definition not needed
6259 constrain out Device from .device in DeviceMetricObservation profile
6266 Please Clarify "Data Element vs. Codes" section
6269 AuditEvent needs a Participant userId type code to explain how to understand the value in userId (e.g. Patient ID in CX form)
6271 Subject of flag
6272 IHE multiple extension point review request
6273 fix typo
6277 Minor editorial fix
6279 Modifier listing should be consistent all be listed in one place (split up)
6298 unable to review adverse event dus to pub issues
6302 ValueSetCategory has no values listed yet is a required binding
6304 Abstract for Action Who/What/When/Where/Why across Resources
6307 Specify dot-notation for element name
6029 More precise definitions of some concept map equivalence codes
6308 Wording improvement for Extensible binding
6309 Allow reference to medication to be either a code or a Medication Resource Reference8112
6310 Add MedicationStatementStatus for planned future medications
6311 Need better explanation of DataElement Slicing
6312 Body Site used to collect specimen is part of Specimen resource not Observation
6313 Distinction between Observation and QuestionnaireAnswers unclear
6318 Bundle.entry.search.mode only captures one status
6320 Clarify distinction between ElementDefinition.defaultValue vs. ElementDefinition.meaningWhenMissing
6321 Improve the mechanism for auto-generating StructureDefinition ids in build tool
6324 JSON views: "canonical form" links broken
6325 ElementDefinition.short should not refer to "generated XML format"
6326 How does OperationOutcome communicate limitations imposed by security?
6327 Descriptions of multiple-cardinality fields should be uniformly expressed in the singular (or plural)
6328 Bundle.entry.resource should be defined as "Resource" (not "Resources")
6329 Clarify description of Bundle.entry.transaction.url
6330 Need a consistent way to refer to quoted values in FHIR spec
6331 Clarify whether conditional operations in a transaction include [base]
6332 Clarify the justification for requiring a "transaction" in history bundle entries
6333 Example reference to Binary content should use a capital "B"
6334 Why do Condition.onset and Condition.abatement have different datatypes?
6335 OperationDefinition should distingush parameters that are Resourecs vs. References
6337 elementdefinition-examples.html should link to structuredefinition-examples.html
6338 Missing "raw" link for some JSON pages
6339 Are slicing discriminators compatible with `pattern[x]` constraints in ElementDefinition?
6340 How do StructureDefinitions treat [x] values?
6341 Slicing examples need to be updated (Observation.name no longer exists)
6342 Clarify the "literal" vs "logical" behavior of :in modifier for search
6343 The /Mailbox endpoint is no longer needed, given FHIR's "operations" framework
6344 Explain how to achieve the behavior or "valueBoolean" for Observations
6345 Clarify how DocumentReference.type and DocumentReference.class differ
6346 DocumentReference should have a reference to Encounter
6347 Timing examples should break "period+units" into two columns
6354 Provenance mapping to W3C specification
6355 Requirements column in profile spreadsheet does not get filled in for generated profile
6365 Improve documentation about element
6578 NamingSystem bundle for FHIR distibution
6629 Define system URIs for common coding systems
6630 Patient.deceased search parameter has wrong xpath
6637 Add modifier to string parameters to indicate what kind of partial match is required
6783 Add a bundle of NamingSystems for known code systems/identifiers
6784 2015May sdc #1 - Can answer lists be independent of questions?
6785 2015May sdc #2 - Multi-code system value sets are bad
6793 2015May sdc #10 - Use stringency, not specificity
6797 2015May sdc #14 - Show the actual data type for References
6798 2015May sdc #15 - Explain usefulness in other jurisdictions
6799 2015May sdc #16 - Warn about schema-centric implementation.
6801 2015May sdc #18 - Explain different id types
6803 2015May sdc #20 - Explain how ConceptMap works better
6807 2015May sdc #24 - Explain usage of value sets in SDC-context
6809 2015May sdc #26 - 404 on link to SDC wiki
6810 2015May sdc #27 - Explain what "options" means
6811 2015May sdc #28 - Can type be a code?
6815 2015May sdc #32 - Can root group be non-required?
6817 2015May sdc #34 - Add invariant on cardinality extensions to repeat
6818 2015May sdc #35 - Duplicate extensions
6821 2015May sdc #38 - Reference to Questionnaire should be profile-specific
6823 2015May sdc #40 - Fix indirect link
6826 2015May sdc #43 - Change referenced QuestionnaireAnswer resource to "QuestionnaireAnswers".
6827 2015May sdc #44 - Fix page numberings
6828 2015May sdc #45 - Define terminology for Questionnaire category extension
6829 2015May sdc #46 - Declare references as Reference(x)
6831 2015May sdc #48 - Missing/bad links
6832 2015May sdc #49 - JSON template not in All view
6833 2015May sdc #50 - Links to structure definitions don't resolve
6834 2015May sdc #51 - XML representation for last "value*" element should have the entire element crossed out not just its description.
6836 2015May sdc #53 - Missing publisher
6837 2015May sdc #54 - Consistent in use of terms. For example, CCDA and C-CDA.
6838 2015May sdc #55 - TOC did not list all sections.
6839 2015May sdc #56 - remove extra "/" at end and relace with "."
6840 2015May sdc #57 - Labels on different tabs should be different
6841 2015May sdc #58 - change FHIR version from 0.2 to 0.5.0
6846 2015May sdc #63 - Diagram references "template"
6850 2015May sdc #67 - What's behavior for modifier extensions?
6853 2015May sdc #70 - Add authorization qualifier to 'read'
6862 2015May sdc #79 - Small XSD facets issue.
6868 2015May sdc #85 - Why unassessible?
6882 2015May sdc #99 - data types inconsistent
6883 2015May sdc #100 - Cardinality change from 0..1 to 0..*
6885 2015May sdc #102 - Change the term EMR to EHR.
6886 2015May sdc #103 - Change CER to PCOR
6887 2015May sdc #104 - Change to PCOR use case
6888 2015May sdc #105 - Reword introduction section
6889 2015May sdc #106 - Forms are not part of an EHR
6893 2015May sdc #110 - Correct link
6895 2015May sdc #112 - Make endpoint 1..*
6897 2015May sdc #114 - Resource is impenetrable
6898 2015May sdc #115 - Repetition spelled incorrectly
6899 2015May sdc #116 - Add pre-population
6901 2015May sdc #118 - Explain signatures of forms with Provenance
6904 2015May sdc #126 - Why are extensions needed for answer list?
6905 2015May sdc #127 - Why is options a reference rather than a list of embedded content
6906 2015May sdc #128 - How do you nest questions under answers?
6907 2015May sdc #130 - Valueset could not be expanded
6910 2015May sdc #133 - why does the sentences states value set has 0 concepts?
6911 2015May sdc #134 - Duplicate "used in"
6912 2015May sdc #135 - Episodes of Care can overlap and reference the same encounter
6913 2015May sdc #136 - How are "append" relationships handled?
6914 2015May sdc #137 - removal of the sentence, removes the issue.
6917 2015May sdc #140 - Simply wording about Narrative
6918 2015May sdc #141 - What's relationship between class and type
6919 2015May sdc #142 - Assert no context flow
6920 2015May sdc #143 - Add Author to list
6922 2015May sdc #145 - Request that max count be unbounded
6923 2015May sdc #146 - Request that max count be unbounded
6925 2015May sdc #148 - Inclusion of pagers for contact
6927 2015May sdc #150 - A requested fix for profiling.
6928 2015May sdc #151 - Make Race and Ethnicity core
6931 2015May sdc #154 - Distinguish primary contact
6934 How does escaping work in composite URI searches?
6935 Provide example post requests for complex operations such as the different variants of $validate-code
6937 2015May core #2 - Add description to AllergyIntolerance
6938 2015May core #3 - Appointment/Encounter Referencing
6944 2015May core #9 - Make reason 0..*
6945 2015May core #10 - Makre reasonReference 0..*
6946 2015May core #11 - Typo on goal
6947 2015May core #12 - Add CarePlan.description
6949 2015May core #14 - Expand on potential uses
6950 2015May core #15 - Message can be sent to many receipient (recipient 0..*). How will the sender know if the message was received by all of them?
6952 2015May core #17 - Explain contraindication.author
6954 2015May core #19 - Clarification needed - is this who authored the documents in the set? Or is this who authored the document manifest?
