FHIR Infrastructure Minutes CC 20161017

FHIR Infrastructure Conference Call 3:00PM Eastern Time (Date above)

Return to FHIR Infrastructure Minutes

Attendees

• Ewout Kramer (chair)
• Lloyd McKenzie (scribe)
• Brian Nantz
• Eric Haas
• Joseph Quinn
• Josh Mandel
• Rienhard Egelkraut
• Richard Ettema
• Rick Geimer
• Rob Hausam
• Grahame Grieve
• Yunwei Wang

Block vote

As posted to the list last week:

• 11432 What is the perceived advantage of using a FHIR Service or Operation compared to a RESTful exchange (eg. Option A)? - 2016-09 core #590 (Paul Knapp) Considered - Question Answered

*8346 Allow read only resources in Bundle transaction (DSTU2) (Joel Costigliola) Not Persuasive
*10381 Additional comment text on codesystem.count to highlight usefulness (Brian Postlethwate) Not Persuasive
*11417 Why is VisionPrescription a request - 2016-09 core #575 (Paul Knapp) Not Persuasive
*11418 "Response" instead of "Event" - 2016-09 core #576 (Paul Knapp) Not Persuasive
*11420 Can Requests be updated? Can tasks be responded to with Tasks? - 2016-09 core #578 (Paul Knapp) Not Persuasive
*11423 Allow occurrence to be a Coding too. - 2016-09 core #581 (Paul Knapp) Not Persuasive
*12224 AggregationMode needs "external" (Lloyd McKenzie) Not Persuasive
*10539 Regex for FHIR Resource API (Harold Solbrig) Persuasive
*10560 profile-tag issue url link add (Xiao Luo) Persuasive
*10582 Update samples and documentation for StructureDefinition "baseDefinition" and "type" changes (Sean McIlvenna) Persuasive
*10594 StructureDefinition's schematron eld-12 is incorrect for valueSetReference (Sean McIlvenna) Persuasive
*10596 The values of kind do not include 'software' (Richard Townley-O'Neill) Persuasive
*10637 Duplicate concept map for Address Use from FHIR to v3 (Brian Postlethwate) Persuasive
*10644 Is-modifier section doesn't specify which element is being discussed in the example (Michelle Miller) Persuasive
*10649 Fix definition of ElementDefinition.name (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive
*10651 Remove the bung loinc answer list code systems (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive
*10657 Update validations pages for changes to tooling (Grahame Grieve) Persuasive
*10678 Conformance needs to identify supported Conformance statements (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive In Person
*10680 Don't be REST-specific (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive In Person
*10686 Harmonize metadata for knowledge artifacts (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive In Person
*10703 'performance of a task' phrase (Zoran Milosevic) Persuasive
*10722 Add all workflow diagrams (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive
*10734 Diagnostic module intro text references "CT" genetics test. (Elliot Silver) Persuasive
*10735 Conflicting information/use of BodySite (Elliot Silver) Persuasive
*10754 valueset-bundle-type - collection definition (Brett Marquard) Persuasive
*10909 Narrative text should allow and tags (Lee Surprenant) Persuasive
*10975 Add missing reference to 'string' and remove reference to other data types for DataElement language extensions - 2016-09 sdc #38 (Chris Hills) Persuasive
*11034 use/mention: sounds like a tech spec - 2016-09 core #53 (Jay Lyle) Persuasive
*11085 Example query doesn't make sense - 2016-09 core #166 (Chris Moesel) Persuasive
*11094 Make hyperlink include "Request pattern" - 2016-09 core #175 (Michelle Miller) Persuasive
*11095 Make hyperlink include "Event pattern" - 2016-09 core #176 (Michelle Miller) Persuasive
*11096 Make hyperlink include "Definition pattern" - 2016-09 core #177 (Michelle Miller) Persuasive
*11149 Proposal to remove the event2 group of the workflow section on the resource list page and to rename the event1 group. - 2016-09 core #303 (Reinhard Egelkraut) Persuasive
*11253 negative-major is no longer a vote type. - 2016-09 core #407 (Brian Scheller) Persuasive
