This wiki has undergone a migration to Confluence found Here
<meta name="googlebot" content="noindex">

Difference between revisions of "AID 201406 Agenda"

From HL7Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(27 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
This is the agenda of the [[AID]] out-of-cycle meeting to be held in Amsterdam, the Netherlands. <br/>
+
[[category:RIMBAA Minutes]]These are the minutes of the [[AID]] out-of-cycle meeting held in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, on June 3rd 2014.
−
The scope of the meeting is the use of HL7/IHE/DICOM/OpenEHR/terminology and other healthIT standards, and the exchange of best practices and architectures related to the implementation of these standards in software applications.
 
  
−
*Date: June 3rd, 2014. 09:00-17:30
+
Summary: this meeting ended up being focused on OpenEHR implementations - and how one can implement IHE/HL7 interfaces on top of an OpenEHR based CDR.  
−
*Language: All Presentations will be in English
 
−
*Location: Furore offices, Amsterdam, @ Bos en Lommerplein 280, 1055 RW Amsterdam (Directions: [http://www.furore.com/contact/ in Dutch], and/or [https://maps.google.nl/maps?q=Bos+en+Lommerplein+280,+1055+RW+Amsterdam Google Maps])
 
−
*Registration: There is no registration fee. The size of the meeting room is limited however, so we urge you to please sign up by adding your name to the tail end of this page.
 
  
−
==Agenda==
+
==Amsterdam AID Minutes==
−
#Administrative agenda items
+
{| border="1" cellpadding="2" cellspacing="0" style="background:#f0f0f0;" width="100%"
 +
|-
 +
!width=”35%”|Workgroup
 +
!width="20%"| Date/Time
 +
!width="15%"| Location
 +
!width="30%"| Chair/Scribe
 +
|-
 +
|'''AID HL7 User Group'''||2014-06-03, <br/>09:00-16:30||Amsterdam, NL||Chair/Scribe: Rene Spronk
 +
|}
 +
==Attendees==
 +
#Rene Spronk, Ringholm, NL
 +
#Ewout Kramer, Furore, NL
 +
#Michael van der Zel, UMCG, NL
 +
#Jan-Marc Verlinden, Medvision360, NL
 +
#Borut Fabjan, Marand, Slovenia
 +
# , Marand, Solvenia
 +
#Fleur Kelpin, UMCG, NL
 +
#Alexander Henket, Nictiz, NL
 +
#Ian McNicoll, FreshEHR, UK
 +
#Arianne van de Wetering, Nictiz, NL
 +
#Hans Vonkeman, Furore, NL
 +
#Marten Smits, Furore, NL
 +
==Minutes==
 +
#Rene calls to order at 09:30
 +
#Administrative agenda items  
 
#*Announcements
 
#*Announcements
 +
#**Rene: I intent to capture (some of) the presentations on video, and as per our DMP I request permission from the group and from the speakers to do so.
 +
#***No objections were raised.
 
#*Aproval of the agenda
 
#*Aproval of the agenda
 +
#*'''MOTION''' To approve the minutes of the [[AID 201401 Agenda|San Antonio January 2014 WGM]]
 +
#**Approved 10-0-2(y-n-a, Ewout/Alexander)
 +
#*'''MOTION''' To approve the minutes of the [[AID 20140504 Agenda|Phoenix May 2014 WGM]]
 +
#**Approved 10-0-2(y-n-a, Ewout/Alexander)
 
#*User Groups
 
#*User Groups
 
#**Rene: at some point AID may be transformed into a fullblown HL7 User Group (HUG). At this point in time the idea is that all HL7 members (of HL7 International, or of any affiliate) will be able to participate for free. Non-members pay a fee of $100 a year, and get to attend all meetings. The $100 (EUR 70) was defined for a UG with just one annual face to face meeting in mind. On the assumption we (as AID) can nearly always use a sponsored meeting room (e.g. provided by a software vendor) the meetings costs are limited to catering costs (EUR 20-45, depending on the quality thereof).  
 