6955 2015May core #20 - Typo - throuh needs a g
6956 2015May core #21 - Typo - change my to by
6958 2015May core #23 - Need to identify generic maternal/paternal relationships without specific family member
6960 2015May core #25 - Typo - remove "for use"
6969 2015May core #34 - typo - fix location of opening parenthesis.
6972 2015May core #37 - Make address 0..*
6975 2015May core #40 - GET should be POST, name changed
6977 2015May core #42 - GET should be POST, name is wrong
6983 2015May core #48 - Missing www
6984 2015May core #49 - Unabreviate name
6985 2015May core #50 - No detail regarding the Risk Assessment issue
6963 2015May core #28 - ?Typo - Change note to list
6986 2015May core #51 - Typo: missing closing bracket
6987 2015May core #52 - In the notes, the incorrect line is stated in reference to the resource's id
6988 2015May core #53 - Make last updated match last-modified
6989 2015May core #54 - Add HTTP headers to example
6990 2015May core #55 - Change "SearchResults" -> Bundle
6991 2015May core #56 - Incorrect line number for meta.lastUpdated
6992 2015May core #57 - Incorrect line number for base
6993 2015May core #58 - Incorrect line number for total
6994 2015May core #59 - Incorrect line number for link
6995 2015May core #60 - "item" should be "entry" with correct line number
6996 2015May core #61 - Typo in word "exist"
6997 2015May core #62 - Incorrect line number for id
6998 2015May core #63 - It would be useful to have the Update Response return an HTTP Location header with the Updated Resource's new location on the service.
6999 2015May core #64 - Spelling typo
7000 2015May core #65 - Unclosed bracket typo.
7001 2015May core #66 - "[Missing]" suggests the spec is incomplete.
7002 2015May core #67 - Use "individual resource level"
7003 2015May core #68 - Invariants Section content missing
7004 2015May core #69 - Table contains a number of values under Status with "Unknown - not stated by committee"
7005 2015May core #70 - Typo in word "that"
7006 2015May core #71 - Typo in word "is"
7007 2015May core #72 - TBD in table of registries
7008 2015May core #73 - Missing section on Canonical XML
7009 2015May core #74 - todo - develop this at top of section
7011 2015May core #76 - remove references to value set from Coding
7013 2015May core #78 - Missing introduction or no introduction?
7014 2015May core #79 - Content is "todo"
7015 2015May core #80 - Missing link
7016 2015May core #81 - Response: Happy with mandatory SSL/TLS+Server Certificate, and optional client certificate authentication.
7017 2015May core #82 - Spelling typo
7018 2015May core #83 - Response: Specifying paging support would be a welcome addition and would further increase interoperability.
7019 2015May core #84 - Spelling typo
7020 2015May core #85 - Grammar around "the criteria is expressed.".
7021 2015May core #86 - Typo around "On"
7022 2015May core #87 - client makes the call, not the server
7023 2015May core #88 - It would be useful and informative to demonstrate how this process fulfills the original problem statement in the beginning of this section.
7024 2015May core #89 - Typo around "if they are do not"
7025 2015May core #90 - Missing content / TODO
7026 2015May core #91 - Disagree with timezone approach
7027 2015May core #92 - Missing content / TODO
7030 2015May core #95 - State whether translation codes are allowed and evaluated
7031 2015May core #96 - State whether translation codes are allowed and evaluated
7032 2015May core #97 - Reference to feed.category is incorrect.
7033 2015May core #98 - More documentation for "cert"
7034 2015May core #99 - Content comes from SDC
7036 2015May core #101 - Specification generation/tooling error
7038 2015May core #103 - Missing content
7039 2015May core #104 - List includes "Other" instead of "Basic"
7041 2015May core #106 - It would be helpful if this value set had a code to indicate a List is accurate within the context it is used in
7042 2015May core #107 - Missing content / TODO
7043 2015May core #108 - Add constraint around Locked Date wrt referenced versions
7044 2015May core #109 - Is the code list complete and sufficient?
7047 2015May core #112 - Explain relationship between AllergyIntolerance and RiskAssessment
7052 2015May core #117 - Agree, this isn't necessary.
7053 2015May core #118 - What is the recommended approach for recording alerts?
7054 2015May core #119 - Typo
7055 2015May core #120 - Explain how No Known Allergies is handled
7056 2015May core #122 - Did you consider making the status mandatory (1..1)? What does it mean when an AllergyIntolerance is retunred with this field empty?
7058 2015May core #124 - The movement of sunlight out of this resource directly is different than the design in C-CDA design.
7059 2015May core #125 - Remove sentence on 5%
7040 2015May core #105 - Spelling typo
7060 2015May core #126 - Typo
7061 2015May core #127 - Add mime type list
7069 2015May core #128 - Is the person that Authored the plan always the one responsible for the plan? Would it better to say who 'wrote' the plan?
7070 2015May core #129 - Please add a suggested value set
7072 2015May core #131 - Did you consider making the title 1..1 if the section is present?
7073 2015May core #132 - What is the use case for not having a title?
7075 2015May core #134 - there's is misspelled
7076 2015May core #135 - Remove "are"
7077 2015May core #136 - resource misspelled
7078 2015May core #137 - whether should not be capitalized
7079 2015May core #138 - Copy and paste from 1.12.2
7080 2015May core #139 - Copy and paste from 1.12.2
7081 2015May core #140 - "that" should be "than"
7082 2015May core #141 - "an" should be "a"
7083 2015May core #142 - Missing "IDs"?
7084 2015May core #143 - Is there a need for a non-bulleted list? list-style-type:none
7086 2015May core #145 - Should communcation also include a prefered method such as sign language, Braille, email, telephone, etc.
7087 2015May core #146 - Is the priority property the patient's priority or the practicioner's priority? Shouldn't both be represented as they may not be the same?
7088 2015May core #147 - Both example links return 404.
7089 2015May core #148 - "activity" should be "activites"
7090 2015May core #149 - "A" should be "An"
7091 2015May core #150 - Remove "a"
7092 2015May core #151 - Remove the phrase "consumer level" from the introduction.
7093 2015May core #152 - Remove the first occurrence of the word "a" in this sentence.
7094 2015May core #153 - Change semicolon to a colon, correct spelling of "differently," and add a period at the end of the sentence.
7095 2015May core #154 - Move the sentence to section 1.23.6.3.1, and consider expanding it.
7096 2015May core #155 - Change "a code" in the first sentence" to "codes."
7097 2015May core #156 - Capitalize the abbreviation "URI."
7103 2015May core #162 - Wording is over complex
7107 2015May core #166 - Request that max count be unbounded
7118 2015May core #177 - Explain whether Contraindication is definition or instance
7121 2015May core #180 - Statuses aren't sufficient
7123 2015May core #182 - What's difference between Procedure.category and type?
7124 2015May core #183 - Use approach site, not target
7125 2015May core #184 - Don't make Procedure.outcome codes
7126 2015May core #185 - Procedure.complication should be narrative
7127 2015May core #186 - Procedure.relatedItem is too complicated - make it extension
7129 2015May core #188 - Procedure.device is too vague
7133 2015May core #192 - Differentiate placer & filler ids
7134 2015May core #193 - Rename clinicalNotes to reason or indication
7135 2015May core #194 - supporting information isn't clear, includes errors
7137 2015May core #196 - Declare relationship with IEEE 11073
7141 2015May core #200 - What unit codes are to be used?
7143 2015May core #202 - needs more description. Doubt they are talking about color as in the light spectrum, so need something that ordinary folks can understand
7144 2015May core #203 - Believe this is really the sampling rate of a signal. If so that should be stated more clearly
7148 2015May core #207 - Explain Apgar example
7149 2015May core #208 - very unclear. is this in case it is Coded with exceptions variable gets a free text answer.. Need an example
7150 2015May core #209 - test not done was reported as part of the status in V2. Would make sense to stay with that both for continuity and because it is NOT really an answer
7152 2015May core #211 - to whom. Think it is usually when made available to the clinical providers. It may be available earlier within lab but not yet "verified"
7154 2015May core #213 - Explain reliability
7155 2015May core #214 - add "instance" to end after "observation". Might comment on the scope of uniqueness. globally unique or unique in the context of the sources
7156 2015May core #215 - insert "donor" after fetus
7157 2015May core #216 - Subject can be communicated within Observation.code
7158 2015May core #217 - change "are often" to "may be"
7160 2015May core #219 - Explain grouping more
7161 2015May core #220 - Related type is unneeded complexity
7167 2015May core #226 - Clarify purpose of MedicationStatement
7168 2015May core #227 - Loosen who can capture MedicationStatement
7170 2015May core #229 - would help in the US to say this would usually be the RxNorm clinical drug code as mandated by MU regulation
7172 2015May core #231 - Does NutritionOrder include hyperalimentation?
