This wiki has undergone a migration to Confluence found Here
<meta name="googlebot" content="noindex">

Difference between revisions of "CIMI Telecom Minutes 2017-02-16"

From HL7Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(10 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 5: Line 5:
 
** https://global.gotomeeting.com/join/754419973 Dialin: United States : +1 (224) 501-3316 Access Code: 754-419-973
 
** https://global.gotomeeting.com/join/754419973 Dialin: United States : +1 (224) 501-3316 Access Code: 754-419-973
 
** '''More phone numbers:''' Australia: +61 2 8355 1034, Belgium: +32 (0) 28 93 7002, Canada: +1 (647) 497-9372, Denmark: +45 89 88 03 61, Netherlands: +31 (0) 208 084 055, New Zealand: +64 4 974 7243, Spain: +34 932 20 0506, Sweden: +46 (0) 853 527 818, United Kingdom: +44 (0) 330 221 0098
 
** '''More phone numbers:''' Australia: +61 2 8355 1034, Belgium: +32 (0) 28 93 7002, Canada: +1 (647) 497-9372, Denmark: +45 89 88 03 61, Netherlands: +31 (0) 208 084 055, New Zealand: +64 4 974 7243, Spain: +34 932 20 0506, Sweden: +46 (0) 853 527 818, United Kingdom: +44 (0) 330 221 0098
−
** '''Telecom Audio:''' https://1drv.ms/u/s!AlkpZJej6nh_lIN6SipbDkxhJW-rUA
+
** '''Telecom Audio:''' https://1drv.ms/u/s!AlkpZJej6nh_k7906pJl4wSDGh7sMg
−
** '''Telecom Video:''' '''TBD (Joey Coyle or Patrick Langford)'''
+
** '''Telecom Video:''' http://www.opencem.org/cimi
 
* '''Co-Chairs:''' Stan Huff, Linda Bird, Galen Mulrooney, Richard Esmond; where, quorum requires 2 co-chairs  
 
* '''Co-Chairs:''' Stan Huff, Linda Bird, Galen Mulrooney, Richard Esmond; where, quorum requires 2 co-chairs  
 
* '''REQUESTED ACTION:''' Directly edit this WIKI page or send your feedback to CIMI@lists.HL7.org with your comments, questions, suggested updates.
 
* '''REQUESTED ACTION:''' Directly edit this WIKI page or send your feedback to CIMI@lists.HL7.org with your comments, questions, suggested updates.
Line 35: Line 35:
  
 
'''Highlighted names were in attendance.'''
 
'''Highlighted names were in attendance.'''
 +
  
 
=Executive Summary=
 
=Executive Summary=
  
−
# '''2017-02-09 Action-01 (Galen): Submit Notification of Intent to Ballot Form
+
 
 +
# Galen reported inability to enter CIMI's Intent to Ballot
 +
## '''2017-02-16 Action-01 (Galen):''' Notify Lydia and
 +
## find a way to Submit Notification of Intent to Ballot
 
# Susan presented PC DCM requirements for PC Wound Assessment Project  
 
# Susan presented PC DCM requirements for PC Wound Assessment Project  
−
Richard leading STAMP task-force
+
# Richard leading STAMP task-force
−
# Patrick demonstrated OpenCimi Mind Maps
+
# Patrick demonstrated OpenCimi Mind Maps http://www.opencimi.org/model-browser
−
# Joey demonstrated OpenCEMs hierarchy capability
+
## '''Action-02 (CIMI WG:)''' Review Browser & Provide feedback to Patrick
 +
## '''Action 03 (Patrick):''' add model inheritance hierarchy
 +
# Joey demonstrated OpenCEMs hierarchy capability http://www.opencem.org/#/
 
