This wiki has undergone a migration to Confluence found Here
<meta name="googlebot" content="noindex">

Difference between revisions of "September 2009 WGM Agenda CBCC Tuesday Q4"

From HL7Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 20: Line 20:
  
 
==Updates==
 
==Updates==
* '''Healthcare, Community Services and Provider Directory – Ballot 1 Normative'''
+
*'''Healthcare, Community Services and Provider Directory – Ballot Reconciliation'''
 +
**Ballot 1 Normative
 
**Only three comments on the entire ballot.
 
**Only three comments on the entire ballot.
**Line 6 – negative comment related to taking out references to HL7
+
***Line 6 – negative comment related to taking out references to HL7
 +
**'''Motion 1:''' Max – Motion to ask SOA for decision on what action to take on line 6 with a deadline for action two weeks following this working group meeting
 +
***Galen seconded
 +
***'''Vote:'''
 +
****2 Abstained
 +
****0 Opposed
 +
****12 Approved
 +
**'''Motion 2:''' Max – Motion to approve the ballot reconciliation
 +
***Pat seconded
 +
***'''Vote:'''
 +
****2 Abstained
 +
****0 Opposed
 +
****12 Approved
  
*'''Motion 1:''' Max – Motion to ask SOA for decision on what action to take on line 6 with a deadline for action two weeks following this working group meeting
+
*'''Composite Privacy Consent Directive DAM - Ballot Reconciliation'''
**Galen seconded
+
**Second time this has been balloted
*'''Vote:'''
+
**Around 60-70 comments; lots of affirmatives
**2 Abstained
+
**Considerable discussion around the use of the word Evaluation in the conceptual system "Consent Directive Evaluation Engine".  Steve's recommendation is to change it to "Consent Directive Decision Engine"
**0 Opposed
+
***Evaluation speaks to a more open ended process rather than a computed process - options are well defined and therefore Decision
**12 Approved
+
***Consent Directive Decision function is closer to the ISO definition of an Access Control Decision function
 
+
***Group agreed that Decision is a widely used term and that this change would not be substantive, therefore it was accepted as persuasive and changed to "Decision Engine"
*'''Motion 2:''' Max – Motion to approve the ballot reconciliation
+
**Reviewed up to line 48 in this quarter
**Pat seconded
+
**'''Motion''' to approve the comments through line 48
*'''Vote:'''
+
***Seconded
**2 Abstained
+
***'''Vote:'''
**0 Opposed
+
****2 Abstained
**12 Approved
+
****0 Opposed
 +
****12 Approved

Revision as of 17:05, 3 October 2009

Community-Based Collaborative Care Working Group

Attendees

  1. Stephen Chu
  2. Steven Connolly
  3. Suzanne Gonzales-Webb
  4. Bruce Laidlaw
  5. Nancy LeRoy
  6. Galen Mulrooney
  7. Patrick Pyette
  8. Harry Rhodes
  9. Rob Savage
  10. Ioana Singureanu
  11. Chris Smith
  12. Sue Thompson
  13. Richard Thoreson Co-Chair
  14. Serafina Versaggi Scribe
  15. Max Walker Co-Chair

Updates

  • Healthcare, Community Services and Provider Directory – Ballot Reconciliation
    • Ballot 1 Normative
    • Only three comments on the entire ballot.
      • Line 6 – negative comment related to taking out references to HL7
    • Motion 1: Max – Motion to ask SOA for decision on what action to take on line 6 with a deadline for action two weeks following this working group meeting
      • Galen seconded
      • Vote:
        • 2 Abstained
        • 0 Opposed
        • 12 Approved
    • Motion 2: Max – Motion to approve the ballot reconciliation
      • Pat seconded
      • Vote:
        • 2 Abstained
        • 0 Opposed
        • 12 Approved
  • Composite Privacy Consent Directive DAM - Ballot Reconciliation
    • Second time this has been balloted
    • Around 60-70 comments; lots of affirmatives
    • Considerable discussion around the use of the word Evaluation in the conceptual system "Consent Directive Evaluation Engine". Steve's recommendation is to change it to "Consent Directive Decision Engine"
      • Evaluation speaks to a more open ended process rather than a computed process - options are well defined and therefore Decision
      • Consent Directive Decision function is closer to the ISO definition of an Access Control Decision function
      • Group agreed that Decision is a widely used term and that this change would not be substantive, therefore it was accepted as persuasive and changed to "Decision Engine"
    • Reviewed up to line 48 in this quarter
    • Motion to approve the comments through line 48
      • Seconded
      • Vote:
        • 2 Abstained
        • 0 Opposed
        • 12 Approved