7175 2015May core #234 - How to handle confusion between intolerance vs. preference
7176 2015May core #235 - How to handle confusion between intolerance vs. preference vs. excludeFood
7178 2015May core #237 - Distinguish what's in internal order vs. provider order (amount)
7184 2015May core #243 - Use route rather than enteral formula
7187 2015May core #246 - Add reference to panels & batteries
7191 2015May core #250 - add " (revised) " for clarity after updated.
7193 2015May core #253 - Overlap of Procedure and Observation is going to be a problem
7202 2015May core #262 - Explain how terminology works with local vs. standard code sets.
7204 2015May core #264 - Typo - "and" misspelled in second sentence
7205 2015May core #265 - Don't understand code system and value set distinction
7207 2015May core #267 - Don't use ValueSet for answer lists
7210 2015May core #270 - Errors in examples
7211 2015May core #271 - Don't use both SNOMED and LOINC
7212 2015May core #272 - no one would do this. Further the oral temperature does not literally measure any thing about the body as a whole
7213 2015May core #273 - no one would do this either if the measure is called oral temperature
7214 2015May core #274 - Narrative doesn't reflect how data would be reported
7219 2015May core #279 - Need phase abnormal flag
7220 2015May core #280 - what are these symbols?
7222 2015May core #282 - Which are master files vs. patient-specific elements. ClinicalImpression is problematic
7223 2015May core #283 - should be distinguished as a master file or knowledge base not patient specific
7224 2015May core #284 - Use MedicationOrder rather than MedicationRequest
7226 2015May core #286 - more often this will be data about a dispensing . The distinction based on how it arrived is not good
7227 2015May core #287 - This is described as an issues at to whether it should be separate
7229 2015May core #289 - Use MedicationOrder rather than MedicationRequest
7230 2015May core #290 - the LOINC code for blood culture is 600-7 Bacteria identified in Blood by Culture
7231 2015May core #291 - Don't use both SNOMED and LOINC
7232 2015May core #292 - "entire body" is a bad example
7233 2015May core #293 - Fix examples to show pre-coordinated formula
7234 2015May core #294 - Use LOINC instead of SNOMED
7237 2015May core #297 - Errors in examples
7243 2015May core #303 - Don’t know what is included
7244 2015May core #304 - presume this relates to the so called segmented privacy, that will be a nightmare and could be glue to the wheels of care. Would try to avoid it.
7249 2015May core #309 - Need more background on parallels of messaging w/ v2
7257 2015May core #447 - No content is provieded in this section
7259 2015May core #449 - The error code and any recommendations on OperationOutcome should be specified
7261 2015May core #451 - No content is provieded in this section
7262 2015May core #452 - No content is provieded in this section
7265 2015May core #455 - contains route codes instead of the intended medication form codes
7266 2015May core #456 - contains routce codes instead of the intended package codes
7269 2015May core #459 - Need a definition from Lloyd
7270 2015May core #460 - The link is critical in order to know what the requirement is.
7256 2015May core #446 - Typo
7271 2015May core #461 - I am unsure as to the intention of this note, but it does not seem to match the example
7272 2015May core #462 - The line number references in the notes do not seem to match the example
7273 2015May core #463 - Typo
7274 2015May core #464 - Missing closing paraenthesis at end
7275 2015May core #465 - Line number reference is incorrect
7276 2015May core #466 - lastUpdated (line 12) - if present, this must match the value in the HTTP header
7277 2015May core #467 - server is spelled wrong
7278 2015May core #468 - Typo
7279 2015May core #469 - How is resource contention handled on delete?
7280 2015May core #470 - More explanation on client-assigned ids8082
7282 2015May core #472 - Typo
7284 2015May core #474 - No content is provieded in this section
7285 2015May core #475 - No content is provieded in this section
7288 2015May core #478 - No content is provieded in this section
7289 2015May core #479 - Verify security risks are handled in stylesheet
7290 2015May core #480 - Content is needed
7301 2015May core #491 - Make birthDate a dateTime
7303 2015May core #493 - There may be more than one dietary preference/restriction
7304 2015May core #494 - There may be more than one diagnosis on discharge
7305 2015May core #495 - admit diagnoses are important, particularly in the cases where the patient may have not be discharged yet.
7307 2015May core #497 - Consider adding birthDate dateTime to resource, just as it is in the Person resource. Ager of the individual involved in the care could be important
7311 2015May core #501 - Keep birthDate data type consistent with the Person resource
7313 2015May core #503 - No guidance provided on Messaging subscription
7340 2015May core #530 - Example links are broken.
7345 2015May core #535 - Require server behavior for merged patients.
7346 2015May core #536 - Make the address search parameter its own type with subdivisions rather than simply a string.
7347 2015May core #537 - Schedule.actor has resource type of "Any"
7348 2015May core #538 - participant.actor should be required
7349 2015May core #539 - Not ALL of CCDA has been incorporated yet.
7351 2015May core #541 - Add ambulatory care to list of contexts
7352 2015May core #542 - Merge first paragraph of 1.7.2.2 into 1.7.2.1. and eliminate second paragraph
7353 2015May core #543 - Use a better comparison than folders
7354 2015May core #544 - Typo extraneous "is." Also suggest capitalizing and making the link more explicit (to Base Resource).
7355 2015May core #545 - Wording is confusing on common properties
7356 2015May core #546 - Don't use "may not"
7357 2015May core #547 - Typo
7358 2015May core #548 - Don't list CCD, say "implementation guide" instead of profile
7359 2015May core #549 - What is the answer then? Shouldn't there be testing tools that can check complete conformance to the FHIR spec, as well as to specific FHIR Profiles?
7360 2015May core #550 - Need to see isModifer=true in the instance
7361 2015May core #551 - Clarify some confusion that cropped up when people looked at "aborted" vs "cancelled" in mapping efforts
7362 2015May core #552 - Expand on life-cylc
7363 2015May core #553 - Use "life cycle" instead of "pattern"
7364 2015May core #554 - Drop life-cycle table until there are more definitions
7365 2015May core #555 - Change "from" to "to"
7366 2015May core #556 - Why not avoid this problem by requiring contained resources to explicitly state their subject? Why allow this degree of optionality?
7367 2015May core #557 - Clarify use of "Medication" as non-patient-specific
7368 2015May core #558 - Narrative should contain all human-relevant discrete data
7370 2015May core #560 - How is list narrative made non-redundant if generated?
7371 2015May core #561 - Narrative only shouldn't be a List
7372 2015May core #562 - See my comment on 6.1.5 -- it does not make sense to call these types of narrative a "List."
7373 2015May core #563 - Is "instant" needed?
7374 2015May core #564 - Clarify reference to contained extension
7375 2015May core #565 - Typo
7376 2015May core #566 - MedicationPrescription "anti-prescription" example has a typo in its first tag, and has as the ending tag.
7377 2015May core #567 - Typo
7378 2015May core #568 - Rename "Specification Map" to "Table of Contents"
7379 2015May core #569 - Be explicit that Composition doesn't contain content. Also note that it establishes context.
7380 2015May core #570 - Typo
7381 2015May core #571 - How are lawn mowing services healthcare related?
7382 2015May core #572 - "a single" is too limiting and does not fit the examples.
7384 2015May core #574 - I think it's important to be explicit about how to know the difference between proposals and actual orders, so I suggested the additional wording.
7385 2015May core #575 - From previous ballot, enter something about 162, 176, 177, 183, 187
7386 2015May core #576 - Differentiate "doesn't have" from "refuted"
7387 2015May core #577 - Add link to documents from Resources page under "Documents & Structure" heading
7388 2015May core #578 - Soften language on presentation of the document changing.
7392 2015May core #582 - Reword definition
7393 2015May core #583 - Remove "final mode" and clarify description of changes list.
7394 2015May core #584 - Where is narrative found in a resource?