# Gallen reported inability to enter CIMI's intent to ballot (deadline Sunday)
 
# Gallen reported inability to enter CIMI's intent to ballot (deadline Sunday)
 
# Claude presented proposed Patirnt Education structure.
 
# Claude presented proposed Patirnt Education structure.
Line 48: Line 54:
 
## Surgical Procedure
 
## Surgical Procedure
 
## Laboratory Procedure
 
## Laboratory Procedure
−
Claude presented proposed structure for Encounter
+
#Claude presented proposed structure for Encounter
 +
 
  
 
=Minutes (Annotated Agenda)=
 
=Minutes (Annotated Agenda)=
Line 60: Line 67:
 
* Record this call
 
* Record this call
 
* Agenda review
 
* Agenda review
−
* Review/Approval of Jan 26 minutes and Action Items
+
* Review/Approval of Feb 9 minutes and Action Items
−
** http://wiki.hl7.org/index.php?title=CIMI_Telecom_Minutes_2017-01-26
 
 
* Updates on active projects (standing item)
 
* Updates on active projects (standing item)
 
** Skin and wound assessments – Jay and Susan
 
** Skin and wound assessments – Jay and Susan
−
*** Finalizing the data items, value sets
+
** '''Susan explained a UML style diagram of the skin assessment classes.'''
 
** FHIM – CIMI integration – Galen
 
** FHIM – CIMI integration – Galen
 
** Harmonization of CIMI and FHIR datatypes - Richard
 
** Harmonization of CIMI and FHIR datatypes - Richard
 
** Graph/STAMP modeling paradigm – Richard
 
** Graph/STAMP modeling paradigm – Richard
 +
*** Rob McClure has been invited to participate
 
** Conversion of CIMI archetypes to FHIR logical models to FHIR profiles – Claude
 
** Conversion of CIMI archetypes to FHIR logical models to FHIR profiles – Claude
 
** BMM parsing and serialization code – Claude
 
** BMM parsing and serialization code – Claude
 
** Creating ADL models from CEMs – Joey  
 
** Creating ADL models from CEMs – Joey  
−
** LOKI – Patrick  
+
** LOKI – Patrick
 +
** CIMI Website – Patrick
 +
*** Patrick has compiled all of the models from the recent HL7 ballot and made them viewable in the CIMI browser.  It was very nicely done.
 +
*** Folks suggested the addition of a view that would show the derivation hierarchy for the models, and other enhancements.
 
** Conclusions from the CIMI FHIM Task Force – Stan Huff
 
** Conclusions from the CIMI FHIM Task Force – Stan Huff
 
*** Stan will update the document based on previous discussion, and bring the document back for review and approval in a few weeks (still not done)
 
*** Stan will update the document based on previous discussion, and bring the document back for review and approval in a few weeks (still not done)
 +
*** '''As noted by Stephen Hufnagel, this item has been overtaken by events. It is no longer relevant.  I will remove it from the to-do-list.''' 
 
* Review plans for May ballot
 
* Review plans for May ballot
 
**  Status of the submission of the Notification of Intent to Ballot Form - Galen
 
**  Status of the submission of the Notification of Intent to Ballot Form - Galen
Line 99: Line 110:
 
**** Tool that takes the BMM patterns and produces FHIR profiles [Richard, Michael van der Zel]
 
**** Tool that takes the BMM patterns and produces FHIR profiles [Richard, Michael van der Zel]
 
**** Ken Lord MDMI tool – Steve and Richard to follow up
 
**** Ken Lord MDMI tool – Steve and Richard to follow up
−
* Wiki and website issues
+
* Review proposed changes to the model – Claude, Galen
−
** Mayo wiki  HL7 wiki migration
+
** '''The group reviewed models for PatientRelatedEducation, Procedures, SurgicalProcedure, Encounter, and encounter related models.'''
−
*** http://informatics.mayo.edu/CIMI/index.php/Main_Page#CIMI_Models
+
** '''It was suggested that we adopt the FHIM representation of Encounters, as for expert review, and focus our attention on clinical data where we can have the greatest impact.'''
−
*** '''We should be able to migrate the Mayo wiki content directly into the HL7 wiki
 
−
** Status of www.opencimi.org website
 
−
*** Who manages the website? How can content be updated, Should we use or link to the HL7 website?
 