#**Rene: at some point AID may be transformed into a fullblown HL7 User Group (HUG). At this point in time the idea is that all HL7 members (of HL7 International, or of any affiliate) will be able to participate for free. Non-members pay a fee of $100 a year, and get to attend all meetings. The $100 (EUR 70) was defined for a UG with just one annual face to face meeting in mind. On the assumption we (as AID) can nearly always use a sponsored meeting room (e.g. provided by a software vendor) the meetings costs are limited to catering costs (EUR 20-45, depending on the quality thereof).  
−
#**Discussion: to define a reasonable fee structure; what to do with any surplusses/losses.
+
#**Review [[AID Transition Plan (WG to HUG)]]
−
#Implementation aspects of my own PHR (Dirk Jan van der Pol, [http://www.quli.nl Quli], NL)
+
#***A meeting fee of about EUR 30 wouldn't be an issue, it would actually show some level of commitment, and would discourage no-shows. Ewout: problem around whose bank account to use, who will do the invoicing. Rene: HL7 International doesn't wish to be involved in this. Maybe local affiliate, or some company.
−
#*Dirk Jan, akin to [http://www.ted.com/talks/dave_debronkart_meet_e_patient_dave.html e-Patient Dave] once suffered from cancer - and decided to develop his own PHR to collect and manage his own health data. Dirk Jan, unlike Dave, has a background in software development and therefore has the perfect background and motivation to develop a PHR.
+
#***Of the participants today only 3 are not members of HL7 nor an affiliate.
−
#*Dirk Jan will share his background, and will subsequently focus on the challenges of trying to incorporate data from all sorts of sources in his own PHR - which meant he had to create clinical models, and resorted to a tagging mechnism in order to retrieve and associate relevant bits of data.
+
#***Ewout: I have an intrinsic motivation to 'share', having the shared information behind some 'membership only wall' doesn't motivate me to share.
−
#An OpenEHR RESTful Archetyped API (Jan-Marc Verlinden, Ralph van Etten, [http://www.medvision360.com/ Medvision360], NL)
+
#*Review/update [[AID Activities]]
 +
#**Dropped due to a lack of time
 +
#Implementation aspects of my own PHR (Dirk Jan van der Pol, [http://www.quli.nl Quli], NL)  
 +
#*Dirk Jan had to cancel his talk due to illness.
 +
#FHIR and DICOM (Ewout Kramer, Furore, see [http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Ewout_Kramer_WADO_AND_FHIR.PPTX http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Ewout_Kramer_WADO_AND_FHIR.PPTX] for slides, and the video at [https://vimeo.com/97308387 https://vimeo.com/97308387])
 +
#*Ewout took part in the SIIM hackathon, a diagnostic imaging hacking event. He will briefly present his experiences in blending RESTful DICOM approaches with FHIR.
 +
#**Ewout had no knowledge of DICOM prior to SIIM. The FHIR resource combines study/series/instance data, whereas QIDO/WADO-RS deals with those individually. Smaller issues reletaed to data types.
 +
#**First time that Ewout was in contact with respresentatives from imaging companies, FHIR resourse dev in close cooperation, they'll visit HL7 connectathons as well.
 +
#**Discussion around getting more DICOM implementers to the join these meetings? Good idea.
 +
#An OpenEHR RESTful Archetyped API (Jan-Marc Verlinden, [http://www.medvision360.com/ Medvision360], NL)  
 
#*Jan-Marc and Ralph are working on a RESTful API (see http://www.medrecord.nl/medrecord-json-api/) for MEDRecord, an open source OpenEHR based application. They will show how the API is related to the back end EHR, as well as how one could create a FHIR frontend on top of this API.
 