7395 2015May core #585 - Saying "base" resource could be confusing since there is a specifical "Base Resource" section (1.10) in the FHIR spec.
7396 2015May core #586 - Typo
7397 2015May core #587 - Remove (or deprecate) this from the Basic Resource Types value set because Slot is already a FHIR resource in the Scheduling/Ordering category.
7398 2015May core #588 - Link is broken, sentence is confusing
7399 2015May core #589 - Typo
7401 2015May core #591 - Distinguish "element" vs. "backbone element"
7402 2015May core #592 - The URL does not work, produces an HTTP 404 error.
7403 2015May core #593 - Description of the rules on human-readable text aren't completely accurate
7404 2015May core #594 - Is narrative the same for documents vs. other mechanisms?
7405 2015May core #595 - Example implies MedicationStatement is a summary, when summary is List
7407 2015May core #597 - CarePlanActivityCategory shouldn't be required
7408 2015May core #598 - Typo
7410 2015May core #600 - Suggest providing a clarification to explicitly allow deprecation (sometimes it just makes sense).
7411 2015May core #601 - Typo
7412 2015May core #602 - ToC links to wrong page
7413 2015May core #603 - Typo, phrase is vague
7414 2015May core #604 - How does OperationOutcome represent business issues?
7415 2015May core #605 - ToC links to wrong page
7417 2015May core #607 - ToC links to wrong page
7418 2015May core #608 - Contradication in definition of Device.location
7420 2015May core #610 - ToC links to wrong page
7421 2015May core #611 - Typo
7422 2015May core #612 - Typo
7423 2015May core #613 - Typo
7426 2015May core #714 - Reference any resource in Document manifest
7427 2015May core #715 - Reference any resources in Document manifest
7428 2015May core #716 - Using of Snomed CT
7400 2015May core #590 - It does not say where to submit the request for a new code. FHIR Management Group? Vocabulary WG? Where? I suggest that be included in the text.
7429 2015May core #717 - Using of Snomed CT
7430 2015May core #718 - Harmonization with ISO EN 13606
7431 2015May core #719 - AuditEvent source identifier
7438 2015May core #726 - Provide help text for flags column
7439 2015May core #727 - Typo
7440 2015May core #728 - hyperlink is to #modifier, but that does not exist on this page….probably should be to #1.16.0.2
7441 2015May core #729 - hyperlink is to seatch.html#mustSupport, but that does not exist on this page….probably should be to #2.1.1.4.7
7444 2015May core #732 - …except… except what? Seems like there is something missing from the sentence
7445 2015May core #733 - nice file cabinet, folder, versioning analogy, but think that read needs to specify it gets the paper from the top of the folder
7446 2015May core #734 - missing a space between appropriate and cabinet
7447 2015May core #735 - resource instead of reosurce
7448 2015May core #736 - Need life-cycle declared everywhere
7450 2015May core #738 - How is unknown extensions support declareD?
7452 2015May core #740 - How do we avoid duplicate extensions?
7454 2015May core #742 - Can only one be declared as primary? Can none?
7456 2015May core #744 - The existing text seems to have a sentence fragment and the meaning is unclear.
7457 2015May core #745 - should allow for multiple Coding returned, with at most one marked as primary
7459 2015May core #747 - Why are_text and _filter missing?
7460 2015May core #748 - Allow non-resources to be focus of Provenance
7463 2015May core #751 - patient compartment should be lowercase patient, not uppercase Patient, which would be the resource.
7464 2015May core #752 - "patient" has wrong case
7466 2015May core #754 - Don't snip narrative
7468 2015May core #756 - Explain issues around cross-origin resource sharing
7469 2015May core #764 - Typo-Binding Definitions
7470 2015May core #765 - Finding the Table of Contents and Section numbers
7471 2015May core #766 - Clinical Resources vs. Administrative Resource
7472 2015May core #767 - Problems with the section "Mixing Custom and Standard Terminologies"
7473 2015May core #768 - Permit a code for a MedicationStatement's Medication
7476 2015May core #771 - Rendering of choice cardinalities
7477 2015May core #772 - Guide to Resources needed
7479 2015May core #774 - 5.1 isn't referenced in TOC correctly
7480 2015May core #775 - These appear to be the same value set but are referenced with different names.
7481 2015May core #776 - Value set link broken
7482 2015May core #777 - This comment appears to be left over from when dosage was 0..* and is no longer appropriate now that dosage is 0..1.
7483 2015May core #778 - consistency of FamilyMemberHistory's condition with the Condition resource
7484 2015May core #779 - Clarify Data Element Boundaries and Relationships
7485 2015May core #780 - Typos in Data Elements vs. Codes
7487 2015May core #782 - Suggested grammar fix in 6.21.8.1
7488 2015May core #783 - Clarification needed on the use of Data Element with other resources
7489 2015May core #784 - Typo in 1.23.0.0.1
7490 2015May core #785 - Grammar in 1.23.0.1
7491 2015May core #786 - Typo in 1.23.0.1
7492 2015May core #787 - Typo in 1.23.1.1.5
7493 2015May core #788 - Sentence re-write is needed.
7494 2015May core #789 - Appropriateness of each coded data type
7495 2015May core #790 - Typo in 1.23.0.2.1
7496 2015May core #791 - Clarify preferred
7497 2015May core #792 - Omitted words in Discriminator discussion
7498 2015May core #793 - Fix incomplete sentence in Discriminator examples.
7499 2015May core #794 - Fix numbering of extensions in Slicing Examples
7500 2015May core #795 - DiagnosticReport.issued -- change to instant?
7502 2015May core #797 - Question about ordering
7503 2015May core #798 - Nested lists?
7504 2015May core #799 - History of
7505 2015May core #800 - FamilyMemberHistory search parameters needed
7506 2015May core #801 - Enforce identifier search parameter
7511 2015May core #802 - Make names consistent between Procedure and Encounter
7513 2015May core #804 - MedicationStatement should allow dose range
7514 2015May core #805 - MedicationStatement- medication as code not Reference(Medication)
7515 2015May core #806 - rename MedicationStatement.dosage.schedule to MedicationStatement.dosage.timing
7517 2015May core #808 - Bring back Observation.component
7518 2015May core #809 - Immunization.protocol cardinality
7519 2015May core #810 - Immunization.protocol.does* cardinality
7521 2015May core #812 - ICD-9 system URLs
7522 2015May core #813 - URL for National Provider
7524 2015May core #815 - URL for NDC
7525 2015May core #816 - MedicationStatement.status definitions
7527 2015May core #818 - Communication.party role type not known?
7528 2015May core #819 - DocumentManifest.recipient role type not known?
7529 2015May core #820 - ElementDefinition should support quaantities too
7530 2015May core #821 - remove ElementDefinition.binding.name
7534 2015May core #825 - remove page toc
7535 2015May core #826 - change driver's license to naming systems
7536 2015May core #827 - Document xml:lang system URI
7537 2015May core #828 - fix json description
7538 2015May core #829 - sort out xml atrribute whitespace
7539 2015May core #830 - PATCH operation
7540 2015May core #831 - Fetch by profile
7541 2015May core #832 - Simply conditional create header
7542 2015May core #833 - registry URLS
7543 2015May core #834 - include transitiveness
7544 2015May core #835 - improve tranasction documentation
7545 2015May core #836 - transaction and base interaction
7547 2015May core #838 - Observation.value= true|false
7549 2015May core #840 - MedicationAdministration.dosage.method duplication
7550 2015May core #841 - AllergyIntolerance negation
7551 2015May core #842 - Current Problem List
7552 2015May core #843 - Spelling error in 1.23.6.3
7553 2015May core #844 - Spelling error in 1.23.6.11
7554 2015May core #845 - Spelling error in 6.21.6
7555 2015May core #846 - Spelling error in 6.21.7
7556 2015May core #847 - Missing entries in table in section 6.21.7.1
7557 2015May core #848 - Spelling error in
7558 2015May core #849 - militaryservice extension isn't useful
7564 2015May core #855 - AuditEvent.event value set is a mess
7565 2015May core #856 - Fix link
7566 2015May core #857 - Use the correct term for the AuditEvent.object.sensitivity. This should be AuditEvent.object.confidentiality.
7572 2015May core #863 - Explain business-specific details of update
7574 2015May core #865 - Add conformance keywords to allow more precision and improve testability. "S" for mandatory is insufficient.