−
**** '''Porta Vita has voluntarily maintained the opencimi website for us'''
 
−
**** '''We own the opencimi DNS, Joey can make subdomains as needed, and people can control their own subdomains'''
 
−
**** It would be helpful to post “work in progress” models where they are visible.
 
−
**** '''Claude will work with Patrick to see if we could add new content to the current CIMI Browser. '''
 
−
** Look, feel and content of restructured HL7 Wiki
 
−
*** http://wiki.hl7.org/index.php?title=Clinical_Information_Modeling_Initiative_Work_Group
 
−
* Mindmaps from Steve Hufnagel
 
−
** '''We will consider how these or other representations might be used in the ballot material to make the model as understandable as possible. '''
 
−
*  Posting models to opencimi.org
 
−
* Additional changes to the model – Claude
 
 
* Review of updated assertion/evaluation table content - Stan
 
* Review of updated assertion/evaluation table content - Stan
 
* Future topics
 
* Future topics
Line 131: Line 129:
 
** Others?
 
** Others?
 
* Any other business
 
* Any other business
−
 
−
 
−
= Plan and Schedule =
 
−
 
−
 
−
[[file: CIMI2017-02-09Plan&Schedule.jpg|none|900px|Plan and Schedule]]
 
−
 
  
 
= Annotated Figures =
 
= Annotated Figures =
Line 146: Line 137:
  
  
−
[[file: CIMI2017-02-09ProposedFocalAssertion.jpg|none|900px|Proposed Focal Assertion Class]]
+
[[file: CIMI2017-02-16-01-DataStructure_Patient_Education.jpg|none|900px|DataStructure_Patient_Education]]
  
−
* '''Claude:''' Changes to the Assertion Model
 
−
** Focal Assertion specialization helps reduce the size of Assertion by specifying Body Location
 
−
** This is a '''"Design by Extension"''', which is preferred in object-oriented programming
 
−
** Another Base Assertion specialization is Device, which may have different attributes than other types of Assertions
 
−
* '''Stan:''' This Focal Assertion Model approach encourages post-coordination
 
−
** Name: fracture
 
−
** Body Location: femur
 
−
** pattern suitable for lacerations, ulcers, etc.
 
−
** previous Assertion model's name field will have redundant information or pre-coordinated concepts.
 
−
* '''Steve's Mind Map (below):''' includes the femur example's preferred post-coordinated and alternative pre-coordinated representations based-on Stan's Example Spread Sheet
 
−
** [[Media: CIMI2017-02-03UpdatedModelOptions-Examples-StanHuff.xlsx]]
 
  
 +
[[file: CIMI2017-02-16-02-DataStructure_Clinical_Statement_Topic.jpg|none|900px|DataStructure_Clinical_Statement_Topic]]
  
  
−
[[file: CIMI2017-02-09-01_DCM_Context.jpg|none|900px|DCM-context Mind-Map]]
+
[[file: CIMI2017-02-16-03_DataStructure_Encounter.jpg|none|900px|DataStructure_Encounter]]
  
  
−
[[file: CIMI2017-02-09ProposesFocalAssertion MM.jpg|none|900px|Proposed Focal Assertion Class Mind Map]]
 
  
 +
[[file: CIMI2017-02-16-04-DataStructure_Pharmacy.jpg|none|900px|DataStructure_Pharmacy]]
  
−
[[file: CIMI2017-02-09MindMapLegend.jpg|none|900px|Mind Map Legend]]
+
= PC Requirements for Skin-Wound DCM =
  
−
= PC Requirements for Skin-Wound DCM =
 
  
 
* '''2917-02-09-1000 ET Patient Care Workgroup Telecom'''
 
* '''2917-02-09-1000 ET Patient Care Workgroup Telecom'''
Line 186: Line 166:
 