#*Jan-Marc and Ralph are working on a RESTful API (see http://www.medrecord.nl/medrecord-json-api/) for MEDRecord, an open source OpenEHR based application. They will show how the API is related to the back end EHR, as well as how one could create a FHIR frontend on top of this API.
−
#Using an OpenEHR platform in a HL7/IHE interoperability environment (Tomaž Gornik or Borut Fabjan, [http://www.marand-thinkmed.com/ Marand])
+
#*(side note) Developed PAAS for dicom data, we found its impossible to store that mass amount of data, found non-fiber netweroks uncable for cloud storage of the data. Project at Univ. of Utrecht, used project hackathon to push the project forward. Show combined medical images (MRI and 24 channel EEG) in 3D. Philips MRI fMRI. DICOM + Philips DICOM. Two vendors related to image processing and viewing.
−
#*The Think!EHR Platform is a big-data, high-performance solution designed to store, manage, query, retrieve and exchange structured electronic health record data based on the latest release of openEHR specifications.
+
#*MEDRecord with archetyped API.
−
#*Tomaž and/or Borut will discuss some of the architectural aspects of Think!EHR and the impact of embracing OpenEHR, as well as the support for IHE/HL7 (v2,CDA,FHIR) as an interoperability interface.
+
#**Tried an XML approach (w XML db first). Queries would take up to 8 seconds, too slow.
−
#A world of models - model transformations (Michael van der Zel, [http://www.umcg.nl/ UMCG], NL)
+
#**Postgress version. MedRecord JSON API. No AQL support, not sure what query language to support, AQL not finalized yet, currently use postgress queries. Focusing on spicif queries for specific use cases, not generic query option. Query for EHRs associated with a certain patients, then query for compositions within such EHRs. OpenEHR has an API specificed in XML.
−
#*Michael has created a number of tools that help in the tranformation of models between OpenEHR, CIMI, DCM, ART-DECOR, ArchiMate, EA UML, and others. This includes the use of the MAX metadata format (kind of an XMI format) for expressing the models.
+
#**XML version is open sourced, Postgress version has not been open sourced.
−
#Teach yourself (some) FHIR (Fleur Kelpin, [http://www.umcg.nl/ UMCG], NL)
+
#*Ian: there's an interest in defining a common REST based interface for OpenEHR. We have a XML representation, JSON needs to be worked on.  
 +
#*Jan-Marc: in OpenEHR, split between communications model and knowledge system, shows HL7 VMR model (for decision support) mapping.
 +
#*Jan-Marc: no problem creating a FHIR interface. Would need mappings. Ian: it's actually not that hard. Not a surprise that they are similar.  
 +
#Teach yourself (some) FHIR (Fleur Kelpin, [http://www.umcg.nl/ UMCG], NL, see [http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Fleur_Kelpin_Teach%20yourself%20(some)%20FHIR.pdf http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Fleur_Kelpin_Teach%20yourself%20(some)%20FHIR.pdf] for slides)  
 
#*Fleur and her team have implemented a FHIR interface on top of existing services for the EHR-System and she will share her experience with doing that.
 
#*Fleur and her team have implemented a FHIR interface on top of existing services for the EHR-System and she will share her experience with doing that.
−
#''Other presentations''
+
#**Team of 5, started with FHIR on their own (didn't go to a training course). One day development project.
−
 
