HarmonizationSummary-20110712

Harmonization Review Summary (date in title)

Change only the right-most three columns. The left is auto-generated from the Harmonization spreadsheet

Item #	Work Group	Proposal Name	Partial Description	Proposal ID	Notes	Result	Vote
010101	DSS	New ActCode concepts	Add eight concepts to the ActCode code system under the _ActTaskCode head concept.	CDSWG_JUL_2011	Appears complete and consistent with the existing ""parent"" codes. Note that the ""dots"" preceding the code terms are NOT part of the term, but appear to have been used to establish the hierarchy in some previous document.	result	^-v-?
010104	MNM	Update HL7 Tables HL7StandardVersionCode and HL7 Version	HL7StandardVersionCode is supposed to hold an identifier for each HL7 Ballot cycle and each Normative Edition. Add codes to make it complete through 2012 ; Remove table HL7 Version Identifiers which i	InM-CA201107-03	The title is incorrect and not related to the contents. The contents are correct, but incomplete. I am bringing up a separately defined ""Techical Update"" as the item 010301 with the same content plus more..	result	^-v-?
010105	MNM	Update HL7 Tables HL7StandardVersionCode and HL7 Version	HL7StandardVersionCode is supposed to hold an identifier for each HL7 Ballot cycle and each Normative Edition. Add codes to make it complete through 2012 ; Remove table HL7 Version Identifiers which i	MM-UV201107-01	Proposed Technical Update (correction) to add missing codes to a ""prof orma"" CodeSystem that identifies HL7 publication packages for V3.	Withdrawn - Duplkicate to one above.	^-v-?
010107	INM	Add codes to ObservationType_ISSUE	Add new concepts to support implementations.	InM-CA201107-04	Seems Complete and would be betrter under the title for the preceding. Note that in the itemixed list there is 5. Add leaf concept under ObservationType_VALIDAT This should read 5. Add leaf concept under ActCode VALIDAT	result	^-v-?
010110	INM	Add concept domain	Add concept domain for existing value set.	MnM-CA201107-01	Appears to be complete and correct.	result	^-v-?
010113	INM	New ControlAct concept domain and codes	Add a concept domain to allow specify why a specific transaction which was requested to be undone, was not undone.	MnM-CA201107-02	Appears complete and correct. Might question the requested UV binding.	result	^-v-?
010116	PAFM	ServiceDeliveryLocation domains and codes	Define a variety of location concept domains, value sets and bindings to help express information about service delivery locations.	PA-CA201107-01	Appears to be complete, but it would appear this will lead to a good buit of discussion. (item one seems to conflate disjoint concepts) Also, it is really two proposals - itmes 1 & 2 are in ActCode space, while rest are in RoleCode space.	result	^-v-?
010119	PAFM	AdministrativeContactRoleType changes	Add a concept domain for an existing value set to allow for context binding to different realms.	PA-CA201108-02	Appears to be complete and correct.	result	^-v-?
010201	ORDERS	Add Microbio concept domains	Add concept domains to accompany the microbiology model template being developed for ballot.	OO-CA201107-01	Appears to be complete and correct. The parent indicates that it is ConceptualSpaceForClassCode: ActClass.OBS. Is there any need to replicate these to the children?	result	^-v-?
010204	ORDERS	Lab concept domains	Update EntityRisk concept domain definition and add new lab concept domain.	OO-CA201107-02	Appears to be complete and correct.	result	^-v-?
010207	ORDERS	New lab concept domain	Add concept domains to allow describing lab orders referred or redirected, as well as capturing reportable test destination.	OO-CA201107-03	Appears to be complete. The concept domain names would appear to need an indication as to what conceptual space the qualify - Act? Role? Entity?	result	^-v-?
010210	MEDREC	Add Concept domains and definition	Add a definition for OrderableDrugForm concept domain, and create one concept domain for alignment with ISO IDMP document.	PHARM-CA201107-01	Appears to be complete and correct.	result	^-v-?
010213	MEDREC	Add concept to MedicationGeneralizationRoleType	Add therapeutic class to hierarchical definition of drugs (MedicationGeneralizationRoleType), and a technical correction to the MedicationGeneralizationRoleType value set definition.	PHARM-CA201107-02	Appears to be complete and correct.	result	^-v-?
010216	MEDREC	New domain SubstanceAdministrationType	Create concept domain SubstanceAdministrationType to allow for comprehensive drug information be captured.	PHARM-CA201107-03	Appears to be complete, but the name is misleading. It suggests kinds of SubstAdmin, where at is is kinds of SubstAdmin-related concepts. (an information type??).	result	^-v-?
010219	MEDREC	Add concepts to QueryParameterValue	Add concepts to QueryParameterValue to manage view of returned records.	PHARM-CA201107-04	Appears to be complete, but the new codes DO NOT appear to be consistent with existing leaf codes with the same parent. Does there need to be an intermediary abstraction? See the differences in the definitions of the old and proposed codes. Further, the existing abstract parent code seems wrong. Should it really have been under a totally different abstract parent?	result	^-v-?