7575 2015May core #866 - Support profiling a profile
7581 2015May core #872 - How do we specify an "active" or "resolved" problem?
7582 2015May core #873 - How do we specify an "active" or "resolved" allergy?
7583 2015May core #874 - We need a status to specify whether the med is "active" vs. "discontinued" meds?
7585 2015May core #876 - GMDN FDA guidance: http://www.fda.gov/downloads/MedicalDevices/DeviceRegulationandGuidance/GuidanceDocuments/UCM369248.pdf
7587 2015May core #878 - body site is overly complicated (Observation)
7588 2015May core #879 - body site is overly complicated (Procedure)
7589 2015May core #880 - body site is overly complicated (Condition)
7590 2015May core #881 - Require GMDN as device kind
7591 2015May core #882 - Don't allow local/proprietary codes
7592 2015May core #883 - This binding strengths would allow for gaps in value sets to persist.
7600 2015May core #891 - Wording should be updated to reflect the appropriate SNOMED CT concept.
7601 2015May core #892 - Wording should be updated to reflect the appropriate SNOMED CT concept.
7608 2015May core #899 - Typo
7609 2015May core #900 - The definition is ambiguous. What does "nominated care provider" mean? Is it the primary care provider?
7610 2015May core #901 - Make managing organization 0..*?
7613 2015May core #904 - How is encounter diagnosis handled?
7614 2015May core #905 - Condition.encounter -> firstEncounter
7615 2015May core #906 - If wish to capture date first asserted, should add a sibling attributed called dateFirstAsserted.
7617 2015May core #908 - Is Working vs. Confirmed in the 80%?
7618 2015May core #909 - Please clarify when/how Range is supposed to be used for Condition.range, abatement
7620 2015May core #911 - Are Condition.stage, evidence, dueTo and occurredFollowing in the 80%?
7621 2015May core #912 - Aren't these all similar items? Shouldn't they all be called target or detail?
7622 2015May core #913 - Allow structures in notes, make 0..*
7626 2015May core #917 - ContactPoint should provide a 'rank' attribute
7629 2015May core #920 - Suggest renaming to 'bodySite' or 'affectedSite'
7630 2015May core #921 - Suggest renaming to 'targetBodySite'. There may be other body sites associated with procedure (e.g., approachBodySite)
7631 2015May core #922 - Procedure.device -> targetDevice
7633 2015May core #924 - Procedure has evolved since ProcedureRequest was drafted. Suggest re-aligning the two resources to account for changes in one, relevant to the other.
7634 2015May core #925 - Procedure.notes is 0..1. ProcedureRequest.notes is 0..*. Suggest updating both resources based on comment number 19.
7636 2015May core #927 - Should 'applies' be renamed to 'physiologicallyRelevant[x]'. While short names are good, they must also be more descriptive.
7639 2015May core #930 - What's difference between has component and has member?
7640 2015May core #931 - Align prescription.status with other resources (e.g. Planned, proposed)
7647 2015May core #938 - Recommend renaming to administrationSite
7650 2015May core #941 - Typo
7651 2015May core #942 - Need to categroize re-admissions
7652 2015May core #943 - Extra 'is'.
7653 2015May core #944 - Bindings aren't mutually exclusive
7654 2015May core #945 - Dietary preference to 0..*
7655 2015May core #946 - Recommend renaming this to referralRequestFulfilled
7659 2015May core #950 - Where are the present-on-admission diagnoses?
7660 2015May core #951 - Why is this 0...1? Are all the other discharge diagnoses supposed to be elsewhere, e.g., under reason?
7662 2015May core #953 - How is a diagnostic report not a diagnostic report?
7663 2015May core #954 - Explain most common types of data exchange
7669 2015May core #960 - Reading through the resource description, it's still unclear how to represent an appointment request. Please clarify.
7670 2015May core #961 - Differentiate ReferralRequest and AppointmentRequest
7672 2015May core #963 - Please populate the actual value set or at least provide a good set of examples based on the logical specification of the value set.
7678 2015May core #969 - The text says the contextType shall always be populated, but the definition has it as optional
7679 2015May core #970 - Please update use case. From a clinical perspective performing a CT scan for further investigation of an elevated PSA level would be unusual.
7681 2015May core #972 - In three cases Retrieve URL maps to the DICOM attribute (0008,1190). Do we really neet 4 Retrieve URLs for the ImagingObjectSelection resource?
7682 2015May core #973 - Need to reference key images too
7684 2015May core #975 - Need to distinguish pathologist from technologist comments
7687 2015May core #978 - Add authorization qualifier to 'history'
7693 2015May core #984 - Who or what should sign a bundle and how is this used? RBAC? What happens if a transaction is not signed?
7694 2015May core #985 - Summary says 9 mandatory elements, but only see 1
7696 2015May core #987 - Please write this section.
7702 2015May core #993 - Can signature be captured by blob?
7729 2015May core #1020 - Suggest updating the name of this grouping so it does not conflict with the proper grouping for Medications and Immunizations.
7731 2015May core #1022 - Possible additional text for improved understanding.
7732 2015May core #1023 - Clarification
7733 2015May core #1024 - Missing attribute?
7734 2015May core #1025 - Suggest update definition.
7735 2015May core #1026 - Clarification
7736 2015May core #1027 - Seeking clarification.
7737 2015May core #1028 - Suggest adding more info in the comment.
7739 2015May core #1030 - If a system wants to communicate the manufacturer, brand, form, packaging, etc., they Should use the full Medication Resource.
7743 2015May core #1034 - Suggest updating this introduction text and fixing the link to the example SNOMED CT value set.
7744 2015May core #1035 - Suggested edit removed parens.
7745 2015May core #1036 - Fix typo
7746 2015May core #1037 - Fix the link
7750 2015May core #1071 - Rationalize the design of Provenance Resource and decouple from AuditEvent.
7751 2015May core #1072 - Replace Provenance extension
7753 2015May core #1074 - The use of the DocumentReference.confidentiality element is not conformant with the HCS requirements on Security Labels. This needs to be fixed.
7757 2015May core #1078 - Add David Hays excellent description of the Operations Framework to the top of operations.html.
7759 2015May core #1080 - It is not clear where CORE extensions begin, DAF extensions begin and QICore extensions begin
7760 2015May core #1081 - Add dependsOn element as an input Parameter with parts, and product as an output Parameter with parts.
7761 2015May core #1082 - Allow ConceptMap/$translate to have multiple outcomes
7765 2015May core #1086 - Harmonize AllergyIntollerance.event, Contraindication and Immunization.reaction
7779 2015May core #1100 - Epub is corrupted
7782 2015May core #1103 - Default cardinality of ElementDefintion min and max is undefined
7785 2015May core #1106 - Make sections of the full table of contents expandable/contractible
7786 2015May core #1107 - Need best-practice documentation for creating profiles
7787 2015May core #1108 - Need to create and document processes for achieving interoperability using FHIR
7788 2015May core #1109 - The normative information on a profile needs to be separable from the rest of FHIR
7795 2015May core #1117 - In profiles, a better way to constrain resource references is needed.
7796 2015May core #1118 - No way to restrict Resource(Any)
7797 2015May core #1119 - Concept look up operation may duplicate functionality
7799 2015May core #1121 - Need to list complete rules of what is allowed/not allowed for overrides in derived profiles (cardinality, type, etc.)
7800 2015May core #1122 - Tools aren't checking cardinality alignment
7801 2015May core #1123 - Need to list complete rules of what is allowed/not allowed for overrides in derived profiles with respect to binding and conformance strength.
7802 2015May core #1124 - Tools aren't checking binding strength alignment
7804 2015May core #1126 - Better documentation and examples for extensions both simple primitive and more complex structures.