+
#**Use toolkit developed by Josh Mandel - developed an iPad app. Build an App on top of a new FHIR API build for their clinical data repository (called PoliPlus, which already had APIs). Also have an XDS-ish document repository. Use case: get documents for patient ID. Basic HTTP authentication, to put authentican out of scope. Spring tools. defauklt Spring serialization of POJOs different than FHIR serialization.
−
==Registrations==
+
#**Found FHIR easy to start with. FHIR vs just XML-JSON: value would be in reuse of app in multiple FHIR enabled settings. Images in FHIR (model representation) quite useful.
−
Registration is free, but the size of the room is limited. Please sign up by adding your name to the list below:
+
#Using an OpenEHR platform in a HL7/IHE interoperability environment (Borut Fabjan, [http://www.marand-thinkmed.com/ Marand], see [http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Borut_Fabjan_InterOp_ThinkEHR.pdf http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Borut_Fabjan_InterOp_ThinkEHR.pdf] for slides, and video recordings at [https://vimeo.com/97714771 https://vimeo.com/97714771] and [https://vimeo.com/97853645 https://vimeo.com/97853645])
−
#Rene Spronk, Ringholm, NL
+
#*The Think!EHR Platform is a big-data, high-performance solution designed to store, manage, query, retrieve and exchange structured electronic health record data based on the latest release of openEHR specifications
−
#Ewout Kramer, Furore, NL
+
#*Borut will discuss some of the architectural aspects of Think!EHR and the impact of embracing OpenEHR, as well as the support for IHE/HL7 (v2,CDA,FHIR) as an interoperability interface.
−
#Dirk Jan van der Pol, Quli, NL
+
#*Borut recaps the OpenEHR model, role of templates to define a subset applicable in a particular context.
−
#Adri Burggraaff, HL7 NL, (afternoon)
+
#**AQL, query builders
−
#Michael van der Zel, UMCG, NL
+
#**Metaform builder
−
#Jan-Marc Verlinden, Medvision360, NL
+
#*OpenEHR CDR, went to connectathon, as a Document Repository. Also support for IHE "on domand document" proposal.
−
#Ralph van Etten, Medvision360, NL
+
#**TDS/TDD openHR document type, can be stored in XDS registry. CDA L1/L2 is a transfrom from an OpenEHR template. CDA L3 is a transform, tricky, lots of academic questions about data models,
−
#Tomaž Gornik or Borut Fabjan, Marand, Slovenia
+
#The experimental HANDI HOPD demonstrator (Ian McNicoll, Ocean Informatics, see [http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Ian_McNicoll_HANDI-HOPD.pptx http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Ian_McNicoll_HANDI-HOPD.pptx] for slides, and the video at [https://vimeo.com/97506030 https://vimeo.com/97506030])
−
#Henk Enting, MGRID, NL
+
#*The HANDI HOPD demonstrator is basically smart on FHIR on openEHR - currently using Marand think!ehr but with the aim to have multiple backends in future. Free to use.
−
#Tom de Jong, Nova Pro, NL
+
#A world of models - MAX model transformations (Michael van der Zel, [http://www.umcg.nl/ UMCG], NL, see [http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Michael_vdZel_MAX.pdf http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Michael_vdZel_MAX.pdf] for slides, and the video at [https://vimeo.com/97512611 https://vimeo.com/97512611])
−
#Fleur Kelpin, UMCG, NL
+
#*Michael has created a tool that helps in the exchanging and tranformation of models between OpenEHR, CIMI, DCM, ART-DECOR, ArchiMate, EA UML, spreadsheet and others. This is based on the use of the MAX metamodel (kind of an XMI format) for expressing the models and HL7 MAX tool.
−
#Alexander Henket, Nictiz, NL
+
#Adjournment at 16:30, next meeting in Amsterdam will be on November 27th, 2014.

Latest revision as of 07:34, 17 June 2014

These are the minutes of the AID out-of-cycle meeting held in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, on June 3rd 2014.

Summary: this meeting ended up being focused on OpenEHR implementations - and how one can implement IHE/HL7 interfaces on top of an OpenEHR based CDR.