*11256 RDF has been added as a supported format and there are 110 current resources in the 1.6.0 specification. - 2016-09 core #410 (Brian Scheller) Persuasive
*11257 Clarify example - 2016-09 core #411 (Brian Scheller) Persuasive
*11273 Text description and example resource don't jive - 2016-09 core #427 (Brian Scheller) Persuasive
*11327 Avoid using PHR term for a patient's record in an EMR - 2016-09 core #485 (David Tao) Persuasive
*11329 Foundation module definition incomplete - 2016-09 core #487 (David Tao) Persuasive
*11330 Number of FHIR exchange paradigms - 2016-09 core #488 (David Tao) Persuasive
*11429 Use the term "pick Task" rather than "claim Task" - 2016-09 core #587 (Paul Knapp) Persuasive
*11430 There are a variety of in-use organizational and jurisdictional communication infrastructures, not just v2. - 2016-09 core #588 (Paul Knapp) Persuasive
*11433 Why are options focused on fulfillment, not status changes? - 2016-09 core #591 (Paul Knapp) Persuasive
*11435 Change "intermediary" to "queue server" or some other term - 2016-09 core #593 (Paul Knapp) Persuasive
*11453 Fix bullet list showing what to look at - 2016-09 core #615 (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive
*11460 How does a StructureDefinition refine the contents of a value set? - 2016-09 core #624 (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive
*11461 StructureDefinitions constrain data types too - 2016-09 core #625 (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive
*11464 DataElement isn't mature - 2016-09 core #628 (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive
*12055 Should "Value.url" be "ValueSet.url"? (Richard Townley-O'Neill) Persuasive
*12070 Clarify wording around POST bodies for operations (Michael Lawley) Persuasive
*12142 TestScript assert response, responseCode elements should be constrained as empty when direction = request (Richard Ettema) Persuasive
*12144 Provide a profile or explanation for event history using Provenance (Jenni Syed) Persuasive
*12147 Harmonize conformance resource metadata (Lloyd McKenzie) Persuasive
*12164 A new page to list the artifacts each workgroup is allocated, and the FMM level of each resource. (Brian Postlethwate) Persuasive
*12179 Update build snapshot to inherit constraints (Chris Grenz) Persuasive
*12180 Update build to correct base.path (Chris Grenz) Persuasive
*12181 Change elementdefinition.name to sliceName (Chris Grenz) Persuasive
*12182 element.id format and location (Chris Grenz) Persuasive
*12184 Poor grammar in bundle reference resolution (Vadim Peretokin) Persuasive
*12228 StructureDefinition schematron rule eld-12 is wrong (both) (Sarah Gaunt) Persuasive
*12250 duplicate text in introduction and 'Scope and Usage' Section (Eric Haas) Persuasive
*12254 edits to _Request.status comments (Eric Haas) Persuasive
*10527 Key to Type Icons and Flags is incorrect for Data Type and Primitive Data Type (Richard Townley-O'Neill) Persuasive with Mod
*11216 not a good sentence - is this what is meant? - 2016-09 core #370 (Riki Merrick) Persuasive with Mod
*11258 Is there a missing location header? - 2016-09 core #412 (Brian Scheller) Persuasive with Mod
*12149 value for the kind property value for defined extension not correct (David Hay) Persuasive with Mod

• Request to exclude the following (as per Paul Knapp)
  • 11432
  • 11417
  • 11420
  • 11423
  • 11434

Block vote: Grahame Grieve/Josh Mandel - 8-0-3

Tracker item

• 12205 - Not Persuasive w/ Mod
• 12148 - Tabled for later discussion

Brett Marquard joins

• Revied DAF Research NIB
• Lloyd abstains due to potential conflict
• Brett Marquard/Rick Geimer: 11-0-1

Brett Marquard leaves

• 12068 - Waiting for Input - Chris G.

Brian Nantz, Yunwei Wang, Rienhard Egelkraut leave

• 9972 - Persuasive
• 10654 - Persuasive
• 10666 - Retracted by Grahame
• 12245 - Persuasive

Josh leaves

• 12063 - Not persuasive w/ Mod
• 12242 - Tabled