7851 2015May core #1170 - Condition.clinicalStatus HL7v2 mapping
7854 2015May core #1174 - Encounter.type HL7v2 mapping
7855 2015May core #1175 - Condition.asserter definition clarification
7856 2015May core #1176 - Introducing HL7 FHIR page needs to update its Patient example
7857 2015May core #1177 - Base Resource Definition page has a misspelled word (resource)
7858 2015May core #1178 - Patient Cause of Death
7859 2015May core #1179 - Condition.dateAsserted definition clarification
7864 2015May core #1184 - Condition.clinicalStatus should not convey both record status (in error) and confirmation Status (working, confirmed, refuted)
7866 2015May core #1186 - Add comments or notes to the Immunization resource
7867 2015May core #1187 - Add a record status to communicate active, in error, cancelled
7868 2015May core #1188 - Add Encounter to Risk Assessment
7870 2015May core #1190 - Add Goal.Informant
7873 2015May core #1193 - Period dates in the future
7874 2015May core #1194 - Patient.careProvider HL7v2 mapping
7875 2015May core #1195 - Appointment.reason HL7v2 mapping
7876 2015May core #1196 - Questionnaire.name
7878 2015May core #1198 - Attachment.contentType has conflicting documentation
7883 2015May core #1203 - Add encounter to list
7884 2015May core #1204 - Add Goal.category
7885 2015May core #1205 - Add Goal.startDate
7886 2015May core #1206 - Communication support for phone calls
7887 2015May core #1207 - Immunization.date optional
7888 2015May core #1208 - Encounter.participant definition
7889 2015May core #1209 - Using Codes in Resources typo correction
7891 2015May core #1211 - Search-specific page needs to clarify what URL POST should be supported against.
7892 2015May core #1212 - Under “identity”, it states that if ports differ, the identity of the resource differs, but specifically mentions that http is equivalent to https. This conflicts.
7894 2015May core #1214 - Rename AllergyIntolerance.event
7895 2015May core #1215 - "related things" to "Related identifiers or resources associated with the DocumentReference"
7896 2015May core #1216 - Encounter Status Management typos
7897 2015May core #1217 - Should immunization be searchable by subject since there is no subject parameter (if yes, should AllergyIntollerance be searchable by subject?)
7898 2015May core #1218 - More clarification is needed around how to query for a subset of observations (vitals, labs, social history, etc.).
7902 2015May core #1222 - Clarify the purpose of FHIR Core Profiles
7903 2015May core #1223 - Clarify boundary and relationships between Communication and Encounter
7906 2015May core #1226 - Encounter condition relationship
7907 2015May core #1227 - RESTful special characters
7908 2015May core #1228 - Add AllergyIntolerance.severity
7909 2015May core #1229 - Flag Summary Search broken hyperlink
7911 2015May core #1231 - MedicationStatement updates
7912 2015May core #1232 - More timing examples
7913 2015May core #1233 - MedicationStatement.status clarification
7914 2015May core #1234 - IV Infusion timing
7915 2015May core #1235 - These concepts need to be split. CRFs is a reserved word in context to clinical trial, data collection.
7921 2015May core #1241 - Require 403 Response for Unauthorized Access.
7924 2015May core #1244 - Clarify content-location for Reads without Versioning support
7925 2015May core #1245 - Clarification on Resource + OperationOutcome responses
7926 2015May core #1246 - Remove support for conditional updates.
7927 2015May core #1247 - Remove support for conditional deletes.
7928 2015May core #1248 - Remove support for conditional creates.
7929 2015May core #1249 - Make version metadata support on Creates conditional on version support by servers
7931 2015May core #1251 - Further clarification for variant searches within compartments
7932 2015May core #1252 - Make Etag support for Conformance optional
7933 2015May core #1253 - Remove Transaction requirement for History interaction
7934 2015May core #1254 - Remove SHOULD stipulation for Server Content Manipulation
7935 2015May core #1255 - Transaction Integrity Guidelines in Read and Search
7941 2015May core #1261 - Unclear wording in field requirements in ReferralRequest
7944 2015May core #1264 - Change Asynchronous Operation execution to use Callback URLs
7946 2015May core #1266 - Clarify Document Immutability for Indirect Resource References
7953 2015May core #1273 - Only support POST for FHIR RESTful Search
7954 2015May core #1274 - Remove _language query parameter support
7955 2015May core #1275 - Modifiers should modify content, not names.
7957 2015May core #1277 - Alternative suggestion for Date Ranges
7961 2015May core #1281 - Modify Name of Substance.Type Property
7962 2015May core #1282 - Add class property tosubstance.
7968 2015May core #1288 - Limit Scope of Composition Resource to Documents
7971 2015May core #1291 - Overlap of elements in DocumentReference and Provenance
7972 2015May core #1292 - add code for 'legalAuthentuicator
7973 2015May core #1293 - The value set for .entity.type is listed as Required and is composed of FHIR resources, I think this is an error and should be "extensible"
7974 2015May core #1294 - Add organization to reference types
7975 2015May core #1295 - Add 'entity' and 'entitytype' as query parameters for provenance.
7976 2015May core #1296 - Add option for a receiver to send responses to mailbox endpoint of the source
7980 2015May core #1300 - The phrase literal isn't used until the "Business Identifier" section and it's unclear whether the spec is referring to id or identifier.
7981 2015May core #1301 - Typo
7982 2015May core #1302 - A simple example, or reference to search, on howto acces by business identifier rather than literal resource id might help the new reader.
7983 2015May core #1303 - Please spell PI out. Protected information?
7984 2015May core #1304 - Does this mean OperationOutcome .issue.severity cannot = error? Why?
7985 2015May core #1305 - Typo
7986 2015May core #1306 - If possible, add link also.
7988 2015May core #1312 - Did you consider creating a diagram for this section?
7989 2015May core #1313 - Which status corresponds to admitted?
7990 2015May core #1314 - Clarify search returns
7991 2015May core #1315 - Does including this in a ballot upgrade the status to proposed? Where can folks track the discusision on this resource?
7992 2015May core #1316 - The examples in other spots are very helpful
7993 2015May core #1317 - The examples in other spots are very helpful
7994 2015May core #1318 - How did the authors decide to include 'to 2 significant figures'? In the next row it states 'to 4 significant figures'.
7995 2015May core #1319 - Allow a codeableConcept in addition to the ability to reference Medication Resource. It's very common to just record the medication code.
7997 2015May core #1321 - Please add an example.
7998 2015May core #1322 - The other sections use the first sentence to define the parameter -- would be great to follow pattern here.
7999 2015May core #1323 - Just trying to highlight difference with parallel sentences.
8001 2015May core #1325 - Typo
8002 2015May core #1326 - Add mode parameters as a value set.
8003 2015May core #1327 - Add examples for FHIR operations
8004 2015May core #1328 - Add example for code:in
8013 2015May core #1338 - When would you ever record a MedicationStatement without a patient?
8014 2015May core #1339 - Where would you put a free text SIG? Please include guidance somewhere on this page: /medicationstatement-definitions.html#MedicationStatement.note
8015 2015May core #1340 - Did you consider allowing a link between MedicationPrescriptions when the status is superceded?
8019 2015May core #1344 - Typo
8020 2015May core #1345 - Please add detail on when you expect to just use the MedicationPrescription.dispense vs the full MedicationDispense resource.
8022 2015May core #1347 - The value set appears to be route codes. Please update to be medication codes. Linked to the page from Medication.code: /medication.html
8023 2015May core #1348 - How did you decided to include this field? Isn't this available through the Medication.code and/or Medication.package?
8024 2015May core #1349 - Not clear what framework is referenced here?
8026 2015May core #1351 - Clarify resource inclusion in document bundle
8027 2015May core #1352 - How would a stylesheet render a document unsafe if it doesn’t alter the presentation? Is a common stylesheet supplied?
8028 2015May core #1353 - Link to "Profile Tags" is incorrect - takes you to compartment based access Why wouldn't you use the meta tag in the composition resource?
8032 2015May core #1357 - Code inconsistent
8034 2015May core #1359 - Occurrence misspelling
8041 2015May core #1366 - Add "and extended with metadata in the HL7 Value Set Definition specification"
8042 2015May core #1367 - Do not understand the use case driving this, nor the need for the recursive containment. Remove.
8043 2015May core #1368 - Change Resource Contraindication to DetectedIssue
8044 2015May core #1369 - effective date range for the communication
8045 2015May core #1370 - Medication Prescription Status Values
8046 2015May core #1371 - Add URI for NDC (National Drug Code)
8047 2015May core #1372 - Add UIR for NPI (National Provider ID)
8049 2015May core #1374 - Support XHTML narrative in extensions
8051 2015May core #1376 - Link broken
8053 2015May core #1378 - Link broken
8054 2015May core #1434 - Why is the patient reference called patient in some resources and subject in others? Should be consistent where possible.