Amsterdam AID Minutes

Workgroup Date/Time Location Chair/Scribe
AID HL7 User Group 2014-06-03,
09:00-16:30		 Amsterdam, NL Chair/Scribe: Rene Spronk

Attendees

  1. Rene Spronk, Ringholm, NL
  2. Ewout Kramer, Furore, NL
  3. Michael van der Zel, UMCG, NL
  4. Jan-Marc Verlinden, Medvision360, NL
  5. Borut Fabjan, Marand, Slovenia
  6. , Marand, Solvenia
  7. Fleur Kelpin, UMCG, NL
  8. Alexander Henket, Nictiz, NL
  9. Ian McNicoll, FreshEHR, UK
  10. Arianne van de Wetering, Nictiz, NL
  11. Hans Vonkeman, Furore, NL
  12. Marten Smits, Furore, NL

Minutes

  1. Rene calls to order at 09:30
  2. Administrative agenda items
    • Announcements
      • Rene: I intent to capture (some of) the presentations on video, and as per our DMP I request permission from the group and from the speakers to do so.
        • No objections were raised.
    • Aproval of the agenda
    • MOTION To approve the minutes of the San Antonio January 2014 WGM
      • Approved 10-0-2(y-n-a, Ewout/Alexander)
    • MOTION To approve the minutes of the Phoenix May 2014 WGM
      • Approved 10-0-2(y-n-a, Ewout/Alexander)
    • User Groups
      • Rene: at some point AID may be transformed into a fullblown HL7 User Group (HUG). At this point in time the idea is that all HL7 members (of HL7 International, or of any affiliate) will be able to participate for free. Non-members pay a fee of $100 a year, and get to attend all meetings. The $100 (EUR 70) was defined for a UG with just one annual face to face meeting in mind. On the assumption we (as AID) can nearly always use a sponsored meeting room (e.g. provided by a software vendor) the meetings costs are limited to catering costs (EUR 20-45, depending on the quality thereof).
      • Review AID Transition Plan (WG to HUG)
        • A meeting fee of about EUR 30 wouldn't be an issue, it would actually show some level of commitment, and would discourage no-shows. Ewout: problem around whose bank account to use, who will do the invoicing. Rene: HL7 International doesn't wish to be involved in this. Maybe local affiliate, or some company.
        • Of the participants today only 3 are not members of HL7 nor an affiliate.
        • Ewout: I have an intrinsic motivation to 'share', having the shared information behind some 'membership only wall' doesn't motivate me to share.
    • Review/update AID Activities
      • Dropped due to a lack of time
  3. Implementation aspects of my own PHR (Dirk Jan van der Pol, Quli, NL)
    • Dirk Jan had to cancel his talk due to illness.
  4. FHIR and DICOM (Ewout Kramer, Furore, see http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Ewout_Kramer_WADO_AND_FHIR.PPTX for slides, and the video at https://vimeo.com/97308387)
    • Ewout took part in the SIIM hackathon, a diagnostic imaging hacking event. He will briefly present his experiences in blending RESTful DICOM approaches with FHIR.
      • Ewout had no knowledge of DICOM prior to SIIM. The FHIR resource combines study/series/instance data, whereas QIDO/WADO-RS deals with those individually. Smaller issues reletaed to data types.
      • First time that Ewout was in contact with respresentatives from imaging companies, FHIR resourse dev in close cooperation, they'll visit HL7 connectathons as well.
      • Discussion around getting more DICOM implementers to the join these meetings? Good idea.
  5. An OpenEHR RESTful Archetyped API (Jan-Marc Verlinden, Medvision360, NL)
    • Jan-Marc and Ralph are working on a RESTful API (see http://www.medrecord.nl/medrecord-json-api/) for MEDRecord, an open source OpenEHR based application. They will show how the API is related to the back end EHR, as well as how one could create a FHIR frontend on top of this API.
    • (side note) Developed PAAS for dicom data, we found its impossible to store that mass amount of data, found non-fiber netweroks uncable for cloud storage of the data. Project at Univ. of Utrecht, used project hackathon to push the project forward. Show combined medical images (MRI and 24 channel EEG) in 3D. Philips MRI fMRI. DICOM + Philips DICOM. Two vendors related to image processing and viewing.
    • MEDRecord with archetyped API.
      • Tried an XML approach (w XML db first). Queries would take up to 8 seconds, too slow.