### Data-Element and Value-Set Spreadsheet
 
### Data-Element and Value-Set Spreadsheet
 
## Mar 8: Presented at LOINC conference by Susan
 
## Mar 8: Presented at LOINC conference by Susan
−
 
  
  

Latest revision as of 20:06, 2 March 2017

<<< Under Construction - Approval: TBD >>>
  • 2017 Minutes: http://wiki.hl7.org/index.php?title=CIMI_Minutes
  • Screen Sharing & Telecom Information: IHTSDO has generously provided a GoToMeeting connection for CIMI use.
  • Co-Chairs: Stan Huff, Linda Bird, Galen Mulrooney, Richard Esmond; where, quorum requires 2 co-chairs
  • REQUESTED ACTION: Directly edit this WIKI page or send your feedback to CIMI@lists.HL7.org with your comments, questions, suggested updates.


Attendees

Linda Bird, Bruce Bray, Linda Buhl, Joey Coyle, Gary Dickinson, John Donally, Richard Esmond, Bret Heale, Stan Huff, Steve Hufnagel, Mark Kramer, Patrick Langford, Jay Lyle, Chris Macintosh, Susan Matney, Chris Melo, Galen Mulrooney, Claude Nanjo, Brian Pech Craig Parker, Serafina Versaggi.

Highlighted names were in attendance.


Executive Summary

  1. Galen reported inability to enter CIMI's Intent to Ballot
    1. 2017-02-16 Action-01 (Galen): Notify Lydia and
    2. find a way to Submit Notification of Intent to Ballot
  2. Susan presented PC DCM requirements for PC Wound Assessment Project
  3. Richard leading STAMP task-force
  4. Patrick demonstrated OpenCimi Mind Maps http://www.opencimi.org/model-browser
    1. Action-02 (CIMI WG:) Review Browser & Provide feedback to Patrick
    2. Action 03 (Patrick): add model inheritance hierarchy
  5. Joey demonstrated OpenCEMs hierarchy capability http://www.opencem.org/#/
  6. Gallen reported inability to enter CIMI's intent to ballot (deadline Sunday)
  7. Claude presented proposed Patirnt Education structure.
  8. Claude presented proposed Statement Topic for Procedure
    1. Surgical Procedure
    2. Laboratory Procedure
  9. Claude presented proposed structure for Encounter


Minutes (Annotated Agenda)

  • Scribe: Stan.Huff@imail.org
  • REQUESTED ACTION: Update wiki directly or send suggested changes to Scribe or cimi@lists.hl7.org
  • Bolded Items were discussed/annotated to the agenda