8055 2015May core #1435 - Typo
8056 2015May core #1436 - Typo
8057 2015May core #1437 - Make Composition.class and DocumentReference.class extensions
8058 2015May core #1438 - Make clear that Procedure.device includes implanted devices
8060 2015May core #1440 - Re-word for clarity
8061 2015May core #1441 - MedicationFormalRepresentation - Link to valueset for medication codes points to value set contents for route of administration.
8062 2015May core #1442 - MedicationForm - Link to valueset for medication codes points to value set contents for route of administration.
8063 2015May core #1443 - MedicationContainer - Link to valueset for medication codes points to value set contents for route of administration.
8064 2015May core #1444 - Medication.code - Reference points to value set contents for route of administration.
8065 2015May core #1445 - Medication.product.form- Reference points to value set contents for route of administration.
8066 2015May core #1446 - Medication.package.container - Reference points to value set contents for route of administration.
8067 2015May core #1447 - medicine -> medication
8074 2015May core #1454 - Concerns for FamilyMemberHistory
8079 2015May core #1461 - More structured approach to conformance resource
8080 2015May core #1462 - FHIR section 6.16.3 does not describe all UML classes
8081 2015May core #1463 - The concept of profile needs further consolidation
8082 2015May core #1464 - What is difference between a profile and implementation guide
8086 Create best practice wording on how to deal with large scale OID URI strategy
8102 Fix description of Timing datatype components: frequency and frequencyMax
8105 DocumentReference.format needs to be type Codeing
8107 Update the definition of "status" for the MedicationStatement7913
8110 When "To many codes to display (>10000)" , show *some* of them
8111 Clarify description of OperationDefinition.idempotent
8112 Recommend adding 'On-Hold' to MedicationStatement.status
8113 Need additional documentation on List resource about List semantics
8114 FamilyMemberHistory.deceased[x] documentation typo
8116 "Example" appears on the description of the Condition-Category valueset even though the values are required if used
8118 Correct typos in Service Root URL
8120 Consider Location.status "present"
8121 Allow additional search results when an advanced search algorithm is available
8122 Definition of neutered only covers male animals
8123 AuditEvent constraints are too tight
8124 Clinical Resource categories
8125 2015May daf #5 - Missing Concept Display Name
8128 2015May daf #26 - Expand value set
8129 2015May daf #27 - Profile title suggestion
8130 2015May daf #28 - Profile title suggestion
8136 2015May daf #36 - Profile title suggestion
8137 2015May daf #45 - Profile title suggestion
8138 2015May daf #48 - Duplicate Section Titles
8142 2015May daf #96 - Modify Content Search Parameters
8143 2015May daf #106 - MedicationPrescription.dispense.numberOfRepeatsAllowed
8146 2015May daf #166 - Provide wording to distinguish severity & criticality
8147 2015May daf #167 - Notes should be 0..* rather than 0..1
8150 2015May daf #181
8154 2015May daf #192 - Incorrect encoding of units in SCT
8155 2015May daf #210
8156 2015May daf #211 - Broken link: http://www.hl7.org/FHIR/2015May/QICoreMedicationCodes.html#1.23.2.1.2088
8158 Brokent Link on extensibility Page.
8159 word clarify
8160 Procedure missing value sets
8162 "Complete Conformance Statement" is incomplete
8163 Transaction processing sequence should reflect bundle entry sequence
8164 allow batch delete for conditional DELETE operation if multiple match
8165 2015May core #975b - Add authorization qualifier to 'read'
8166 Order should have a search parameter "identifier"
8167 What to do when I encounter unknown elements in a FHIR payload?
8168 Small typo in ConceptMap detailed description
8171 Profile HTML pages should have default values from base resources grayed out if missing in differential
8172 transaction-operation coding system doesn't correspond to transaction-operation value set
8174 Typo on REST/API page
8175 xsd:decimal precludes implied precision
8176 Typo on REST/API page, conformance operation
8177 change administrationinstructions to administrationinstruction (remove s)
8178 fix dangling references to web categories in security labels page
8179 also change .scheduled to schedule for consistency (remove d)
8180 schedule[x] (dateTime|Period|Timing) can be just schedule (Timing)
8183 Add mode of encounter
8184 Add reference to Condition
8185 Change DO .item.code and DR .name valueset binding to Example
8186 Identifier Type needs to use internally defined codes
8187 Correct Language about outcome of translation operation
8188 ConceptMap structure doesn't make sense
8189 Dead link to Profile Tags
8190 BindingStrength of FamilyMemberHistory.condition.outcome is UNKNOWN
8194 May2015 QICore #34 - Unreadable documentation page
8196 MAY2015-QICore#61- Broken "link-to-here"
8197 MAY2015-QICore #62-63 - Show value set and strength instead of binding name
8198 MAY2015 QICore#70 - Change CommunciationRequest.orderedOn to requestedOn
8200 MAY2015-QICore#84 - Null values for modifying attributes?
8202 Questionnaire.group.question missing validation
8203 The MedicationPrescription resource does not specifically state that it includes the ability to order total parenteral nutrition.