      • Postgress version. MedRecord JSON API. No AQL support, not sure what query language to support, AQL not finalized yet, currently use postgress queries. Focusing on spicif queries for specific use cases, not generic query option. Query for EHRs associated with a certain patients, then query for compositions within such EHRs. OpenEHR has an API specificed in XML.
      • XML version is open sourced, Postgress version has not been open sourced.
    • Ian: there's an interest in defining a common REST based interface for OpenEHR. We have a XML representation, JSON needs to be worked on.
    • Jan-Marc: in OpenEHR, split between communications model and knowledge system, shows HL7 VMR model (for decision support) mapping.
    • Jan-Marc: no problem creating a FHIR interface. Would need mappings. Ian: it's actually not that hard. Not a surprise that they are similar.
  6. Teach yourself (some) FHIR (Fleur Kelpin, UMCG, NL, see http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Fleur_Kelpin_Teach%20yourself%20(some)%20FHIR.pdf for slides)
    • Fleur and her team have implemented a FHIR interface on top of existing services for the EHR-System and she will share her experience with doing that.
      • Team of 5, started with FHIR on their own (didn't go to a training course). One day development project.
      • Use toolkit developed by Josh Mandel - developed an iPad app. Build an App on top of a new FHIR API build for their clinical data repository (called PoliPlus, which already had APIs). Also have an XDS-ish document repository. Use case: get documents for patient ID. Basic HTTP authentication, to put authentican out of scope. Spring tools. defauklt Spring serialization of POJOs different than FHIR serialization.
      • Found FHIR easy to start with. FHIR vs just XML-JSON: value would be in reuse of app in multiple FHIR enabled settings. Images in FHIR (model representation) quite useful.
  7. Using an OpenEHR platform in a HL7/IHE interoperability environment (Borut Fabjan, Marand, see http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Borut_Fabjan_InterOp_ThinkEHR.pdf for slides, and video recordings at https://vimeo.com/97714771 and https://vimeo.com/97853645)
    • The Think!EHR Platform is a big-data, high-performance solution designed to store, manage, query, retrieve and exchange structured electronic health record data based on the latest release of openEHR specifications
    • Borut will discuss some of the architectural aspects of Think!EHR and the impact of embracing OpenEHR, as well as the support for IHE/HL7 (v2,CDA,FHIR) as an interoperability interface.
    • Borut recaps the OpenEHR model, role of templates to define a subset applicable in a particular context.
      • AQL, query builders
      • Metaform builder
    • OpenEHR CDR, went to connectathon, as a Document Repository. Also support for IHE "on domand document" proposal.
      • TDS/TDD openHR document type, can be stored in XDS registry. CDA L1/L2 is a transfrom from an OpenEHR template. CDA L3 is a transform, tricky, lots of academic questions about data models,
  8. The experimental HANDI HOPD demonstrator (Ian McNicoll, Ocean Informatics, see http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Ian_McNicoll_HANDI-HOPD.pptx for slides, and the video at https://vimeo.com/97506030)
    • The HANDI HOPD demonstrator is basically smart on FHIR on openEHR - currently using Marand think!ehr but with the aim to have multiple backends in future. Free to use.
  9. A world of models - MAX model transformations (Michael van der Zel, UMCG, NL, see http://www.hl7.org/documentcenter/public/wg/java/20140603_Michael_vdZel_MAX.pdf for slides, and the video at https://vimeo.com/97512611)
    • Michael has created a tool that helps in the exchanging and tranformation of models between OpenEHR, CIMI, DCM, ART-DECOR, ArchiMate, EA UML, spreadsheet and others. This is based on the use of the MAX metamodel (kind of an XMI format) for expressing the models and HL7 MAX tool.
  10. Adjournment at 16:30, next meeting in Amsterdam will be on November 27th, 2014.
Retrieved from "https://wiki.hl7.org/w/index.php?title=AID_201406_Agenda&oldid=87794"