  • Record this call
  • Agenda review
  • Review/Approval of Feb 9 minutes and Action Items
  • Updates on active projects (standing item)
    • Skin and wound assessments – Jay and Susan
    • Susan explained a UML style diagram of the skin assessment classes.
    • FHIM – CIMI integration – Galen
    • Harmonization of CIMI and FHIR datatypes - Richard
    • Graph/STAMP modeling paradigm – Richard
      • Rob McClure has been invited to participate
    • Conversion of CIMI archetypes to FHIR logical models to FHIR profiles – Claude
    • BMM parsing and serialization code – Claude
    • Creating ADL models from CEMs – Joey
    • LOKI – Patrick
    • CIMI Website – Patrick
      • Patrick has compiled all of the models from the recent HL7 ballot and made them viewable in the CIMI browser. It was very nicely done.
      • Folks suggested the addition of a view that would show the derivation hierarchy for the models, and other enhancements.
    • Conclusions from the CIMI FHIM Task Force – Stan Huff
      • Stan will update the document based on previous discussion, and bring the document back for review and approval in a few weeks (still not done)
      • As noted by Stephen Hufnagel, this item has been overtaken by events. It is no longer relevant. I will remove it from the to-do-list.
  • Review plans for May ballot
    • Status of the submission of the Notification of Intent to Ballot Form - Galen
    • Work plan
      • 3/26 pub date
      • 3/1 full content draft
      • 3/10 content done
      • 3/14 docs done: to Patrick for editing
    • Ballot content (top priorities)
      • Modeling content [Claude, Galen]
        • Claude and Galen will meet and make a prioritized list and figure out how far they can reach down the list
          • Claude and Galen did not get a chance to meet
          • Will try to meet soon
        • Skin and wound assessments – plans are in place
        • Quality measure – Jay and Claude to meet tomorrow, then reach out to Ken Kawamoto and Floyd Eisenberg
        • Skin and wound assessment quality measure use case
      • Documentation [Patrick, Editor]
        • Documents created and edited on Google Docs, and then published to the wiki
        • Overview/marketing pitch [Stan, Jay, Claude, Steve, Nona, Ask Laura]
        • Updated and fleshed out style guide [Susan, Jay, Steve]
        • Architecture guide [Claude]
          • Holding off until the architecture is more stable, then he will do a new version that incorporates all of the changes
        • Refine CIMI Process Definition for CIC #3 [Steve, Claude, Jay, Galen]
        • (Help to create documentation) Tool that reads a model and generates wiki pages (a document generation tool) [Michael van der Zel, Claude]
        • Tool that takes the BMM patterns and produces FHIR profiles [Richard, Michael van der Zel]
        • Ken Lord MDMI tool – Steve and Richard to follow up
  • Review proposed changes to the model – Claude, Galen
    • The group reviewed models for PatientRelatedEducation, Procedures, SurgicalProcedure, Encounter, and encounter related models.
    • It was suggested that we adopt the FHIM representation of Encounters, as for expert review, and focus our attention on clinical data where we can have the greatest impact.
  • Review of updated assertion/evaluation table content - Stan
  • Future topics
    • Loading of concepts into SOLOR – Susan Matney
    • Review CIMI Observation Result pattern - Stan
    • How will CIMI coordinate with DAF? - Claude
    • Granularity of models (schematic anchors) – from Richard
    • We need a way to identify the focal concept in indivisible and group statements
      • We would probably use the new metadata element
    • New principle: Don’t include static knowledge such as terminology classifications in the model: class of drug, invasiveness of procedure, etc.
    • Proposed policy that clusters are created in their own file – Joey, Stan
    • The role of openEHR-like templating in CIMI’s processes - Stan
    • IHTSDO work for binding SNOMED CT to FHIR resources – Linda, Harold
    • Which openEHR archetypes should we consider converting to CIMI models?
    • Transform of ICD-10 CM to CIMI models – Richard
    • Others?
  • Any other business

Annotated Figures

  • Scribe: Stephen.Hufnagel.HL7@gmail.com
  • REQUESTED ACTION: Directly edit this page or send suggested changes to scribe or cimi@lists.hl7.org


Error creating thumbnail: Unable to save thumbnail to destination


Error creating thumbnail: Unable to save thumbnail to destination


Error creating thumbnail: Unable to save thumbnail to destination


Error creating thumbnail: Unable to save thumbnail to destination

PC Requirements for Skin-Wound DCM

  • 2917-02-09-1000 ET Patient Care Workgroup Telecom
  • Attendees: Jay, Susan, Richard, Claude, Steve
  1. Skin Wound content & scope
    1. Braden
    2. Skin Assessment
    3. Wound Assessment, with Pressure Ulcer specialization
    4. No Skin Risk Assessment (out of scope)
  2. Schedule
    1. Feb 13: Requirements UML and Terminology spreadsheet finished
    2. Feb 13 to Mar 3 - VA verification and validation of spreadsheet
      1. Diagram
      2. Data-Element and Value-Set Spreadsheet
    3. Mar 8: Presented at LOINC conference by Susan


Skin Wound UML Requirements


Skin Wound Context Mind Map.jpg


Error creating thumbnail: Unable to save thumbnail to destination


Skin Wound Detail-2


Skin Wound Detail-3
Retrieved from "https://wiki.hl7.org/w/index.php?title=CIMI_Telecom_Minutes_2017-02-16&oldid=134983"