8204 URI for Medical Device Codes defined in ISO 11073-10101 is wrong
8210 2015MAY QICore#85 Goal.patient cardinality
8216 Make clear separation of recommendation and plan in CarePlan
8220 Add unavailable as list empty reason
8222 Device Scope nad Usage needs editing
8226 ValueSet.url should be ValueSet.uri
8228 How to represent a range of infusion rates?
8230 Display for filter-operator "=" code is " "
8232 Add ImagingStudy element to ImagingObjectSelection
8233 Add searchRevInclude to Conformance
8234 What are "the standard search parameters"
8235 Return behaviour of named queries: Bundle or Parameters
8236 terminology system URL syntax
8238 MedicationAdministration.dosage.rate clarification
8239 fix typo in updates page
8244 2015May daf #104 - Update Data Types Timing.code value set
8245 2015May daf #94 - Add preferred binding to condition.severity
8246 Signature.who can have every dataType in fhir-single.xsd
8247 Invariants not showing up on Element
8248 CliniciansonFHIR: Care Plan status value set
8249 CliniciansonFHIR: Care Plan reference Care Plan
8252 CliniciansonFHIR: Care Plan roles
8254 CliniciansonFHIR: Goal - link to goal observation
8256 CliniciansonFHIR: Goal Status Value
8258 iniciansonFHIR: Goal with computable < and >
8261 Procedure Resource need to reference referral
8262 2015May daf #50 - FHIR Version Number
8263 2015May daf #54 -Title: Extension: Data Absent Reason
8265 ValueSet.compose.include should have codes or filters, but not both
8270 ValueSet observation-values has no codes as defined
8271 Value set specimen-collection-priority references nonsensical code system www.example.com
8272 CarePlan Definition - how zero or more providers in a team with the person/patient intend to guide care.
8277 Add a value for Clinical Research Sponsor to Organization type Value Set
8281 Rename ProcedureRequest.timing[x] to scheduled[x]
8283 Typos on Inter-Version Compatibilty page
8284 Profile vs StructureDefinition on Conformance rules
8285 Profiling examples are still DSTU1
8286 Slicing entry needs to repeat full definition, not only root
8287 Profile to StructureDefinition
8288 Profile still used as example
8289 Typo in Life Cycle page
8290 Typo in narrative page
8291 Typo overview clinical page
8293 Typo in overview page
8295 Typo on profiling page
8296 New explanation for discriminator
8297 Typo in references page
8298 Typo on references page
8300 unclear about language tag on resource page
8301 Typo on updates page
8303 Valueset expansion in parameters clarification
8306 Change binding of EnteralRouteOfAdministration from required to extensible
8307 Canonical url name clash "http://hl7.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/cda-inFulFillmentOf"
8308 Add FMM gradings, and give all resources a FMM level
8309 Constraints can be used to constrain extensions too
8310 Constraining to max=1 in profile loses information
8311 Small errors in StructureDefinitions for primitives
8313 Change terminology for AllergyIntolerance.type
8314 Logical table icon for Bundle incorrect
8315 Guidance on "Care Team"
8319 adjust wording for bundle.entry.transaction.url
8321 Extensibility documentation should explain representation for primitive data types in JSON
8322 Bad Link
8323 DiagnosticReport vs Composition - How are they related/different?
8324 Add "component" to ValueSet http://hl7.org/fhir/goal-relationship-type
8325 Add reference from Communication --> CommunicationRequest
8326 Example uses an invalid element name 'dob'
8327 2015May QICore #56 - Make Procedure.status field isModifier
8328 value-set code generator creates duplicate line for the profile within the meta tag
8329 Refine explanation of $translate for non-map assertions
8333 Missing Examples for other usage identified
8337 Value set manifestation-c-cda-codes has no codes as defined
8338 Description of Condition/Problem/Diagnosis Codes off Condition.category has redundant "condition"
8339 Allow a server to specify that eTags are required for updates
8341 conformance versioning detail not consistent
8342 include the option for a client to specify whether the updated resource is to be included in a transaction response
8343 j.equivalence definition and valueset detfinition contradict each other
8345 Support MedicationPrescription.dosageInstruction.rate as a Quantity
8352 2015May QICore #65 - Copyright Statement not appearing in generated valueset HTML page
8353 Non-resource-specific pages should include responsible WG
8354 ValueSet.define should be renamed to ValueSet.codeSystem
8355 valueOrdinal should be decimal, not integer
8356 Add a note about ordinals and reference to extension on Questionnaire
8357 Extension display doesn't show cardinality for extension
8359 ATNA REST action codes do not cover DSTU2 operations
8360 Clarify Condition.code and evidence
8363 No place for a displayname in SearchParameter
8365 Relative URLs in reference search parameter
8366 "it's" vs "its"
8370 We're ambiguous about allowing relative urls for reference-type search parameters
8371 content-type=application/x-www-form-urlencoded
8372 Support multiple discharge diagnoses
8376 Encounter participant type value set - add addtl V3 ParticipationType codes
8379 Observation indirect target is confusing
8381 Extend OrganizationType to include other commercial types
8382 Incorrect code in patient-example.xml
8386 LOINC copyright query should not allow "All" as a value
8388 doc-typecodes filter value for LOINC should match case with LOINC db
8389 Create codes in special value code system for "L" (below detection limit) and "U" (above detection limit)
8393 Operations defined on profiles do not work
8394 Conformance.security search param path is wrong
8395 Error First child element must be of type... when defining a nested complex type extension
8396 json-edge-cases.json is invalid
8397 MedAdmin clarifications needed
8399 observation-methods includes an invalid filter for LOINC
8401 Add ConceptMap search parameter for sourceUri
8403 Need 21090 ordinal extension on Coding
8407 Add AllergyIntolerance.onset
8408 Add identifier field to search parameters for Procedure resource
8416 Remove batch operations now that we have a batch interaction
8417 Concept Designation Use binding - clarify SCT licensing issues
8418 Add Period to Group Characteristic
8419 adjust binding strength of DocumentReference value sets
8421 Conflicting advide in ValueSet expansion and define/compose
8423 Care Plan Status missing draft and cancelled(or similar)
8426 What is the effect of operations on _history?
8427 Custodian of a Resource should be accessible through Provenance
8429 $everything operation support _include directive?
8430 Clarify how non-transaction/batch Bundle posts work when sent to the base URL
8431 add Signature to the datatype graphic on the top of the datatype page
8432 Add Encounter to MedicationStatement
8433 Add "logical" to StructureDefinition.kind
8434 Document content expectations too tight
8437 Remove Social Security Number from the Identifier type value set and improve definition
8438 Add identifier systems to the system list
8439 Add a value set for yes/no/don't know (common questionnaire combination)
8440 Change references from Supply to SupplyRequest
8441 Provide support for a CodeableConcept for answer to question
8444 Test Script should note relationship to other resources
8446 typo in narrative for mode = create
8449 OperationOutcome.issue.code is either extendable CodeableConcept or not Code - Prefer extendable
8450 OperationOutcome.issue.location is unfriendly to JSON based applications only using HTTP Get parameters
8452 Add StructureDefinition.invariants
8454 Support for multiple authors and sections they've completed
8455 Provide support for other roles involved in questionnaire/assessment completion
8456 Inconsistent extension element links
8457 Add section on IP considerations
8466 Allow Communication resource to have Group as a recipient
8469 StructureDefinition notes refer to "type" instead of "contextType"
8470 Rendering of extensions includes a "Summary" with no content
8471 StructureDefinition.context needs a clearer definition
8473 When StructureDefinition.contextType is 'extension', rules are unclear
8474 Condition laterality
8479 Remove Observation.value[x] binding
8480 Rename QuestionnaireAnswers to QuestionnaireResponse
8481 Don't force use of ValueSet for questionnaire question choices
8482 Criticality terminology for AllergyIntolerance resource
8483 Update element description for ElementDefinition.type.profile
8485 published xml extensions misslng "-->'
8486 DataElement should have stringency as a search criteria
8487 Need a system url for mime type
8488 The presentation of Goal is not clear
8490 Timing documentation is out of date
8492 Searching for codes by valueset should use ValueSet.url
8494 QI-Core and CQF are two non-names for QICore
8495 HealthcareService missing Identifier search property
8497 valueset-c80-doc-classcodes should include four missing C-CDA document-level codes
8498 DocumentReference.format belongs inside content
8499 DocumentReference: "Document Formats" section is out of date
8500 Profile schematron rules do not trigger
8501 Document the "system" for Patient.communication.language
8502 MedicationAdministration rate changes
8504 change DR.requestdetail to DR.request to harmonize with PC resources
8505 add choice of ProcedureReequest and ReferralRequest to DR.requestDetail
8508 Invariant rules in profiles not populated in schematron files
8509 Conformance should have a "kind"
8510 Rename NamingSystem.type to NamingSystem.kind
8511 NamingSystem.country and .category should become useContext
8512 NamingSystem.category should have same binding as Identifier.type
8514 change name of element serviveCategory to category
8520 Duplicate profile ids overwrite
8521 Questionnaire Extension defaultasfixed - clarification
8532 The Questionnaire parameter on the $populate operation should permit by reference
8535 Search documentation missing anchor for "_security"
8539 StructureDefinition invariants mention non-existent f:type
8540 Primitive types have f:element/f:type/f:code which violates binding
8541 How interpret StructureDefinition differential?
8542 Extension example - value[x]
8543 Request multi-level extension example
8544 Duplicate search parameter "familymemberhistory-daf-FamilyMemberHistory-condition"
8547 Complex extensions not showing proper icon
8549 Reject modifiers inside complex extensions
8551 create and extension for O.refrange to allow for ...or equal to
8553 Remove Medication.name from Medication Resource
8555 Need enableWhen to work for non-answered questions too
8556 Clean up profile list
8561 Profie examples not published in IG section.
8562 Bad link generated in pubished pages to raw XML of IG-defined valuesets
8568 Need example valueset on ProcedureRequest.asNeeded[x] and indication elements
8582 Define MPI search for patient resource
8584 Erroneous warnings on path being generated by build
8586 Elements repeating in differential view
8589 QA: All properties are included in the Summary
8590 Questionnaire Summary items missing "name" of the Questionnaire
8594 ElementDefinition.type.code values not in data-type valueset
8595 add two codes to provenance-participant-role for assembler and composer
8596 profile element comments not displaying in element details
8597 clarification for identifer.system
8598 typo for comparators in inclusive extension -fix = instead of =< and =>
8599 AllergyIntolerance.status value set
8605 Datatype Boolean - explanation required
8607 Don't require use of data elements for $populate w/ SDC
8613 change EPUB link to readable version of FHIR Book
8606 Clarify description of slicing, not limited to element lists
8622 validation.zip's dataelements.xml contains duplicate fullUrl and canonical urls
8623 validation.zip conceptmap.xml contains incorrect canonical url
8624 Clarify that Subscription.criteria should not have a leading "/"
8625 Fix missing Provenance HL7 Extension
8626 build not expanding Provenance valueset v3 Value Set ProvenanceEventCurrentState
8628 some slice members lack f:name
8629 The schema for Parameter resource is missing.
8631 Extensions missing in differential view
8633 Description of string search w/ :exact is slightly ambiguous
8635 Search Parameter Crossmap w/ Data Types Missing All Number Types
8636 Quantity Search Needs Clarification Regarding Quantities With Comparators
8637 Quantity Search Needs Clarification Regarding Value Semantics

FHIR Breaking changes between DSTU 2 ballot and final

Navigation menu

Personal tools

Namespaces

Variants

Views

More

Search

Navigation

groups

meetings

general

Tools